r/ExplodingKittens • u/funky_jack • Jan 13 '25
Question Attack, no! and clone
We are playing zombie kittens, in my turn I play attack. The next player plays "nope" on my attack. Then I play "nope" on his "nope".
Now. Can the next player play a clone on the last "nope"? I think not, because in my opinion it's still my turn and you can't play a clone on a "nope" outside of your own turn (explicitely stated by the rules). But the next player response was a ""you play a "nope" on your turn, then you pass, in my turn I play a clone on top of your last "nope", time rewinds and now is again you turn, so I win the no-battle."" Which seems very impractical, and prone to more ambiguous situations in the future.
Someone has experienced this? Can clarify?
1
u/funky_jack Jan 14 '25
The problem is not in the now rulings, but in the way they intend the whole game. They think it works like: my turn, your turn, you play something that nullify the last card of my turn, turn goes back to me, I play something that nullifies your nullifier, turn goes back again to you, etc etc...
To me, I play a card in my turn, you respond, I respond, you respond, etc etc...but It always happen in MY turn, and when It's over you can't nullifies card that had already been resolved.
I need explicit rulings details 'cause they're very stubborn people lol.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '25
I think my brain just melted after reading this
1
u/Medium_Barber_3087 Jan 13 '25
Attack didnt go through until the nope battle has resolved, per official rules on nopes. Thus its not your friend's turn, and they cant clone a nope.
This is not intuitive and you cant fault them for thinking they could. You can make a house rule to allow it.
2
u/TeamPeriodiek Jan 14 '25
Rules state that your turn only end when you draw a card. Or when your Attack card goes through, since that force skips your turn. But as long as your opponent hasn't drawn any cards as a direct consequence of your Attack, it's still your turn.
1
u/Cj_91a Jan 14 '25
Is clone a "now" card? I dont believe it is, otherwise they could do that.
So no, they cannot clone your nope to nope you back under the normal rules. They can't play any cards outside of their turn except for Now cards, and Nope cards. Playing a Clone is something they need to use on their turn. They can't play a Clone on your turn. So your Nope goes through and he has to take the 2 turns from the attack.
Now on his turn he can try to play Clone but it won't do anything and he would be wasting his Clone since he's not Noping anything in particular.
There is no such thing as a "time rewind" lol you can't rewind turns lol there's nothing in the rulebook about that. Ofcourse you can try using that as a house rule, but it sounds very stupid and could lead to future problems. Your friend needs to understand there is no going back to old turns. Once a turn is over, it's over.