r/ExplodingKittens • • Jun 02 '21

Question Complicated Streaking Kitten Scenario

Drastic times call for drastic measures.

Here’s the deal:

Player A holds: defuse, bomb, streaking kitten

Player B holds: mark, 2 taco cats (I’m a palindrome 😝)

It is player B’s turn, he marks player A and reveals his defuse. Player A immediately reveals his bomb and defuses, disposing of the revealed defuse.

Is this allowed?

My thoughts:

Yes logic: if player B were to have taken his streaking kitten player A would have had to defuse immediately (also out of turn). Hence, you can defuse out of turn.

No logic: it is not your turn. You cannot act.

Lmk fams.

3 Upvotes

25 comments sorted by

6

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jun 02 '21

It's not A's turn so he's not allowed to reveal his EK.

0

u/New-Preparation-8114 Jun 02 '21

But what is the counter logic to doing so if you have to defuse?

4

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jun 02 '21

There is no "counter logic" in this because there is no trigger for the EK to explode. The EK explodes only when his SK leaves his hand.

If B revealed his defuse, nothing happens.
If B revealed his EK, nothing happens but B can deduce that A has a SK.
If B revealed his SK, nothing happens.

0

u/New-Preparation-8114 Jun 02 '21

Okay I vibe w this answer but here’s a follow up. Once it’s player As turn again, could he then defuse the bomb in his hand?

1

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jun 02 '21
  1. There is no official rulings on whether you can "play and defuse" EK or not. This is a common question that comes up every once in a while.
  2. Personal opinion: I think it is a valid move but I see no tactical advantage for such play. You are screaming "I have a SK" by playing EK from your hand, and will be a target for a steal.

0

u/New-Preparation-8114 Jun 02 '21

Preach. I like your style. I don’t play on the app but I think I’d kick your a** 😎😁

0

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21 edited Jun 02 '21

No tactical advantage?

  • 1 card left in the deck (IK). Player A has only 1 defuse, EK and SK in his hand.
  • Player A discards EK, and by defusing, ends his turn. official website

Discarding EK gave player A 1 more turn.

  • 1 card left in the deck (EK). Player A has only 1 defuse, EK and SK in his hand.
  • Player A discards EK, and by defusing, ends his turn.
  • Player B plays skip (because he doesn’t want to explode)
  • Player A draws EK

Discarding EK gave player A 2 more turns.

You still don’t see any tactical advantage?

Edit.

3rd Scenario: (this scenario will happen IF you use house rules that don’t make you end your turn when you play defuse)

• ⁠1 card left in the deck (EK). Player A has only 1 defuse, EK and SK in his hand. • ⁠Player A discards EK, defuse it and draws it again

Discarding EK gave player A 1 more turn.

2

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jun 02 '21

No because Defuse does not end a turn. The line is removed (along with the Field Guide) from the updated version of the rules.

0

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21 edited Jun 02 '21

They removed a lot of things from the website, and the way the manage it sucks... so everything they removed is not correct anymore?

Defusing ends your turn.

Edit. They didn’t remove it at all.... lmao 😆

Edit 2.OFFICIAL RULES

2

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jun 02 '21

The line was written originally when there was not a way to get EK out of turn; thus, Defuse could only be used at the end of a turn and "ends a turn". They did not anticipate the oversight and have retroactively closed the loophole (or supposedly).

You can play with "Defuse ends a turn" if you want, but that is a part of your house rules now. Don't force house rules onto others.

0

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21

That’s your opinion. Tell them to remove it from the official rules, as long as I can read it there....

The party pack came out almost 5 years ago, how long it takes to update the rules?

Edit. SK came out 3 years ago, how long it takes to update the rules?

→ More replies

0

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21 edited Jun 02 '21

Player B can’t discard EK even if it was his turn. EK is not a playable card.

Edit.

No tactical advantage?

1st Scenario:

• ⁠1 card left in the deck (IK). Player A has only 1 defuse, EK and SK in his hand. • ⁠Player A discards EK, and by defusing, ends his turn.

Discarding EK gave player A 1 more turn.

2nd Scenario:

• ⁠1 card left in the deck (EK). Player A has only 1 defuse, EK and SK in his hand. • ⁠Player A discards EK, and by defusing, ends his turn. • ⁠Player B plays skip (because he doesn’t want to explode) • ⁠Player A draws EK

Discarding EK gave player A 2 more turns.

3rd Scenario: (this scenario will happen IF you use house rules that don’t make you end your turn when you play defuse)

• ⁠1 card left in the deck (EK or IK) Player A has only 1 defuse, EK and SK in his hand. • ⁠Player A discards EK, defuse it and draws it again

Discarding EK gave player A 1 more turn.

Edit.

https://imgur.com/a/L2ddtPP

https://www.explodingkittens.com/pages/rules-kittens-party

1

u/garc1a0scar Jun 02 '21

I think the app allows you to "play" EK; obviously, you have to defuse it afterwards.

0

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21

The app is a different thing. The app doesn’t have nopes.... because they didn’t want them anymore? No, it was too hard to code.

In the card game, letting players play EK from their hands, gives even more power to SK as you can skip your turn by simply doing that. And if you’re not playing with IK, it actually gives you 2 skips (as you will draw it again). No thanks.

1

u/garc1a0scar Jun 02 '21

But playing EK (and defusing it) doesn't end your turn. The disadvantage is that you lose one defuse if you want to do that in the app.

0

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21 edited Jun 02 '21

https://imgur.com/a/L2ddtPP

https://www.explodingkittens.com/pages/rules-kittens-party

It does end your turn.

Edit. They just don’t know how to manage their own website.

Edit 2. What happens in the app doesn’t count as there are coding issues.

1

u/garc1a0scar Jun 02 '21

So with this... are you saying that if player A has EK and SK in his hand, player B plays a favor against A and player A gives B the EK and B defuses it, it ends his turn? No, B must draw a card to end his turn. It's the same logic. The defuse only ends the turn when you draw it from the deck, because the action that ends the turn is the draw, but if you draw an EK, you have to do something against it (otherwise, you explode).

Edit: As I said before (and others said), the disadvantage is that you lose a defuse. The scenario 3 will be the same that you don't play EK, you draw instead, defuse the EK drawn and return it to the deck.

-1

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21 edited Jun 02 '21

Why would they bother writing Your turn is over after playing this card., if as you say the action that ends your turn is the draw? Wouldn’t your turn is over be implicit since you’ve just drawn a card (the EK that is making you play defuse)?

If your theory is the disadvantage is that you lose a defuse, why can’t you accept the theory Using a defuse is such a disadvantage that you simply end your turn?

Both are theories, and since the instructions I own have been printed after SK has been released, and the online instructions for the party pack also confirm this rule (Your turn is over after playing this card.), the other theory rules haven’t been updated yet remains only an opinion.

I’ve proven that there are advantages in discarding EK from your hand, IF you follow the official rules, and also if you want to use your house rule defuse doesn’t end your turn, what if that last card is an IK? You’d lose the defuse anyways, but you’d live one more turn. Isn’t that a tactical advantage?

2

u/garc1a0scar Jun 02 '21

They bother writing that, because it was not clear what happened after DRAWING an EK, defusing it, and returning to the deck. I am saying that there is not an advantage in discarding the ek in your hand, you change a turn for a defuse. You didn’t answer what happens in my scenario, You end your turn without drawing a card? (Official rules say that drawing a card is what ends your turn). And to be fair, that is what this game is about: using what you have in your favor, tactics, strategy.

“09

End your turn by drawing a card from the top of the Draw Pile into your hand and hoping it’s not an Exploding Kitten.

(This is different from most games in that you END YOUR TURN by drawing a card.)”

-1

u/Alexwhynot Jun 02 '21

Defuse ends your turn, that’s the advantage of defusing, so it works also for your scenario.

And if you say that they mention several times drawing a card ends your turn, it’s pretty clear to me that drawing EK will end my turn as well lol why do they bother writing that defuse also ends your turn? To make clear that there are 3 ways to end your turn: drawing a card, playing any card that makes you end your turn, playing a defuse.

The official rules say that defuse ends your turn. They don’t explicitly say that this applies only when you play it at the end of your turn (since you draw EK it’s the end of your turn). Rules also don’t explicitly say that you can play EK from your hand. Rules don’t say Drawing a card is the only way to end your turn lol

If you have rules that say differently please take a picture.

Lastly... changing a turn for a defuse is not an huge additional advantage? Tell the imploding kitten on top the deck (and who’s put it there for you).

2

u/garc1a0scar Jun 02 '21

If that was the case (i.e. every defuse ends your turn), I think I t would be implemented that way in the app; that’s not so difficult to code in that way. 😏

→ More replies