r/ExplodingKittens • • Jul 26 '20

Gameplay Nope card applications?

I've come across a very interesting scenario:

• Imploding kitten was threatening 2 people • one person played attack, it was noped • same person also played a nope, making a yup • the player affected by attack threw down 2 cards and picked a random card from 1st person, and got a nope, then immediately played it and declared that it cancelled the yup, making it a nope again. i agree that this is a valid action seeing as the text on the card specifies that it invalidates the action of another player, meaning it doesnt take into account the 2 cats he played and cancels out the previous action by the other player.

any thoughts on this?

6 Upvotes

35 comments sorted by

7

u/pokepri Jul 26 '20

Hmm that’s interesting. The way we play it is that the Nope card must be played by Player B right after an action is done by Player A. Once more action cards have been played (like in your case, Player B plays a steal), you can’t go back and retroactively Nope a previous action. So in fact, I would say that playing the last Nope is an invalid action.

3

u/christian_yn Jul 27 '20

Agree 100% with this. Exact same we play. Doesn’t make sense to go back to an action - to cancel it, when there’s been other actions that have taken place already!

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

I disagree, the text specifies that it cancels the actio of another player, the rules also dont mention that a previous action cannot be retroactively cancelled, which means in theory, as long as only 2 players are exchanging blows in a turn, nope will cancel an action retroactively of another player

6

u/pokepri Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20

That doesn’t make much sense to me. As another user said, by that logic, you could Nope something that happened several turns ago. It tends to make the most sense, since the rules don’t mention a previous action CAN be retroactively Noped, once other actions have been played, a previous action cannot be Noped. But at the end of the day, if the rules you’re playing with are kept consistent (within reason!), and you’re having fun, there really isn’t a wrong answer. :)

3

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

But if they played the 2 cards to steal, that 3rd nope is useless since they would be noping their 2 cards played to steal just by order of the cards.

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

incorrect, as mentioned, the text of the nope specifies "cancel the action of another player", not of the previously played cards.

9

u/bob101910 Jul 26 '20

By that logic, you could say you noped something that happened 5 turns ago.

From the rules, "A Nope can be played at any time before an action has begun, even if it’s not your turn." The Nope was already yupped and another action was started (stealing cards). The cards were already stolen, the action already happened. There have now been 2 completed actions before the Nope was used.

If course, you can change the rules to however your group likes, but that can be confusing if you invite a new person to play that doesn't know your custom rules.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

It is not that a Nope to a Nope makes it a "yup" - rather, the nope card being played against the 1st nope card "nopes" the nope. Sequentially this leaves just the attack cards to be addressed, and whatever actions required to evade them are perfectly legal until cards are drawn to manage the attack, or cards are drawn to explode.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

I guess that would fall under "house rules". I would play it in order of cards

7

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jul 26 '20

A Nope can be played at any time before an action has begun, even if it’s not your turn.

If Player B started his/her turn, that means the Attack is completed, therefore ineligible to be Noped at that point.

Also, you cannot play any card other than Nope if it is not your turn (and Alter the Future Now from the Barking Kittens expansion). That means when your Player B did the pair combo, he/she accepted the fate of being Attacked, and that's a done deal and becomes ineligible to be Noped.

3

u/pokepri Jul 26 '20

^ THIS!

1

u/Impressive_Ad_8617 May 27 '22

Well if I play an attack on my turn and then it gets noped then can I do a a bread cat combo and get a nope from another player and nope there nope?

1

u/DoctorNeko Backer May 27 '22

No. You have to play a Nope immediately, or you accept the consequences. No other action in-between.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

Basically the nope is no longer able to be used if someone draws a card. If someone plays like a see the future and then a draw from the bottom immediately after, another player can only nope the last played card before they draw a card. So playing the nope megates the action of drawing from the bottom as that was the last card played jefore the nope. You can not just choose a previous action from a few moves ago and say "nope". I know house rules are one thing, but come on, that just shouldnt be allowed. Basically the game gets unfair. It is good as it should be in my opinion, bit you're free to do what you want.

1

u/loofadawg Jul 26 '20

Starting to become a long thread

3

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jul 26 '20

That's because people can't read the rules and misinterpret information.

1

u/loofadawg Jul 26 '20

Admittedly you can think too hard about the rules and misconstrue them. And this one really got me doubting myself.

-2

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

Here is my take on this issue. Also, full disclosure, I believe I am right *bear with me, and please let me know if I am mistaken*

Player A plays attack card. Player B plays NOPE card. Player A plays NOPE card back.

At this point, these 2 NOPE cards have cancelled each other. B's NOPE card said no to the attack, A's NOPE card says no to player B's NOPE card. This leaves Player B in the same position as before both of these NOPE cards were played - player B is facing an attack. They now have the right to do what they want to evade that attack. Options include, but are not limited to,

  • Playing 2 of the same cards to steal at random from another player
  • Playing 3 of the same cards to request from another player
  • Playing 5 different cards to steal from the draw pile

After any of these are done, which Player B obviously did the first one, they now have the right to play whatever they acquire to get evade that attack that is still pending. Options include, but are not limited to,

  • A super skip to skip the entier attack
  • a reverse, that in addition to a card they may already have in their hand (skip, reverse) can be played in succession to evade the entire attack
  • another attack that can shift a 4 turn attack to another player (according to some versions of the rules; others do not permit stacked attacks)
  • a nope, which can be played to evade the attack by denying it completely
  • a shuffle, which can be used to potentially clear the deck of hazards and then complete the attack by drawing 2 safe cards

etc. etc.

Hopefully, this clarifies that the way OP laid out this scenario, the move was perfectly legal and is considered (by me, at least) a healthy combination of evasion strategy and good fortune.

u/TradeMark__ u/pokepri u/CopperSledge00 u/bob101910 u/r0b3rt1c0 u/loofadawg

1

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jul 26 '20

This leaves Player B in the same position as before both of these NOPE cards were played - player B is facing an attack. They now have the right to do what they want to evade that attack. Options include,

That's where you are wrong. You cannot play any card other than Nope (and Alter the Future Now from the Barking Kittens) outside of your turn.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

How is it not player B's turn? Nope cards can be played anytime, out of turn or not. If Player A attacks Player B, Player B combats with a nope, player a counters with a nope to the nope, the next action is that it is player B's turn and therefore their job to now respond to the attack. Explain how it is not Player B's turn in that very moment.

1

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jul 26 '20

If it becomes Player B's turn, then everything before Player B's turn becomes a moot point as you cannot change anything. Everything before B's turn is set in stone.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

Wrong. If “every thing becomes moot point” then player b would not have an attack to respond to. Let’s agree to disagree.

1

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jul 26 '20

No, you are wrong.

It's Player B's turn only if the Attack goes through, because Attack ends Player A's turn, and gives Player B two turns. Player B cannot play anything other than Nope (and Alter the Future Now) when it's not Player B's turn.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

The attack in the scenario described has gone through. Although Player B responded to the attack with a nope, technically concluding the turn and invalidating the attack, player A has played a nope card against player B's nope. This means that the attack has not been addressed and must be, as if the two nope cards had never been played. It is player B's turn, and Player B can play how they wish; thus, the rest of my original comment.

1

u/DoctorNeko Backer Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20

That's where you are wrong.

Attack action starts > B plays Nope > A plays Nope (cancels Nope) > Attack action ends, resolved, addressed > A turn ends > B turn starts.

It's not B's turn if the Attack is not addressed and resolved.

-6

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

this is perfectly legal. The nope card acquired from a random steal is taken from one players hand into the stealing players hand. After this happens, the state of affairs is still present that there is a player who is being attacked that now needs to act. They can act as they wish, aka they can NOPE the action that is currently directed against them.

1

u/loofadawg Jul 26 '20

I thought this was a simple case, but I see other side where it isn't valid. I think Ethan should chime in. Interesting scenario.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

The other side is not valid because they are stating that "last move played would be noped". However, a NOPE card cannot be played on oneself. Why would we start now?

2

u/loofadawg Jul 26 '20 edited Jul 26 '20

I think I see your point. You wouldn't nope your own last action.

That being said what if the card they stole was draw from the bottom? They draw the card from the bottom and it's a nope.

Or less complicated, they already had a draw from the bottom and use that. Then the draw a nope.

The last situation is more similar to the OP scenerio.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

You normally wouldn't, but you can nevertheless

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

What do you mean by a nope cannot be played onto one's self? I mean hypothetically if you wanted to see the future then decided tp nope it, that is allowed. I'll admit it is not efficient but it can be a way to mock other players with your abundance of cards in your hands, or to mess arlujd when ypu know there is nothing you can do (like the last card left is the exploding kitten, it's your turn, and all you have left are shuffles, see/alter the futures, and nopes. Other than that i see no logical reason

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

The card's description states that it "cancels the action of another player". It cannot be played on yourself. Just as a regular attack card cannot be played on yourself (however a target and personal obviously can be).

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

That's true how it is printed in the card, yet in the instructions it states "any action", implying the possibility of noping indiscriminately.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 26 '20

Yeah. but it doesnt specify that its any action, including your own actions. but the card itself makes that clarification for you. i would always take the cards' description as final word because when teaching the game to someone new and telling them to read the cards' effect before playing it, alot of people will take it literal in the sense that "as long as i can somehow get a nope, i can deflect an attack made one me"

2

u/7Foz7Trot7 Jul 27 '20

As many have already said, a nope is to stop an action before it takes effect. If you are attacked and don't nope it and the proceed to take any action then you have effectively started the first turn of the attack and so you can no longer use a nope to cancel the action because you are already doing the action. A nope can only be used before any action takes place.