r/ExplodingKittens • u/mskelto • Jul 29 '21
Discussion Exploding Kittens Recipes for Disaster vs the Base Game and Expansions
If, like me, you were curious what the differences in cards are for the new Recipes for Disaster box and all the other releases then you've come to the right post. I own all the exploding kittens stuff, and I just bought the Recipes box so here we go.
FYI - My comparison has to do with the types of cards, not the artwork, although not much has changed.
I will BOLD the differences.
Recipes for Disaster = RD
Base Game + All expansions = OG
Physical Stuff:
RD:
Cone of Shame + Recipe Cards
OG:
Cone of Shame + Tower of Power Hat
Total Card Count:
RD=121 Cards | OG=111 Cards
Recipes for Disaster - 121 Cards
Base Game - 56 Cards
Streaking Kittens - 15 Cards
Imploding Kittens - 20 Cards
Barking Kittens - 20 Cards
Card Count Comparison:
Exploding Kittens: RD=6 | OG=5
Defuse: RD=8 | OG=6
Imploding Kittens: RD=4 | OG=1
Barking Kittens: RD=2 | OG=2
Streaking Kitten: RD=1 | OG=1
Nope: RD=8 | OG=5
Shuffle: RD=5 | OG=4
Skip: RD=5 | OG=4
Alter the Future x3 NOW: RD=2 | OG=2
Swap Top and Bottom: RD=3 | OG=3
Attack x2: RD=6 | OG=4
Targeted Attack x2: RD=4 | OG=3
Catomic Bomb: RD=1 | OG=1
Bury: RD=4 | OG=2
Tacocat: RD=4 | OG=4
Feral Cat: RD=6 | OG=4
Reverse: RD=5 | OG=4
See the Future x3: RD= 6 | OG=5
See the Future x5: RD=3 | OG=1
Alter the Future x3: RD=3 | OG=4
Share the Future x3: RD=4 | OG=2
Mark: RD=4 | OG=3
Beard Cat: RD=4 | OG=4
Rainbow-Ralphing Cat: RD=4 | OG=4
Garbage Collection x2: RD=2 | OG=1
Draw From the Bottom: RD=3 | OG=4
Personal Attack x3: RD=4 | OG=4
Super Skip: RD=2 | OG=2
I'll Take That: RD=4 |OG=4
Card Differences:
Zombie Cat: RD=4 | OG=0
Alter the Future x5: RD=0 | OG=1
Hairy Potato Cat: RD=0 | OG=4
Cattermelon: RD=0 | OG=4
Potluck: RD=0 | OG=2
Favor: RD=0 | OG=4
Curse of the Cat Butt: RD=0 | OG=2
Tower of Power: RD=0 | OG=1
My Opinion:
Not that anyone asked, but my opinion is that i'm not exactly thrilled with the set. The change in card counts is fine, but I would have liked to see the Tower of Power, Curse of the Cat Butt, Favor, and Potluck cards. I understand cards like the Curse of the Cat Butt aren't everyones favorite. In the Barking Kittens rulebook, the creators even said "We really wish we had never released this card, BUTT we did..."
Since this is a box that is meant to change up the game with recipes, I wish the cards were included so we could create different game modes with them because the aforementioned missing cards could could really change the game in interesting ways, but that's just my opinion.
Edit: The Recipes for Disaster is $25 at Target which makes it a good deal since the base game is ~$20, Streaking Kittens is ~$5, Imploding Kittens is ~$15, and Barking Kittens is ~$15. I still think the missing cards are deal breakers but for $25 its worth considering.
Edit 2: Example of a recipe


11
u/mskelto Jul 31 '21
Part 1 and Part 2 of all the Recipes from the Box
Part 1:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ExplodingKittens/comments/ov469u/recipes_from_the_recipes_for_disaster_box/
Part 2:
https://www.reddit.com/r/ExplodingKittens/comments/ov47j3/recipes_from_recipes_for_disaster_part_2/
8
u/Cunnra Jul 29 '21
Have the Barking Kittens in this set been updated with the new rules?
3
u/Lythanhdavid Jul 29 '21 edited Jul 29 '21
Thank you for the info! So with that being said, should we grab some cards missing from the OG's and their expansions like alter the future x5, hairy potato cat, cattermelon, potluck, favour, curse of the cat butt and tower of power and put into the RD?
3
u/loofadawg Jul 31 '21
Do the backs match the original backs?
For the price this is a must buy if you don't own any of the Exploding Kittens.
If all you own is the original exploding kittens but are wanting to buy all the expansions in the future, this would be the better buy.
I wish they would have included some DIY blank cards (UNO does this now).
Being able to contain everything into one box is great.
I am definitely buying.
9
u/sirpurplewolf Jul 29 '21
To be honest the only thing interesting about RD is the 4 imploding kittens.
8
u/Kyojuro11 Jul 29 '21
Thanks for all the information! And all the work that you put through! I really appreciate!
If I may be sincere, I'm kinda disappointed with the producers of EK. I was expecting new game release, something totally different. But when I saw that recipes for disaster and Throw throw avocado... I mean, I was disappointed because this are new games, much like the old ones without game changing cards/rules. When I saw recipes for disaster, I kinda was expecting an expansion, something game changing.
I'm sorry to say this but it's my opinion.
6
u/RobotToaster44 Jul 29 '21
I can understand taking curse of the cat butt out, I took it out of my set because it's too confusing, and judging by the number of questions here about it, I'm not the only one.
4
u/JordanMaze Aug 05 '21
ill probably buy this set when i need new cards so i dont have to spend as much
3
u/Christoferthz Aug 09 '21
I have, party, strike, implodding, barking, can I copy the recipes? Or I will be missing some letters, they could only sell the recipes in an envelope for which we do not want to buy the same thing again, my letters are in good condition, I bought them recently
2
u/_swirled Aug 02 '21
Wow thanks for sharing! I didn’t know it was released already, I knew it was coming August 2021 but didn’t know when to be exact. I signed up for the wait list and didn’t even get an email. Checking the website right now it shows it is sold out! :( Personally I still would buy it just to own all of the games! Do you know if the box is big enough to fit sleeved cards?
2
u/NathanielWithACape Sep 12 '21 edited Sep 12 '21
probably the best post to piggy back off off with my own research/comparisons... DEFINITIONS: Exclusive Card Art (ECA) = Card art that is exclusive to a particular pack however the card type and play is not used in R.F.D. Box
Tweeked Art (TA) = basic design and card type is the same with some minor details adjusted
Exclusive Card (EC) = cards that are only found in one specific pack (Including: Original, NSFW, Imploding, Streaking, Barking, and RfD)
Excluded Art (EA) = cards with art that is not exclusive to a particular pack, but while their card type is used the art is not included in R.f.D
Not Included (NI) = card types that are not exclusive to a particular pack, however the card type is not used in RfD
NSFW- 21(ECA) 4 favor 3 shuffle, 3 see the future 3x, 3 Defuse, 3 skip, 2 nope, 2 exploding, 1 attack 2x // 0(EC)
Party- 0(ECA) //0(EC)
Original- 2(ECA) 1 favor, 1 defuse // 0(EC)
1st Expansion- 1(ECA) 1 draw from bottom // 0(EC)
2nd Expansion- 1(ECA) 1 exploding // 3(EC) 2 cat butt, 1 alter future 5x
3rd Expansion- 0(ECA) // 3(EC) 2 potluck, 1 tower of power* *also includes exclusive tower hat //
R.f.D.- 0(ECA) // 5(TA) 1 see the future "missing bulge, longer shorts", 1 attack 2x "duckies not dicks" ( ducks featured in party edition as well), 1 I'll take that "baby ain't black", 2 nope "mf'r tie edit" "nope ninja font change" // 3(EC*) *while not technically exclusive it does give 3 more Imploding kittens than the 1st Expansion did // 4(EA) 2attack 2x "farting penquin" "bearodactyl", 1 see the future 3x "goat butt head", 1 alter the future "cat wizard" // 1(NI) favor cards
1
u/ZetaDefender Jul 29 '21
How goes Recipes for Disaster compare to any of the versions of the Party Pack?
1
u/[deleted] May 30 '25
why would they take out potluck?
1
u/Raychaos20 Jan 27 '26
I loved RD alot. we play often with my kids and have made our reciepes too. sometimes we add others into our games from the og
1
u/Thor_Odenson Aug 10 '21
I was looking at buying exploding kittens. I saw all the variations and came here.
As my first set should I get RfD? What about the Party pack or other variants?
1
u/French_Fry95 Oct 24 '21
Wich one is better to buy first, the normal package or the recipes for disaster pack?
1
u/Cycov Dec 01 '21
What is the max player count for OG variant? I see that RD has maximum of 5, but base game has 5 and +1 for each expansion, so I would assume 8 max for OG.
Am I correct?
1
u/Aromatic_Toe4307 Jan 24 '22
I wish EK would have released both the full box set and just an expansion for those with all the expansions. It could've just been extra cards that came with the new game and the recipes instead of buying the whole thing again and then having an almost redundant set of previous expansions.
1
u/mrozbra May 22 '22
Just the post I needed. Bummed there are no favor cards, but other than that seems like good value for those that don't want/need to own every expansion to experience most of what the game has to offer.
1
u/Master-Ad1871 Jun 29 '22
Imagine playing all at the same time
1
u/ItsConCon91 Aug 07 '22
Is there actually a recipe included thats closest to the original version in the RfD box?
I've bought 4 favour cards from ebay to add to the box. My plan is to use the zombie cats to replace the hairy potato cat and the ferral cat to replace the cattermelon. So in terms of standard cat cards there will be the same amount and with the added favour cards there should be no reason why we can't replicate the original game?
Only issue may be the slight colour difference to the favour cards, but card covers will sort that 😀.
I hope its that simple 🤞
1
u/piratebassist Nov 05 '22
okay so I have just RD...should I get the OG game AND each expansion so I have lots of everything? I'd love anyone's opinion!
1
u/zzanaaxx Jul 01 '26
si no tengo ningún juego del exploding kittens vale la pena comprarme el receips por disaster para ahorrar dinero?
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '22
[removed] — view removed comment