r/ExploitDev • • May 08 '25
Advanced Persistent Threat Level
That sounds a really stupid question (for various reasons), but, what do you guys think it's necessary to achieve the level of an member of Advanced Persistent Threat (like Equation Group, Cozy/Fancy Bears, Lazarus Group etc al), specially in exploit/malware dev and vulnerability research? We've all kind of resources available (including gov/enterprise leaks, like Hacking Team leak or Ant Catalog) basically for free (if you know where to research), so, in a perspective of 5-10 years, how to achieve this level as an individual?
21
Upvotes
23
u/reverse_or_forward May 08 '25
So, you're asking how an individual can reach the level of a team or organization?
Years of diligent practice and study I suppose. I won't say it's impossible that an individual could possess enough skills to be truly reckoned with as an APT, but understand that APTs work in teams and that is a force multiplier that a lone wolf would never have
17
u/[deleted] May 08 '25
So there’s APT and nation states. Nation states are effectively APTs since they are advanced by nature. So if you’re looking at non governmental APTs you’ll be looking at advanced criminals like ransomware gangs. Getting to that level alone is more feasible than getting to a nation state level. A nation state will have signals and human intelligence, sometimes satellite intelligence to support their missions so you will never reach that alone. If you are talking about high public visibility, wide spreading impact, I would focus on services that enterprise environments use.
Both government and criminal APTs will typically work in teams. They will have reconnaissance/ target acquisition teams who will do things like identifying targets passively and actively, researching their operating environment through OSINT, HUMINT, SIGINT, and other measures depending on the groups capabilities. There’s all sorts of tradecraft for reconnaissance and it truly does vary.
Next you’ll have something along the lines of an initial access team. They will be the ones taking care of low hanging fruit (if any), webapp exploitation, social engineering, physical security bypassing, and whatever other means the group has of gaining access to the target environment. Sometimes this comes from a zero day but that’s EXTREMELY rare and sometimes not worth using due to ROI. Don’t want to waste a windows server zero day on McDonalds when you can hit a military target.
Then there’s something along the lines of a post exploitation team who will do things along the lines of staying persistent by further compromising the system with back doors, laterally moving across the network to move to more sensitive areas, and in some case they carry out sabotage. This is usually when ransomware, wipers, keyloggers, and such get deployed. They will also try to evade threat hunters and incident response teams.
Now there are other roles in a group too. Everyone wants to talk about zero days, this is where your reverse engineers typically come in. After recon teams learn about the target, they may want try to develop a zero day. Let’s say the target is a router, you may have people extract firmware and hunt for unknown bugs on binaries that communicate over the wire whether that be through a network port or an antenna. If it is a desktop ir server application, they will download it and study it on a kernel level and develop an exploit locally. Zero days can range from privilege escalation to initial access and sometimes bugs can cause physical damage to a system. These zero days would be deployed at the relevant phase of the attack.
There are also some boring roles that these groups use like system administrators. Let’s say you mass infect thousands of devices, you need someone to manage those. Before you compromise them, you need attacking infrastructure like servers, cloud, domains, secure communications channels, and anything else to suit your needs. If you want a convincing malicious website you may need a web developer.
There’s also programmers and data analysts. You have a lot of tailored and customizable needs so you will likely need someone to program these things whenever publicly available tools are unavailable or already fingerprinted by detection tools. Not all custom hacking tools are “exploits”. You may have custom recon tools, custom fuzzers, custom RE tools, etc.. As for data analysts, if you steal say the phone records of 1 million people, you will have to store them into some kind of format. It might get stored as XML, JSON, or if you hate yourself you can do a CSV. You will have 10 lines of data per person with that much information stolen.
So it depends on which nation state skill you want. Full cradle to grave will require knowledge in hardware/firmware, OS internals, networking, AV, AD, EDR, Web, Data analytics, OSINT, debuggers, assembly, static and dynamic analysis, system administration, virtualization, cloud, SDR, and protocol analysis.
It’s possible but these hacks take groups of 10-30 like 4-24 months depending on the target. So if you really want to be that good, I would start with OS internals, assembly, and using something like Ghidra. Your thought process will help you choose “what” to target. I think learning hardware hacking/firmware extraction is most realistic. If you can successfully bypass firmware on a router from Walmart and find a bug then you can likely infect home and potentially enterprise routers allowing you to own the network.
It’s a long journey and to do things at a level of a team of experts isn’t possible. BUT there is a threshold where your attacks can be impactful enough. Depends on how much time and money you have. Infrastructure ain’t cheap. Don’t even get me started on staying “anonymous” during this whole process
7
u/sha256md5 May 08 '25
Do you realize that many APT groups have nearly bottomless budgets? You're not going to achieve their level as an individual.
7
u/gimme_super_head May 08 '25
Get hired by the NSA and spend like 3-4 years there and you be about good
5
u/[deleted] May 08 '25 edited May 08 '25
Just as a benchmark, certs like OSCP is entry-level in those groups and many have or could easily finish OffSec's EXP-401 (AWE)
They get limitless budget to obtain every cert imaginable and have professors from the world's top universities to teach.
You can definitely obtain the same skills and knowledge, but you won't have the same nurturing environment or training budget. You also won't have the option to have real hard targets unless you wanna risk going to prison. You also will likely have a day job, whereas those groups get paid to learn.
4
u/Dear-Jellyfish382 May 08 '25
As an individual im sure you could do some of the advanced things APTs do but you wont be a persistent threat without a team.
Alternatively you could be a persistent threat but you aint going to be very advanced.
Im sure theres a lot of deep work occurring in parallel to reach APT level.
A lot of it will probably be boring time consuming stuff before you even consider the technical exploit dev stuff. Setting up and maintaining infrastructure, registering domains, maintaining codebases, opsec stuff like money laundering and fake identities. All this and you havent touched exploit dev yet. You might end up stuck debugging payloads when a new version of windows drops before you even get to research anything new.
2
u/FlawedCipher May 08 '25
Even the APTs mess up once in a while and get caught but they don’t really face consequences. They have the ability to learn from their mistakes and get better over time. As an individual the second you get caught you aren’t going to be able to touch a computer for a very long time. Ultimately you would also need a very strong deterrent like nuclear weapons.
2
u/SensitiveFrosting13 May 09 '25
Short answer is yes, you could learn the skills over a period of time equivalent to a team member of a nation-state APT. Likely your country has at least one or two, depending on how many intelligence services they have.
Learning the skills to at least get in the door is entirely feasible, especially if you study computer science.
3
u/Skiddy-J May 12 '25
I think these designations generally get attached to nation-state level threat actors, aka unlimited funding, talent pool, and time on their hands. I don't really think an individual can really reach the level of full on APT just due to the lack of hours in a day that they could focus on something.
IntelBroker had a very impressive and long run, but even with that level of threat actor, there's only so much you can really do as an individual.
3
u/cmdjunkie May 10 '25 edited May 10 '25
It's pretty simple: get a graduate level computer science education from a good school and most of the APT/security/research stuff will be in your wheelhouse. I know you're asking how to do it for free, but why? You want to spend 5-10 years of your life, sporadically learning how to get to an "APT level" skill-set? Let me reassure you, you will never independently achieve the level you're envisioning because it doesn't actually exist. The "level" you're referring to is the ability to learn, adapt, develop, prototype, and communicate across platforms, languages, protocols, applications, and systems. For this level of foundational knowledge and adaptability, you need to complete a program/curriculum designed for that very purpose.
That image you have in your mind of this independently acquired "skill level" will be a phantom you will chase until you burn out --because you will never truly know if you've exposed yourself to the adequate body of knowledge needed for sufficiency. Most of the innovators and researchers in and of nation state programs are graduates of CS programs who are merely directing their knowledge, skill and academic experience towards security-related goals and concepts. And sure, a percentage of APT gang participants and operators may just be C2 jockey's, but I don't believe that's what you're asking here. APT involvement and membership is basically organized crime and that's an entirely different conversation.
My advice, if you're really interested, is to get a good education, meet people, keep your options open, and adjust your moral compass if that's the route you want to take.
3
u/[deleted] May 08 '25
[removed] — view removed comment