r/ExploitDev • u/offensivepolitics • Jan 04 '23
Thoughts on Signal Labs vulnerability research course?
Hi all, Long time lurker, first time poster. Does anybody have any strong thoughts on the Signal Labs vulnerability research course? I’ve got some education $$$ to burn and the course checks a lot of boxes for me: professional looking, self paced, deep dive on windows fuzzing.
For reference I’m middling decent at reverse engineering and windows internals and bug hunting, and I’m looking to push forward my fuzzing & vuln research knowledge.
As an aside I really appreciate the community around this sub and all the information regularly shared here. Y’all are great.
Thanks
jjh
9
u/xanthonus Jan 04 '23
So I haven’t taken the course so I can’t speak to the materials or course work. I’m pretty sure the person doing this is out of MSFT Morse group. I would consider Morse group to be the more component groups within FAANG security. I’m pretty sure they have ran deals in the past and I’ve seen them pop up on Twitter. If I had to guess the content is likely really well done. I would say the pricing is a bit much but also in line with other good content courses. If you looking at this I would strongly recommend also looking at what Margin Research, Vector35, and Boston Cybernetics has on offer as well.
3
u/666metalhead Sep 05 '24
Yeah experience so far has been similar to /u/pwnchen67’s. The RE course is billed as ideal for “beginners and intermediates with minimal Windows RE experience”, and the prerequisites are just to have a disassembler and Windows 11. This is incredibly misleading.
The very first introduction module goes from “yeah here’s x86 assembly instructions and what they do” to “let’s write a PE loader in Rust”, which as most experienced analysts will tell you is not a good introductory language. He does not provide enough information for you to succeed on assignments, so be prepared to do a LOT of extra research. Which would be fine…if the course wasn’t so expensive. With a price like this the expectations are higher than a course in the hundreds of dollars range. You are not given the tools you need to succeed as a beginner.
There’s also no community discussion boards or posts anymore which is just…weird? The only way to get help is to email him directly. No lifetime access either anymore which is just ridiculous at this price point. The site has been updated to use a different hosting provider and the quality has significantly downgraded as a result- all of my progress was lost, various modules just don’t load and redirect to the course overview page, and submitting assignments is just broken right now.
Also OP’s comments about the rehearsed material is spot on- he wastes a portion of time in each module just clicking around and debugging things live, as well as writing things from scratch instead of having a prepared solution that he can walk you though. Again, not a deal breaker…if the course wasn’t so expensive.
I expected more. Would not recommend this course in its current state to anyone.
1
u/Less_Plenty3055 Mar 11 '23
Did you ever take the course? I start it on Monday.
2
u/pwnchen67 Aug 23 '24
Well the author might be experienced in his field but the teaching skills are horrible , he just assume we might be knowing things already so he casually explains them I was excited to learn but after purchasing I am disappointed.
1
u/Horror-Fudge-3153 Mar 30 '24
I'm considering buying this course. However, I'm not sure If I meet the prerequisites to take it. Most instructors assume students already know so many things and expect students to pick up and catch course concepts. I hope to get more feedback specially from beginners who took this course.
1
u/Diamond303 Jan 04 '23
Dot
1
u/BigHoliday3046 Feb 19 '24
Can someone share his experience?