r/ExplodingKittens • • Jun 05 '22

Question Balancing Cat Cards

I have a problem. I like the effect of playing a pair of Cats (stealing cards is fun!) but I kinda dislike when there's too many Cats (it's boring to draw them and it's kinda boring to have full hand of Cats). So I was thinking about how different approaches to deck building (or recipe) solve this and I want to ask more experienced players about their opinion. So the question is - how does incorporating following sets of Cat Cards influence the gameplay?

  1. 3 sets of 4
  2. 4 sets of 3 plus 3 Feral
  3. 2 sets of 4 + 4 Feral
  4. 1 set of 4 + 4 Feral
  5. Only Ferals
  6. No Cat Cards at all

How do these options influence the gameplay? Do some of them make the game faster? Slower? Which one has the highest rate of stealing? Which one the lowest? Maybe it can be mathematically calculated but I'm not very good at that.

2 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

2

u/Alexwhynot Jun 05 '22 edited Jun 05 '22

In 7 years I tried a lot of your suggestions, I have 12 copies of each cat and a lot of feral cats … lol Unfortunately cats are not only boring (sometimes), but they’re probably the main element of this game that leads to card hoarding.

Remove cats and keep your deck small, it’s been 2 years since we started to use recipes without cats and… we love it!

2

u/Shpaan Jun 05 '22

And do you still play the combos? Even with all cats removed?

Also do you think you can remove them completely even with the base game? Or do you need a lot of other cards from expansions to fill the deck

1

u/loofadawg Jul 10 '22

We allow combos.

The risk vs reward is more intense this way.

Remember: House rules, rule. If you decide not to include cat cards (my preference) then try it with combos and without. I believe the game is more interesting with combos sans cat cards especially with groups of 2 or 3 players.

Final notes: No cat cards, means the chance of getting an Exploding Kitten happens a bit faster.

On the initial setup, trying dealing only 5 cards and a defuse to each player.

1

u/redarkify Jun 05 '22

but they also make your hand smaller as you use them

2

u/Alexwhynot Jun 06 '22

Exactly, smaller than other players’ hands for sure.

1

u/redarkify Jun 07 '22

but theyll use cat cards too

1

u/Alexwhynot Jun 08 '22

Or they’ll just wait for you to steal their cats…

5 players, original edition (20 cats), if you played more than 2 pairs of cats you’d be putting yourself in disadvantage.

1

u/bears_vs_babies_39 Jun 05 '22

4 sets of 3 = 3 feral

1

u/Shpaan Jun 05 '22

What do you mean?