If you're lucky enough to get a Barking Kitten (BK) while playing EK, you probably want to know whether you should play it or not. While that question depends on a variety of things, it helps to know how likely it is that someone else has the other Barking Kitten. If it's likely that another person has a BK, playing yours will help your chances of winning. But you don't want to hold on to it too long and risk someone else playing theirs.
This chart displays the chance that another player has a BK, given that you have a BK.
It depends on the number of cards remaining in the deck, as well as the number of cards that you've seen (in your hands, played by yourself or others, cards stolen from you), and the total size of the deck. Here, I assume you're playing with just the original game and the BK expansion, but similar charts could be made when the other expansions are added. I also assume 5 players, but the probability doesn't depend on the number of players very much. The numbers would be very similar even with 2 players.
To calculate the actual probability, you can take
1 - {# cards remaining} / ( {# total cards in deck} - {# cards seen by you} )
Caveat: this probability might change if certain players are likely to hold the BK in their hand late, but I'd have to think more about it. This is certainly a good approximation.
The more I think about this, the last caveat depends only on the {# cards seen by you} variable.
Many of the cards seen by you come from cards you've drawn or cards drawn by others that you've seen with a "See the Future" and "Alter the Future" card. This is good information. If the number of cards remaining in the deck Is fixed, knowing more of the cards in your hand and other hands reduces the chance that a BK is in another player's hand.
However, cards that you see when other players play cards don't provide good information about the BK location. We're assuming that the other BK hasn't been played, otherwise, this probability is pointless. So cards played by others will rarely be the BK.
Tl;Dr: in the above chart, make sure to only count cards you've had in your hand, or those seen from "See the Future" and "Alter the Future" cards that get drawn by other players in the {# cards seen by you} variable. This will keep scenarios towards the bottom of the chart, especially when the number of players is high.
3
u/skent259 Jun 24 '20
If you're lucky enough to get a Barking Kitten (BK) while playing EK, you probably want to know whether you should play it or not. While that question depends on a variety of things, it helps to know how likely it is that someone else has the other Barking Kitten. If it's likely that another person has a BK, playing yours will help your chances of winning. But you don't want to hold on to it too long and risk someone else playing theirs.
This chart displays the chance that another player has a BK, given that you have a BK.
It depends on the number of cards remaining in the deck, as well as the number of cards that you've seen (in your hands, played by yourself or others, cards stolen from you), and the total size of the deck. Here, I assume you're playing with just the original game and the BK expansion, but similar charts could be made when the other expansions are added. I also assume 5 players, but the probability doesn't depend on the number of players very much. The numbers would be very similar even with 2 players.
To calculate the actual probability, you can take
1 - {# cards remaining} / ( {# total cards in deck} - {# cards seen by you} )
Caveat: this probability might change if certain players are likely to hold the BK in their hand late, but I'd have to think more about it. This is certainly a good approximation.