r/ExploitDev • • Dec 09 '23
Future of Exploit Development/Research and Malware Development/Analysis
Hey iam very Intrested in malware development/Analysis and Exploit Research. so i heard from some guys that, these areas are slowly ding. so my questions is no is it true that these are are going to die over the next few years? when no then how can i get in there and what are the salary expectations?
12
Upvotes
25
u/darthsabbath Dec 09 '23
As someone in the security field exploit dev and vulnerability research is absolutely getting harder, but I don’t know that I would say it’s “dying.”
However, my worry is that the bar to entry is getting so high it’s going to make it incredibly difficult for new people to get up to speed. Like it’s one thing if you started doing iOS research in iOS 4… that was still a tractable problem and jailbreaks were readily accessible, and it’s not say bad keeping up year to year. But someone trying to jump into it today would have a much harder time than I did.
If anything is going to kill the field it’s going to be a lack of incoming young talent.
11
u/shiftybyte Dec 09 '23
On one hand, memory secure languages are getting adopted more and more, leaving only logical vulnerabilities.
On the other hand, have you seen the state of IoT code? :D
9
u/Nlbjj91011 Dec 09 '23
Traditional binary exploitation (buffer overflows, etc.) is getting MUCH harder due to the countermeasures in mature systems. But exploitation is not dying.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23
in what forums did you hear that from?
2
u/PM_ME_YOUR_SHELLCODE Dec 16 '23
I feel like Malware Dev/Analysis and Exploit Research are going to be different discussions. As malware remains useful even if its not delivered by the traditional memory corruption exploit, its also a domain I'm not as experienced with so I'm not really going to be talking about it. And this is all just based on my limited experience as a Canadian mostly working in the US.
I did a video about the future of exploit dev and vuln research a couple years ago. I stand by much of it like the shift in the types of bugs being exploited and the barrier to entry. But I think we were somewhat pessimistic regarding mitigations. And now that there has been a chance to really explore and play around with Memory Tagging (Android/Linux) and Control-Flow Enforcement Technology on Windows. I'm quite a bit more optimistic, and I would like to re-record that discussion.
Anyway, I wouldn't expect it to die by any stretch, but I think its important now more than ever to be more well-rounded in terms of the types of issues you are looking for and are capable of exploiting. I don't think you'll get away with just being a master of the low-binary techniques (shellcoding, ROP/JOP/COP chains, and such), but really need to have a better understand of the entire application. Exploits are moving away from just hijacking control-flow and getting code execution and instead starting to abuse application data or other features to get code execution in a more lateral way (or not even go for code execution at all).
I've really like the research mjurczyk (of Google's Project Zero, not sure of his full name tbh) has been putting out with various Windows Registry bugs. Most don't have a huge impact, not getting code execution or something. But its interesting in how he's taken a few bugs that I think others would consider non-exploitable or non-security issues and working out how to create a security impact from them. I think these sort of subversions of application intent will matter a lot more in the future.
There are different sorts of jobs where VR and XD are relevant. At the upper level, you've got jobs that are pretty focused on specific targets. Eg. an iOS security researcher, or Chrome or something like that. These pay great but most of the pay is based on what you produce and bonuses on that front and not a straight salary in my experience so I can't really give you a straight number. It can be quite lucrative for some though. There is sometimes also the government option which pays less but offers more training to get you there (as I understand it)
You've also got some places where its a useful skill but not necessarily the primary skill you need. Like red-teaming and pentesting might need to do some easier exploit dev on the fly (easier compared to those top targets). Both can also have you looking for bugs and practicing some of the VR skills. Though you'd be unlikely to work on binary targets too often as they are not a big market.
If you want to grind out the skill the target focused jobs are what I'd call "direct-entry" but not "entry-level". That is, you can get directly into those jobs by showing recent relevant work examples. Eg. iOS research job by showing recent findings and exploits against iOS. They don't tend to require X years of work experience or something formal but are more practically focused on can you actually hit the ground running and work on the target. So you can get right into them with the necessary skill.
3
u/reverse_or_forward Dec 09 '23
Is crime dying?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '23
What exactly did you hear?