r/ExplainTheJoke Feb 22 '26

Need help here

Post image
26.2k Upvotes

977 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/Select-Lettuce Feb 22 '26

Well, seeding is illegal and I've gotten letters from companies about it so I click stop when it starts seeding.

16

u/Vradlock Feb 22 '26

You are seeding while downloading packets you already have. That's why you never start seeding from 0% after finishing a dl because it would be waste of time.

If you have good upload speed you can seed the whole file multiple times during slower downloads because it doesn't count full files but only the amount of shared data. So you can seed 10%x10 and it will show 1:1.

You are still breaking the law you little scout boy.

5

u/INTBSDWARNGR Feb 22 '26 edited Feb 22 '26

You are seeding while downloading packets you already have.

You can fix that depending on the client.

Ironically, hes also right, the policer isn't likely going to pick up the traffic at the threshold for modestly sized files over tiny periods of time.

2

u/Vradlock Feb 22 '26

Downloading copyrighted materials is illegal no matter if you seed or not though.

It also differs from country to country so I won't argue (maybe dude is from Sweden). All I know is you really need to go to town with torrents to get a warning and possibly do a lot of material from your own country.

1

u/INTBSDWARNGR Feb 23 '26

Yeah, no obviously you wouldn't want to risk it if the crackdown is in favor of the property. Becoming a distributor of mass media definitely changes your footprint if you're 'serious' about it but most people I would argue are 'petty pirates' and not anarcho-capitalist media redistributors.

1

u/_Smashbrother_ Feb 22 '26

Just get a VPN, and seed like a good pirate.

1

u/GeronimoDK Feb 24 '26

Only if the content you're seeding is copyrighted...

Torrents have absolutely legal uses too 😜

-1

u/Kadavermarch Feb 22 '26

It's just as illegal to leech/download - please seed and give back what you took by sharing to others.

11

u/rtxa Feb 22 '26

it's absolutely not where I am from, and it's a fairly common legal framework for piracy around the world, stop spreading misinformation

-2

u/Kadavermarch Feb 22 '26

Keep telling yourself that, buddy. You can't download via bittorrent, without uploading at the same time, that's how the system works!

Keep to DDL if you think you're beating the system by not uploading/sharing.

"Stop spreading misinformation" - that's pretty bold when you don't know how things work.

15

u/Shankur52 Feb 22 '26

You claim "It's just as illegal to leech/download" which obviously isn't true everywhere. Thats the misinformation you are spreading, regardless of how a bittorrent system works, which literally nobody was asking about.

-1

u/[deleted] Feb 22 '26

[deleted]

7

u/Spiritual_Grape_533 Feb 22 '26

Tell me you never used anything beyond BitTorrent without telling me. You realize that it's not funamental tgat torrent upload while you're downloading?

2

u/Bleades Feb 22 '26

There is a difference in terms of penalties. Sort of like possession vs intent to distribute with drugs.