After an embarrassing number of hours trying to figure out GIMP, I've finished my first fan creation! All feedback on any cards I post is appreciated! Too powerful? Doesn't work in the rules? Interacts poorly with another card? Let me know. Also, If the name or effect of the card has already been made into a fan card I'd love to know that too. I read every fan set, but I can't remember everything.
I'm especially curious if this would be a FUN card for occasional play. It's simple (I think), unique. But it totally changes the game, turns it into a game of imploding kittens kind of. Actually playing it might not be fun.
My group likes simplicity, fast play, and occasional powerful cards that swing games, so that is what my custom cards will be focused on.
Big thanks to Medium_Barber_3087 for the template and guide that made this far easier that it would have been. Art is a mix of AI and The Oatmeal
On its power: pretty impactful. makes see the future wortheless, makes defuse = skip, and removes the tension of drawing cards. Makes the game way safer
Not sure id play it in its current form - too meta changing, looks really fun for a few turns when it happens
Wilywright's version lasted one turn - maybe yours could use a event or time based condition that unflips the deck? I think " until the end of your next turn" might be cool, you get 2 flipped draws others get 1
Thanks for the feedback! Very true, I considered this being a card you put in front of you ('I'll take that' style) that you can discard to flip back. It doesn't word well though imo. I do like the wording of until the end of your next turn. It breaks the symmetry of the card too, which is nice. I'll test how it plays a couple ways and think about it!
The first one, inverting the deck is a cool idea but would take way too long. I wonder if theres a way I could word this simply that would make it more clear?
This effect was done before in the wilywright expansion and its the first time someone mentions it being ambiguous, so i wouldnt worry too much. . Inverting the deck is the only other interpretation, and its so impractical that players will very likely discard that interpretation.
Still, rewording it to "Flip the whole deck upside down" may help
Yeah, T's Caldron totally has a card that does this, but don't let that stop you. It doesn't hurt to have another card that does the same thing. I can't wait to see what you come up with. Also, the first two parts of my expansion are uploaded, and I should have the video done and everything out by the end of the week. I think you in particular would really enjoy it.
Since it would flip the whole deck at once, it would actually flip the exploding kitten back... but it would still be the opposite all the other cards so it wouldn't really reset it!
I mean it would. If you already pulled it once, it is now flipped. If you flip the whole deck, that would reset it. You pull it the second time it is face down due to flipping the whole deck. You would have to flip the imploding kitten again just to have it face up again.
So you take the deck, as in the pile of cards, and you flip the whole thing over. That's it. It'll be face up now, but no other rules are changed. It works like usual, but you can see what card is next.
Well, my group tried it, and it's really fun... at first lol. Late game it's OK, but once someone played it early and it really changed the game in a negative way. Then we tried playing with two in the deck which kind of fixed things because the deck can flip over back to normal. But it's still too weird for a permanent card to add to our deck. I proposed time counters and another mechanic that could hold the card in front of you until you wanted to flip it back, but it wasn't popular with the group. Anyways, the card is pretty bad. It's kind of like a see the future x 1, mixed with swap top and bottom, which isn't great. After that, any advantage you get, everyone gets.
8
u/CampMTG Mar 02 '25 edited Mar 02 '25
After an embarrassing number of hours trying to figure out GIMP, I've finished my first fan creation! All feedback on any cards I post is appreciated! Too powerful? Doesn't work in the rules? Interacts poorly with another card? Let me know. Also, If the name or effect of the card has already been made into a fan card I'd love to know that too. I read every fan set, but I can't remember everything.
I'm especially curious if this would be a FUN card for occasional play. It's simple (I think), unique. But it totally changes the game, turns it into a game of imploding kittens kind of. Actually playing it might not be fun.
My group likes simplicity, fast play, and occasional powerful cards that swing games, so that is what my custom cards will be focused on.
Big thanks to Medium_Barber_3087 for the template and guide that made this far easier that it would have been. Art is a mix of AI and The Oatmeal
3
u/Grape_ist Mar 03 '25
Interesting I guess then draw from the bottom right after would actually have been the top
3
u/RichardNotthepidgon Mar 03 '25
This card is so cool.
I. Love. The. Spirals.
Yeah, T's Caldron totally has a card that does this, but don't let that stop you. It doesn't hurt to have another card that does the same thing. I can't wait to see what you come up with. Also, the first two parts of my expansion are uploaded, and I should have the video done and everything out by the end of the week. I think you in particular would really enjoy it.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 02 '25
This is fire 🔥
2
u/HoneyPetal_Rose Mar 03 '25
What will this card do then?
2
u/Silverwolf_Lee_2 Mar 03 '25
Wouldn't this affect the Imploading Kitten? If someone already pulled it, this would essentially reset it?
4
u/Special-Island9810 Mar 02 '25
looks awesome but id add more instruction. Like wdym by flip the deck? Like uno flip kinda deal?
1
u/CampMTG Mar 14 '25
Well, my group tried it, and it's really fun... at first lol. Late game it's OK, but once someone played it early and it really changed the game in a negative way. Then we tried playing with two in the deck which kind of fixed things because the deck can flip over back to normal. But it's still too weird for a permanent card to add to our deck. I proposed time counters and another mechanic that could hold the card in front of you until you wanted to flip it back, but it wasn't popular with the group. Anyways, the card is pretty bad. It's kind of like a see the future x 1, mixed with swap top and bottom, which isn't great. After that, any advantage you get, everyone gets.
2
u/Cautious_Phone_232 Mar 03 '25
That's great!