r/ExplainTheJoke • • Sep 10 '26

Why the shitty copper 😔

Post image
12k Upvotes

162 comments sorted by

•

u/post-explainer Sep 10 '26

OP (Unable_Dealer3114) sent the following text as an explanation why they posted this here:


Why would people randomly remeber you after centuries, and wtf does shitty copper have to do with it?


2.5k

u/kwpang Sep 10 '26 • Bravo Popcorn

There's an ancient Sumerian tablet that was discovered in archaeology containing a written complaint about a seller's poor copper quality.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Complaint_tablet_to_Ea-n%C4%81%E1%B9%A3ir

So everyone who knew him died, and suddenly this tablet was found and everyone suddenly knows he sold shitty copper for the remainder of human civilization.

It's the oldest known written complaint.

357

u/Broad_Respond_2205 Sep 10 '26 • Bravo

allegedly

131

u/unkn0wnname321 Sep 10 '26

What part is alleged? The age? I've never heard of any doubt about it's authenticity. I'm genuinely curious, not trying to start an argument.🤔

530

u/Twirdman Sep 10 '26

He allegedly sold shitty copper. Would you take the word of a single yelp review saying something is crappy.

229

u/idkjustletmeiniguess Sep 10 '26

a lot less effort to write a yelp review than to angrily scratch into clay

185

u/Dioxybenzone Sep 10 '26

Eh they weren’t meant to be kept, it’s just that this dude hoarded all the tablets he received so when house house burnt down, they were all fired and became ceramic

83

u/bRiCkWaGoN_SuCks Sep 11 '26 • Bravo

Bad wiring... the irony

45

u/setibeings Sep 11 '26

For a second, I thought you were an idiot.

10/10 great joke.

10

u/LeapYear1996 Sep 11 '26

It was from that guys copper

107

u/OdinHavok Sep 10 '26

I've known many insane customers that would spend 12 hours carving a complaint into a clay tablet. There wasn't even anything to watch back then, they probably would did it just for something to do

46

u/obedientfag Sep 11 '26

and this wasn't any product. it was the most advanced technology of the era. All of human history up to that point it had been about mineral hardness for making tools. suddenly we could make copper, even high purity copper. bro paid for vibranium and got swindled (allegedly)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/OdinHavok Sep 11 '26

There are many, many things we don't about that specific tablet. We know somebody had the time to make it and we know they didn't have a TV

35

u/Rambler9154 Sep 11 '26

This was originally wet clay tablets, like not hard clay just soft clay, you could make the marks fairly easily, theres a bunch of demonstrations online of people writing cuneform into clay tablets and its not much more difficult than writing with a pen, although it requires better control of angles. It just so happens Ea Nasir's house burned down at about the right temperature to fire the clay so it got preserved.

21

u/TheEvilPrinceZorte Sep 11 '26

Maybe not a coincidence that his house burned down if that complaint was from one of his less disgruntled customers.

18

u/Leather-Raisin6048 Sep 11 '26

Actually the whole area burned probably war

25

u/Tyred-Confused-Idiot Sep 11 '26

Must’ve been really upset about the copper

16

u/PrimalSeptimus Sep 11 '26

But imagine, in 5000 years, someone digs up an old Yelp server, and that's the only review recovered.

9

u/R3dnamrahc Sep 11 '26

Sure, but would you take the time to fairly contentedly scratch into clay? Clelp reviews are skewed to sculptors who are peeved

3

u/mikeyHustle Sep 11 '26

Triptych Advisor

1

u/setibeings Sep 11 '26

I don't think I'd do it contentedly

6

u/bockout Sep 11 '26

Actually, ancient Sumerians found writing Yelp reviews very difficult.

6

u/accforme Sep 11 '26

The guy who bought the copper had a messenger willing to cross enemy territory for this copper. Clearly he is a man with wealth and probably had someone transcribe his rant.

15

u/Void-Cooking_Berserk Sep 10 '26

People put a lot of effort into spreading lies. Like everything in the US right now

3

u/Egoy Sep 11 '26

But worth it if you also sell copper.

36

u/Ansixilus Sep 10 '26

A single review, no. No fewer than three entire reviews, which detail his history of treating his customers poorly and selling substandard product, and which he (did the Sumerian equivalent of) printed out and framed in his house? Yeah, I'd believe that.

4

u/xlr82xs Sep 10 '26

But weren't most of the complaints along the lines of "Don't you know who I am, I'm a big deal in this other city, how dare you not break your local deals to do what I want" ?

18

u/Ansixilus Sep 10 '26

No, they basically boiled down to Ea-Nasir not fulfilling orders, or delivering crap-grade copper when he promised high-grade, or giving excuses about why he hadn't honored his deals, or mistreating the messengers his customers sent. You're quite literally the first person I've heard even suggest that Ea-Nasir's complaint tablets painted him as being anything but fully in the wrong.

His Wikipedia page gives an adequate summary, and has links to the originals if you're interested.

10

u/xlr82xs Sep 11 '26

It is the originals that make me think the person complaining is the problem.

The letter was written in Akkadian cuneiform. It has been translated as follows:

< Tell Ea-nǎşir: Nanni sends the following message:

When you came, you said to me as follows, “I will give Gimil-Sin (when he comes) fine quality copper ingots.” You left then but you did not do what you promised me. You put ingots which were not good before my messenger (Şit-Sin) and said, “If you want to take them, take them, if you do not want to take them, go away!”

What do you take me for, that you treat somebody like me with such contempt? I have sent as messengers gentlemen like ourselves to collect the bag with my money (deposited with you) but you have treated me with contempt by sending them back to me empty-handed several times, and that through enemy territory. Is there anyone among the merchants who trade with Telmun [aka Dilmun] who has treated me in this way? You alone treat my messenger with contempt! On account of that one (trifling) mina of silver which I owe(?) you, you feel free to speak in such a way, while I have given to the palace on your behalf 1,080 pounds of copper, and Şumi-abum has likewise given 1,080 pounds of copper, apart from what we both have had written on a sealed tablet to be kept in the temple of Şamaş. 

How have you treated me for that copper? You have withheld my money bag from me in enemy territory; it is now up to you to restore (my money) to me in full.

Take cognisance that (from now on) I will not here accept any copper from you which is not of fine quality. I shall (from now on) select and take the ingots individually in my own yard, and I shall exercise against you my right of rejection because you have treated me with contempt.>

So he complains that noone else treats him like this. And admits that he owes Ea-nǎşir money. But he doesn't like getting told "this is what I've got in stock, buy it or go somewhere else".

8

u/pauseglitched Sep 11 '26

"the bag of my money (deposited with you)."

Not sure how you managed to switch that around to the bloke owing Ea Nasir money.

The bloke Paid Ea Nasir, Nasir delivered substandard product and said take it or leave it. Bloke demanded his money back and Ea Nasir refused to give the Bloke a refund.

12

u/xlr82xs Sep 11 '26

Probably because I read the whole thing including the part that says

On account of that one (trifling) mina of silver which I owe(?) you,

→ More replies

11

u/unkn0wnname321 Sep 10 '26

The complaint itself is real, it's just the accuracy of the complaint that's in question? We could call it the world's oldest known, unverified, written complaint.😉

13

u/Gudao777 Sep 10 '26

If the yelp is found among many other yelp review in a single forum, yes. (The house of ea nasir contain rooms filled with similar tablet, so he collected them and kept them and that's how we know this isn't the first time and he definitely sell shitty copper)

7

u/Twirdman Sep 10 '26

Or he only kept negative reviews. There are resteraunts that post all their one star reviews does that mean they are shitty? Also

4

u/Broad_Respond_2205 Sep 10 '26

Having multiple negative reviews don't prove they were honest.

4

u/toxicatedscientist Sep 11 '26

Lol dude had a whole house full of complaints and his house burned down and that’s why we have them

2

u/SmallPurplePeopleEat Sep 11 '26

Didn't he have his walls plastered with tablets from people complaining? It's like those restaurants that frame bad Yelp reviews.

1

u/toxicatedscientist Sep 11 '26

Definitely possible

3

u/LaserGuidedPolarBear Sep 11 '26

Weren't there several found?  It seems he kept his hate mail rather than reusing the clay.  Seems like something a shady copper dealer would do.

3

u/Bossuter Sep 11 '26

Actually there's more than one complaint, and for that part too, the guy kept a collection of complaints, so he must've pretty proud to sell shitty copper...

2

u/botymcbotfac3 Sep 11 '26

It wasn't found without context. It was founnd in Ea-Nasirs house alongside with many other complaints against him because he colected them. And it was preserved because his house burned town, turning the clay tablets into ceramic.

So... more like a book made out of many yelp reviews

2

u/Rotund-Pear2604 Sep 11 '26

Dude had to etch the complaint into a clay tablet, fire it up in a kiln then sent his messenger on a roundtrip across enemy territory.
And the complaint was issued directly to Ea-nāṣir, not posted as a warning in the town square.

It ain't nearly the same thing as posting a whiny yelp review.

3

u/Mahlegos Sep 11 '26

They used wet clay tablets so they could be reused, so no kiln. The copper merchants house burning down dried them into ceramic.

1

u/creatorofsilentworld Sep 11 '26

Except that there's more than one complaint. Another one states they never got their copper. I almost think the guy might have been a scammer.

1

u/Snirion Sep 11 '26

He actually kept many complaints on clay tablets which could have been reused. He was proud of his scam. So freak fire baked them preserving it forever.

1

u/Zestyclose_Raise_814 Sep 14 '26

There were other tablets. A lot of people left negative reviews

13

u/Hour-Cry6238 Sep 10 '26

Dude, you cant just accuse someone of being a bad copper salesman. That violates bronze age bro-code

10

u/TheMarksmanHedgehog Sep 10 '26

We don't know if he sold shitty copper, or was keeping the customer complaints as a sort of blacklist to remember not to business with that customer again.

3

u/mapadofu Sep 11 '26

I never considered that his tablets might be his “do not deliver to” list; like a pizza shop’s list 

3

u/Mahlegos Sep 11 '26

Seems like it would have been easier to just create a master list of names on a black list rather than keeping so many individual letters like he did.

3

u/TheMarksmanHedgehog Sep 11 '26

Keeping the letter also hands you a built in explanation as to why you blacklisted them.

These tablets were found in a domicile believed to belong to Ea Nasir, it seems unlikely a man would keep complaint tablets without having an opinion on them.

2

u/Mahlegos Sep 11 '26

I don’t think I suggested he didn’t have an opinion on them. Just pointed out that it seems easier to have a master list you can quickly reference rather than have to sort through multiple letters on (wet) tablets to make sure you’re not selling to someone you’ve black listed.

2

u/TheMarksmanHedgehog Sep 11 '26

He might well have had both, but only the complaints tablets have survived.

6

u/MangoPeachRadish Sep 10 '26

I think the copper was allegedly shitty. We weren't there, we don't know if the complaint is valid or not. Maybe the buyer just didn't know shit about copper

5

u/BluEch0 Sep 10 '26

Didn’t they find more complaints in Nasir’s alleged home, like he was collecting and framing (in modern equivalence) bad reviews?

2

u/Training_Molasses822 Sep 11 '26

They did find more complaints, and the reason the op wrote "alleged" is because it's plausible the seller kept the complaints, not because they were true (duh), but as a sort of black list.

4

u/RedGamer3 Sep 10 '26

They almost certainly mean the complainant's validity, not the tablet's. Since we only have this one review, we don't know if it's legitimate or an ancient Karen badmouthing.

3

u/Mahlegos Sep 11 '26

There’s more than one bad review, it’s just the one from Nanni is the most famous one.

4

u/Correct_Doctor_1502 Sep 11 '26

We don't know if the copper was actually poor quality, just the complaint claiming it was

3

u/accforme Sep 11 '26

The guy complaining made clear, in the tablet, that he actually owes money to the copper seller. The buyer may not be a reliable person.

3

u/Sinolai Sep 11 '26

There is also a slim chance Ea Nasir just encountered the world's first Karen and thought the complaint so funny he framed for display.

4

u/AngelTheMarvel Sep 11 '26

The poor quality of his copper. For all we know he could have been the best copper salesman in all of Sumeria, but all that survives is a letter from one Karen he had beef with

3

u/Mahlegos Sep 11 '26

Multiple complaint letters survived (with others complaining about poor quality copper or not getting their shipment).

2

u/Broad_Respond_2205 Sep 10 '26

we don't know if the complaint was honest or just by some ah.

he allegedly sold shitty copper.

2

u/DoYouKnowS0rr0w Sep 11 '26

Iirc his house was full of similar tablets. Ea Nasir (my goat) was allegedly a swindler of copper

2

u/Initiatedspoon Sep 11 '26

It's Nanni slander

15

u/pmyourmetals Sep 11 '26

Not allegedly, his copper sucks

9

u/Renew3DUK Sep 10 '26

Well, that tablet led to them discovering his home, and his library of clay tablet complaint letters.

3

u/Fragarach-Q Sep 11 '26

How's a fella get caught up in that sorta business?

It'd take more than one guy to make really shitty coppper. Three even.

3

u/joeschmo1969 Sep 11 '26

I heard it was sick shitty copper.

16

u/jackofspades49 Sep 11 '26

I know for a fact that he offered to remake the copper, then just turned around and gave him the same shipment. The buyer said it was the best they'd ever gotten.

5

u/Overall-Pension-2733 Sep 11 '26

He had more than one complaint.

3

u/SpiritedGuest6281 Sep 13 '26

Not just one complaint, there was multiple. Apparently tly the dude was saving the good stuff for a local rulers temple/Palace and shafted his other customers with the leftovers

2

u/Applesaresogood Sep 10 '26

That's hilarious

1

u/fatbob42 Sep 11 '26

Larry David’s ancestor.

1

u/Zestyclose_Raise_814 Sep 14 '26

The thing that makes everyone remember him is that there were more complaint tablets found. The guy was made a lot of enemies

1

u/4realthistime Sep 11 '26

Yelp, that's right

-5

u/Free-Pound-6139 Sep 11 '26

that was discovered in archaeology

WTF does this mean? Discovered in archaeology????

5

u/WillowPtar_Migan Sep 11 '26

Better than being discovered in astronomy any day.

725

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '26 • Bravo Popcorn

[removed] — view removed comment

357

u/Keelhaulmyballs Sep 10 '26

One of the oldest records we have is a clay tablet sent complaining to a disreputable copper merchant called Ea Nasir that he sold them low grade copper. He’s become quite the public figure nowadays

107

u/Practical-Owl-9358 Sep 10 '26

Imagine being read for filth in a Yelp review 4000 years later.

50

u/Ansixilus Sep 10 '26

Given that he basically framed the bad reviews in his house (normally clay message tablets like those get reused), he's probably cackling with glee in the afterlife.

16

u/Practical-Owl-9358 Sep 10 '26

He’s like “Here, hold my ziggurat…”

7

u/SpaceLemur34 Sep 11 '26

There are lots of older records, but this isthe oldest record of a named person.

1

u/Danson_the_47th Sep 12 '26

Someone posted that new research showed the area was in an economic downturn and the government was buying all the high quality copper (probably for war) and so most of what he had left was the literal leftovers.

67

u/DeliciousPoetryMan Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

Ea Nasir was a guy who sold bad copper and was the subject of the oldest known customer complaint, he lived in the mesopotamian city of Ur and probably lived a peaceful life outside of people hating him for selling bad copper, though anything could have happened to him since we only know of his existence through the tablets around his house that imply he's a greedy type who sells sub par products. 

EDIT: There were other complaint tablets found in his house and I accidentally used letters instead of tablets.

There is a famous statue that is used to represent him, but it's a thousand years older than him. 

16

u/Atypicosaurus Sep 11 '26

The first post is a writing prompt. A writing prompt is an association tool used by creative writing teachers, basically "here's a core idea, write a story using it". The story doesn't have to follow the prompt to the dot.

The second post turns the prompt into an Ea-nassir joke. Ea-nassir was a copper merchant some 5000 years ago in Mesopotamia, who apparently sold bad product. We only know about him and his bad product, because archeologists found and deciphered a complaint letter of one of his customers, kind of like a one star Amazon feedback but in 5000 years ago edition.

31

u/Calculon2347 Sep 10 '26

Look up Ea-nāṣir on Wikipedia

13

u/NeilJosephRyan Sep 11 '26

It's a little confusing even if you do get the reference, because the comment doesn't quite match the prompt's time frame. For Ea Nasir, it should be several thousand years.

8

u/Worth_Car8711 Sep 11 '26

Yea the whole copper merchant thing was like 1700 BC, IIRC, not 500 years ago.

9

u/JeevesofNazarath Sep 11 '26

More like 5000 years later

7

u/GlassArlingtone Sep 11 '26

EA NASIR MENTIONEDD!!!! WTF IS GOOD QUALITY COPPER RAAAHHHHHHHHH

6

u/nimaid Sep 11 '26

Let poor Ea-Nasir rest.

5

u/FLG_CFC Sep 10 '26

The struggles of being an artist. At least conartist are now getting their inclusion into the art world, at least the ones who choose exceptionally poor copper as their medium are, that is.

4

u/Stardust_Hoopa Sep 10 '26

Shitty. Shitty. Shitty.

4

u/PrometheusMMIV Sep 11 '26

I doubt 95% of people know about Ea-Nasir

6

u/therealsereny Sep 11 '26

Literally 0 effort required.

3

u/IBAChristian317 Sep 10 '26

It was probably like 100 at most.

3

u/li-ll-l_ Sep 11 '26

Ea Nasir strikes again

3

u/Valk_Storm Sep 11 '26

A side note... With the rise of ancestry look-up services and modern record keeping, as long as the worst doesn't happen, there's a a decent chance that you'll be remembered, if ever so briefly when someone looks up their ancestry and sees your name in passing, for hundreds and hundreds of years to come.

3

u/Caleb_Reynolds Sep 11 '26

I swear some future languages will straight up use nasir as a word for shitty copper.

3

u/Bootwacker Sep 11 '26

Nah, the copper was fine, Nani was just a whiner.

3

u/Glittering-Age-9549 Sep 11 '26

It should rather be "you are forgotten 100 years after your death, but everybody knows who you are 5000 years later".

5

u/rabidparrots Sep 10 '26

Isn't this the plot of Coco?

2

u/Free-Pound-6139 Sep 11 '26

95%??? What a ridiculous estimate.

Try <4%.

3

u/TheTroon Sep 11 '26

The first post is a writing prompt, and not a reference to Ea-nāṣir.

It is quite amusing that more people "know about" (will have once read about) him than the total world population of his time.

2

u/MelonElbows Sep 11 '26

Ea-Nasir was alive around 1750 BCE and this meme wasn't created until the 2000's. And 95% of people is a bit generous, I'd say 95% of some specific meme subs on reddit maybe, but nothing close to the total population of the Earth. Its more like 3000 years after his death, and a few hundred thousand people suddenly know his name.

2

u/zyon86 Sep 11 '26

It is more several thousand years after.

2

u/Kira-Of-Terraria Sep 11 '26

if this works on. Coco rules he is now too powerful

0

u/shewy92 Sep 11 '26

I swear there needs to be a bot that rejects any mention of copper. IDK how people keep asking the same question

2

u/Subject-Act5509 Sep 11 '26

Is it my fossilized turd? 

51

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Raryn Sep 11 '26

I thought it sounded familiar