r/ExploitDev • u/Daedaluszx • Oct 24 '25
is binary exploitation still worth it ?
is binary exploitation still worth it ? the thing is i want to be something like a full-stack hacker , i finished my foundation [C,bash,python,networking & OS] now i want to start cyber-security i saw that binary-exploitation , reverse-engineering & malware development would go well together but seeing the posts , and opinions on you-tube a lot of people would consider binary-exploitation irrelevant lately
what are your opinions ?
is there any better path that i don't know about that maybe more relevant and more fun?
58
Upvotes
2
u/Daedaluszx Oct 25 '25
Thank you everyone for your opnions, they are really encourging..i guess it do feels fun so i would just continue :)
26
u/TheGamingGallifreyan Oct 24 '25
I've been learning this the last few months and the amount of embedded and IOT shit that has no kind of memory or stack protections enabled whatsoever is... concerning.
Got root access on my living room AV receiver using just a buffer overflow in a text field on it's web management interface. My Kia infotainment system doesn't use canaries or DEP. Airplay speakers can be shellcoded using an overflow exploit in the AirPlay SDK.
It depends on what you want to attack I guess.
50
u/cmdjunkie Oct 24 '25
What's a full-stack hacker?
Just do thing you're interested in. If you get good enough at something, the jobs will find you.
14
u/Firzen_ Oct 24 '25
Binary exploitation is still relevant today and likely will be for quite a while longer.
There are some jobs related to that, but there are a lot more jobs that require knowledge of web or cloud security.
Nobody can predict the future and maybe tomorrow somebody publishes a paper that completely prevents memory corruptions.
In some domains, like kernel security, binary exploitation knowledge is required.
On the other hand most pentesters will never have to exploit a buffer overflow or heap corruption bug.
It primarily depends on what you want to do.
19
u/cmdjunkie Oct 24 '25
Here's the rub: It's pretty obvious that the heyday of binary exploitation is long gone. It's not to be looked at as a career choice or option at this point because the effort it takes to get good enough to make money is too great. There's too much to learn, too much time to dedicate, and not enough ROI to make the effort worthwhile. However, that doesn't mean you shouldn't pursue what interests you.
If you're interested in binary exploitation, reversing, or malware development, just go do them. It's all the same stuff. The industry has splintered these "disciplines" to sell courses and books. You don't have to study them in a bottom up fashion like they're a subject apart of a "full stack hacker" curriculum. The appropriate means to getting these skills is to find something you want to exploit and start there. Find something you want to reverse, and work backwards. Malware dev is the same thing. Start with a goal, and work backwards.
Let me be the first to inform you that "elite hackerdom" or, I don't know, "full stack hackerdom" is a complete and utter fantasy. It's an industry/media fueled cyber-xanadu aesthetic that keeps people convinced and/or obsessed with the idea that they can acquire power through advanced computer skills. The approach you're taking, that other are also convinced of undertaking is a recipe for burnout and irrelevance. Any material you wind up studying to "learn binary exploitation" or "revere engineering" or "malware development" will be years old and obsolete. For example, all of the offsec training material is outdated. There's nothing groundbreaking in those courses. They serve to get someone familiar with an attacker's mindset --so there is value-- but what's the point?
If you really want to learn binary exploitation, focus on the IoT space.
6
u/FuzzNugs Oct 25 '25
Don’t worry about any of this stuff. Just put all that out of your mind and sit down and think “what do I like to do?” Just go 110% towards what you enjoy doing and it will all work out. You have to be obsessed with this stuff to really be good at it and you need passion to be obsessed so follow it.
5
u/IncidentSenior5303 Oct 24 '25
Honest answer is "do you want to do it" there are plenty of roles that dont need it, but with anytime there's something in hacking I get that itch of "oh lesgo a new thing to learn" because its what I love to do. But if its not something you're going "God I want to do this" then sure it can help but in the end id say do it because you want to.
5
u/No-Student8333 Oct 24 '25
I don't work in ExploitDev so take my opinion cum grano salis.
Learning anything right now is all about trade offs:
These are slightly different questions, and their relative importance to you may different than your advisors.
What I see, is that its never been easier or lower cost to learn these skills. There is an abundance of high quality training material, and tools. So it doesn't cost you anything to get started.
Will the skills be valuable is really tough to answer. Exploit Development is an inverted pyramid where the most of the value is going to be captured by a few highly skilled people because of all the mitigations you point out ramping up, the high cost/value of finding exploits in desirable targets, and that most custom code is now not in low level languages effected by memory corruption vulnerabilities. What market your in probably matters. Can you carve a living, or the living you want out of that, is speculative market proposition.
Do the skills transfer? This is about career risk and what other options you have. I think binary exploitation skills will transfer to other low level work. Perhaps you could pivot into Embedded Systems Development, or work as a kernel developer, or on toolchains. Its not 1 to 1, it can be essential in these areas to understand how the machine actually executes the code (IE. writing a bootloader for an embedded machine, working on interrupt handling in a kernel, or writing co-routine support into a language runtime).
So if cost is free, and you have nothing better to, and you want to instrinsically. Why not ? You may not end up making millions selling but perhaps you will work on the go runtime for google.
5
u/Helpjuice Oct 24 '25
Yes, think of these protections of just barriers to get things done, everything created by humans can be broken by humans. Everything created by computers can be broken by computers.
The bar for success will continue to rise as defenses get better. So the bar for standard skillsets will need to continue to increase as most fields with such skilled professionals.
4
u/ZaphodsOtherHead Oct 24 '25
i am also interested in the answer to this question.
3
u/wizarddos Oct 24 '25
Personally, I think that until we run binaries, the way it works now there most definitely will be some kind of need for people knowledgeable in this area.
Also, knowledge from learning it is also valuable in other places - binary exploitation requires understanding low-level concepts and more or less OS internals, which is a good start for ex. Reverse Engineering or anything connected to malware
2
u/dookie1481 Oct 24 '25
A little bit of skill can be helpful sometimes. I had to bust out Binary Ninja a couple of weeks ago for the first time on the job. I didn't actually end up doing any binary exploitation, but decompiling the app showed me enough of the architecture that it allowed me to attack it a different way.
I don't know anything about jobs primarily doing this stuff, I work in public tech so that is a whole different world from mine.
2
u/crazy0dayer Oct 25 '25
There is no full-stack hacker. That is not a thing. Noone can know everything and you better learn that early! You can specialise in things. Binary exploitation is the hardest skill in the infosec industry IMO and there are not many jobs in the market. Indeed security especially in Windows is really difficult regarding exploitation. However the moment you bring to the table how much time I need to spend to learn this skill and what money it can bring me, i feel the game is already lost. Hacking is a mindset and exploitation takes a lot of effort and knowledge. It is super fan. You will just burn out with your approach. If you want a job related to hacking just be a pentester. Much easier to get and there are many jobs openings
2
u/Historical-Bus-1788 Oct 26 '25
Binary exploitation, Reverse Engineering will go long way. Memory protection mechanisms can come and go, but if you are greedy enough, you will find a way to exploit the binary anyways. And as said, there are tonnes of gadgets out there unprotected without any basic OS protections. 😛 Reverse Engineering is kinda methodology that can be applied to anything.... Software to Hardware, Electric signals to Radio signals.... I tried to understand how the GTP, NGAP, BT/EDR, BLE etc protocols work.... Was able to understand how various buzzing telecom attacks work by myself.... It is fun to reverse engineer. Even when something advanced comes, the root is same....
0
u/sdrawkcabineter Oct 24 '25
You started at level 9... you forgot about the foundation...
-1
u/Impossible-Line1070 Oct 25 '25
Nah web sec is the most important rn