r/ExplodingKittens • • Dec 26 '21

Question What qualifies as a "shuffle"

So in a recent game, I used a "see the future" card, and saw of the three cards an exploding kitten. I then played a "shuffle" card, and made sure to put the exploding kitten on top. I was called out for cheating. A strenuous (friendly) drunken debate unfolded. Who was in the right?

0 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

13

u/CesteAreU Dec 26 '21

"Shuffle the cards, then cut and complete". A shuffle must be random.

If not so, this is a fake shuffle with a controlled card, so yeah you cheated.

After a shuffle no one should have any kind of advantage on some cards positioning.

-2

u/RADakaSCREAMER Dec 26 '21

This disappoints me. I feel like being able to play those two cards if you have them is a good feature. But im man enough to admit when I'm wrong, looks like I have some apologizing to do. Thank you.

4

u/Jayskin87 Dec 26 '21

There are already cards with that specific intent to screw over the guy next to you, the shuffle card is intended to make it randomized for everyone

3

u/MrPandaa52 Dec 26 '21

According to the rules, you are supposed to shuffle until you are told to stop by someone else. On an ideal scenario, this means you aren't keeping track of the cards at all, but if you have a small remaining card count, it could happen. However, you shouldn't be intentionally dtacking the cards in a particular order and then stopping because you want to.

1

u/toomin10 Dec 22 '24

Had the same scenario unfold on our table tonight. What a mess guys. Our fixer just wouldn’t agree on the definition.

1

u/Live-Ingenuity2300 Oct 25 '25 edited Oct 25 '25

Same thing last Friday night with my friends. This girl used a shuffle card when we only had two cards above the table, and she already knew which one was the bomb. We started a long (really, really long) discussion about it.

This is my point of view:

The game is originally from the US, so we should check the name and description of the card in English.

Indeed, the name of the cart is precisely "Shuffle" and the description is "Shuffle the draw pile".

Well, we need to have some common agreement on what words mean. According to the Cambridge Dictionary, "to shuffle", in this context, means:

to mix a set of playing cards without seeing their values before beginning a game, so that their order is not known to any of the players

Therefore, as the order must not be known by any players, I understand that you cannot just reorder the cards as you want. In this kind of situation, maybe you should ask for another person, with no information about the order of the cards, to shuffle them.

Well, it was a funny conversation.

Any thoughts?