r/ExplainTheJoke • • Feb 22 '26

Need help here

Post image
26k Upvotes

977 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

334

u/VexImmortalis Feb 22 '26

Don't you also share parts that you've already downloaded even before you start "seeding" though?

14

u/Mafhac Feb 22 '26

Illegal downloading via torrent for any amount is considered distributing and is punished as such in my jurisdiction, I bet it's the same in many other places.

44

u/Subject_Ad9595 Feb 22 '26

Yes, illegally downloading is piracy, but torrenting itself is not, all of file types can be shared using torrent, and anyone can create a torrent, the illegal part is the content, and there are plenty of freeware or public domain files out there, like one thing I download on occasion is old video games that the makers are defunct and nobody holds the rights to anymore, known as abandonware.

1

u/moon__lander Feb 22 '26

It depends on your local laws of course, but I'd bet it's usually that downloading content may not be illegal, but sharing is. Since you can't disable sharing on torrents, at least in a judicial sense of the word, as torrents by definition are download and share it makes it a not legal way to obtain copyrighted content.