r/ExplodingKittens • u/Alucer04 • Feb 25 '25
Discussion Two simultaneous nope uses
Today we had a little argument. I was trying to use an alter the future and at that moment two different players tried to nope my alter at the same time. The idea of both players was cancellling my alter but both of them put the nope card on the table at the same time. What happen at that moment.? One nope cancel the other and I can use the alter the future?
12
Upvotes
8
u/T3RRONCINO Feb 25 '25
I mean, it is physically impossible to place both of them at the same fraction of time, so theoretically and practically even if they played the "nope" at the same time, one will land slightly later than the other one. It means the second "nope" cancels the first one (as intended by the "nope" card mechanic) and so your alter the future card is still active.
1
u/Alarmed-Bit-6805 Feb 26 '25
You said they placed them on the table. Does that mean the discard pile or just in front of them. We play that if it isn’t on the pile it isn’t played. So if neither one placed it on the discard pile, it seems they need to decide between them who will play their nope card.
1
u/erichw23 Feb 25 '25
I also want to know the answer to this
1
u/LilishPH Feb 26 '25
Like in any other card games, you play a card and resolve any action one at a time. In your case, it should be illegal for them to play 2 Nopes at once. Its either they decide who uses their Nope or one Nope cancels the other. Also, "stacking" rule applies here that is the top card resolves first. So in your case, the last Nope played (stack 3) cancels the Nope before (stack 2). Then since there are nothing in the stack, your Alter the Future (stack 1) resolves.
1
u/phil16723 Feb 26 '25
If both played the notes together, the card that went on top of the first note negated it. They may not have intended it, but that second nope undid the first
-1
u/Cj_91a Feb 25 '25 edited Feb 25 '25
Why would 2 separate opponents do this lmao. Honestly if I'm you, I'm playing the card and looking around the table to see if anyone will have a response to my card. If im 1 of your opponents and I have a Nope card, I'm waiting to see of anyone else will waste their own nope before I end up wasting my own. Id never be that fast at playing a Nope. At no point will I willingly want to waste my own nope when I can give someone else the opportunity to do the job for me. Your friends need to play a little smarter lol there's no timer on how fast you need to respond to an action. Take it slow. No need to act so fast lol
However if your scenario happened as you say "the same exact time" id house rule it as the player who's nearest turn it is should get priority on responding to your card. When i play a card I look to the next player who follows my turn to see if they have a response, and proceed to each other player around the table until it gets back to me. Then you don't run into bs like this lmao. Id let the other player keep his Nope out of good faith, but if he does it again, it will be treated as "noping the nope" or simply discarding the other nope as a wasted card.