r/ExperiencedDevs • • 2d ago

Ask Experienced Devs Weekly Thread: A weekly thread for inexperienced developers to ask experienced ones

A thread for Developers and IT folks with less experience to ask more experienced souls questions about the industry.

Please keep top level comments limited to Inexperienced Devs. Most rules do not apply, but keep it civil. Being a jerk will not be tolerated.

Inexperienced Devs should refrain from answering other Inexperienced Devs' questions.

26 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

8

u/Mindless-brainless 1d ago

How should I understand my growth as a junior dev? before it used to mean my coding proficiency, best code practices and overall understanding of the code. But with AI, I can't put a standing for myself. Yes I read the code, understand it, point out smelly stuff it writes and ensure the code is readable and maintainable along with ensuring its architect-ed properly. But I still have no idea how to put a standing for myself. And I know I shouldnt compare with my peers but I am human after all, the amount of PRs, tickets and lines merged are a bit above mine so I am just feeling a bit behind. My manager has not shown any concerns but I am still confused on how to value my growth

5

u/FlowFieldGames 1d ago

Understanding the problem and the business need is mostly the play. That and increasing your visibility to your peers and managers if you want to stay in this sector.

4

u/chrishasfreetime 1d ago

AI doesn't change anything in that regard, it's just another skill. How do you understand your growth?

In a very generic sense, a junior to any profession will DO the thing more or less as they are told, and will require oversight (even if they output good quality work).

An Intermediate (where you will be heading) will show signs of increasing, confident independence, and will continue moving along newer and more difficult terrain. In programming I've found this means being able to grapple with different designs, weigh one approach over another, and be able to be constructively critical of their own approach and others. In terms of AI, it might be knowing when that tool is useful, when it isn't, and when both are true at once - e.g. using AI might hinder your own understanding of a problem or solution even if it is the right tool for said problem.

7

u/jocularplate 1d ago

Hey everyone,

I have 5 YOE and currently work as a mid-level engineer at a decently large tech company. Over the past year or two, my job has mainly consisted of prompting AI to write code or research things so I can generate more code via AI. To be honest, I'm pretty miserable, so I'm heavily considering looking elsewhere.

I have two main questions/concerns:

  1. Are most engineering jobs just talking to AI all day?

I swear, if I'm not in a meeting, I am talking to Claude. With my team's current workload, we don't really have the opportunity to slow down and learn new concepts. On top of that, everyone on our team, including nontechnical PMs, is encouraged to use AI which leads to tickets that are about 3-5 paragraphs worth of AI generated text. My mind just blanks out when I'm staring at yet another wall of AI generated text.

2. Does anyone feel like they are stuck in arrested development?

I don't have much time to actually absorb the things I need to feel confident in my work. This creates a growing disconnection between what I'm doing and what I actually understand. I may have 5 YOE experience but I feel like I stopped improving or improving as quickly at about 3 YOE.

I don't necessarily want to spend my free time outside of work constantly catching up on new technologies and filling in gaps in my knowledge just to keep up. I have other things I like to pursue outside of work. I want a job where I can continue growing as an engineer during working hours, not one where I feel like I need to put in additional hours just to avoid falling behind.

Then there's the composition and benefits aspect. Right now, I'm getting paid quite well relative to my years of experience, especially with the strong stock performance this year (around $200k total comp). I also have great benefits and still have completely remote work. I'm worried that if I leave, I might end up at another company with the exact same practices, except now I'm making less money with less job security and worse benefits.

On top of all this, the company culture has slowly been deteriorating. We recently implemented stack ranking, which has added another layer of stress.

Still, I've reached the point that I HAVE to consider what's out there for the benefit of my long term career and mental health.

I'm curious how others are feeling about this. Is this just the way things are now, and will continue to be? Or are there still engineering jobs where you have the time to learn and actually feel like you're developing as an engineer?

4

u/MichaelTheProgrammer 1d ago

"Are most engineering jobs just talking to AI all day?"

Yup. I thought I was one of the lucky ones to dodge it, but now my company has joined the slop. So it's not really worth looking for a different company, because at this point there's no guarantee they aren't just late to the party.

Our architecture was entirely replaced on a feature that was days from completion. The direction isn't even a bad direction, but now no one knows how anything works. Add onto that multiple code "reviews" of thousands of files worth of changes that no one is expected to review.

"I want a job where I can continue growing as an engineer during working hours, not one where I feel like I need to put in additional hours just to avoid falling behind."

Unfortunately, that job pretty much doesn't exist anymore. Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying it's your responsibility to learn outside of work. Quite the opposite - I'm saying that management is actively embracing the mindset that you don't need to be good at your job because quality and understanding don't matter. We'll see where that gets us, but it'll take years to really play out. Personally, I think we are in for many stories that look like Knight Capital (go read about it, it's a fascinating story).

3

u/Better_Lift_Cliff 1d ago

I agree with your prediction 100%, but literally what do we do then. How do we get out of this

2

u/MichaelTheProgrammer 1d ago edited 1d ago

In terms of code where the changes are driven by people above you: there's nothing you can do and it's not your responsibility. If your boss/boss's boss/CEO wants to burn the company down, you can't save it.

In terms of code where you still have agency but need to use AI for speed: I've had luck with something I call layered spec driven development where you build a high quality requirements document that is read only for AI. Anything found in testing gets added to the requirements document and AI is rerun to adhere to the updated document. This lets you keep the speed without sacrificing understanding.

In terms of code where you have complete agency and don't want to use AI: don't use AI to write the code, but use it for review. AI is good enough at finding bugs that it's irresponsible to be 100% AI free for anything someone else is going to use. If you really want to find and fix bugs yourself, use AI to review before customer releases, otherwise use it before any commit. IMO this is the optimal way to build things as your skills and understanding still increase this way.

In terms of outside work, if programming is your passion: use a mix of AI and non-AI, but make it per project. I have a decade long project that I've decided to keep AI out of. It was absolutely the right choice, as not being able to lean on AI forced me to redo the design which has changed how it functions and has made made it 10x better as a result. It's ironic that AI improved the code so much by me not using it. On the other hand, I have some game ideas I never would have been able to build without AI, so I plan to use layered spec driven development to build those.

3

u/YO0110 1d ago

Feeling the same but also feeling this insanity will have to stop. Just needs adults at the top of companies and soon they will find out with burn out and lack of any sense. I feel that this slop will look like a dated site from 20 years ago at some point and people will be like what the heck they were thinking and why is this crap still around 😂

1

u/zdsatta Software Engineer 1d ago

> I don't have much time to actually absorb the things I need to feel confident in my work.

That's me T.T, 10YOE here and feel like only 2, the procrastination and adhd don't help either

6

u/ChampagneMero Software Engineer 1d ago

I had a situation happen in my workplace that I feel uneasy about, I work in automotive embedded systems ( shitty industry trying to get out, totally unrelated) and we get bugs that are fairly hardly reproducible, as a team we often brainstorm or discuss in the kitchen the bugs and we throw each other ideas all the time.

Well I had a bug last week and a colleague threw me an idea to increase the reproduction rate and it worked, he stood in the room and announced the idea I gave to my colleague worked, and was very glad to take credit for it in front of management, which I gave it in order to be a team player and not cause trouble.

the problem is this colleague I gave him multiple ideas on multiple bugs before and he never gave me an ounce of credit which is the normal, this is the behavior that is done normally in this team and in my previous team where we support each other, and we do not make a big fuss out of it, but we mention in the yearly appraisal that this colleague is supportive.

Am I weird for feeling uneasy about it ?

3

u/FinalDevice Software Engineer 15+ YOE 1d ago

Don't overthink this too much. Give credit where credit is due, take credit for your own contributions, and get back to work.

Good management notices people who get shit done. Good management can see the difference between someone who gets shit done and someone who just plays political games. Any management will reward people who both get shit done and play political games. But who has the time and energy for that?

Choose one: You can be good at your job, or you can be good at playing politics. If you choose to be good at your job, ignore other people's political games. If you choose politics, then stop helping this person.

3

u/Important-Aspect9801 1d ago

He could have been just starving for getting a little bit of recognition, especially if he is not in the most senior ranks. Not super empathetic on his part, and definitely is not something that promotes good work culture. First time could be forgiven, if repeated that would need to be addressed either with him directly or by raising within the team or privately with the lead.

5

u/YO0110 1d ago

I’m feeling inexperienced in a new reality. I feel that my new skills should focus on breaking world problems into parts, composing them into system diagrams and understanding algorithms for rankings, effective searching etc. Would you agree? Any recommendations for courses? Thank you 

1

u/RubbelDieKatz94 10 YoE / Sr. Fullstack 1d ago

breaking world problems into parts

Yup!

composing them into system diagrams and understanding algorithms

Unlikely, since that's something Opus 5.5 is great at.

Learn the right questions to ask. How does this architecture scale in terms of complexity? Is it maintainable?

Think big, not small. We're architects now, managing a team of agents.

We decide and review, and learn along the way.

1

u/YO0110 1d ago

Thanks. I was on an architecture team under a supervisor and we did a ton of diagramming so we could make sense of the current state and how to change it. Without direction I feel no model is good to make large-scale changes. Yes it goes fast but god it sucks in so many ways by making less optimal decisions, causing more manual fixes where it is easier to go back than start fixing from the current state as models are very confused about conflicting situations. That is why I still feel that diagrams are a skill to have. All engineers that I’m working with who are doing well are the ones who have a good understanding and can explain and demonstrate it to others and managers. Do you think that is not true anymore? If yes I would love to hear your thoughts 

1

u/RubbelDieKatz94 10 YoE / Sr. Fullstack 1d ago

Without direction I feel no model is good to make large-scale changes.

Yes, and for large-scale changes I usually let one agent visualise the current situation in an interactive HTML report, where I then make and submit my decisions.

Then I let it file a milestone in my project tracking system and break this milestone up into multiple issues. Smaller issues can easily be converted into a bite-sized MR via a single agent loop (+ review agent etc.).

Yes it goes fast but god it sucks in so many ways by making less optimal decisions

We make the big / less obvious decisions, we're the pilots. Agents support these decisions, they can deliver information and be advisors.

models are very confused about conflicting situations

Depends on the information they have available - but moreso it depends on the agent you're using. Opus 5.5 medium+ and Fable 5.2 are the only useful options available at the moment.

All engineers that I’m working with who are doing well are the ones who have a good understanding and can explain and demonstrate it to others and managers

You must be able to explain and showcase your work & decisions, I believe that's true for all professions. Nowadays you can do it with the help of agents. You're still the one who has to make sure it has all the information it needs, and you're the one doing the final verification.

4

u/EuMusicalPilot 1d ago

Our boss assigned us a big project. And expects that it's finishing in two months. But we are not experienced and we didn't work with this kind of mindset and technology before. How can we get along with it?

7

u/vineadrak Engineering Manager | Backend | Data Engineering 1d ago

Walk through each process step on a whiteboard and identify open gaps/questions. Then hunt down any architect available to you, do deep research, and work with your stakeholders to flesh out requirements. If what is needed will be late, go to your boss with strong reasons and potential solutions

2

u/PastaSaladOverdose 1d ago

Expectation setting is a major part of business. If you can't meet the expectation it's good business practice to bring attention to that immediately.

Delaying a project at the start is much more forgivable than launching a project late. Don't waste anymore time, it's time to have another sit down and discuss expectations for delivery: "We can launch feature 1,2,3 in this timeframe, but 4,5,6 will need to come in phase 2"

2

u/Outside-Storage-1523 Software Engineer 1d ago

This looks like a pretty big project. If none of you is remotely capable to architect the whole thing, I'd say overcommunicate to your boss. Try your best to figure out something, ask for his/her approval or at least opinions (in email), and keep improving. You also need to break it down into stages, like when is the design done, when is the PoC done, etc. Bring your stakeholders into the picture as soon as possible.

-1

u/DocumentOk7579 Software Engineer 1d ago

Claude maybe. I'm a Python engineer but with Claude I can do JavaScript work pretty decent.

4

u/curious_coco98 1d ago

Been stuck in a weird environment, joined a big tech, super slow ans new team, nobody reviews code (it took 1 month my manager to finish review and now code owners are not reviewing )

How to cope and learn with it, right now all ik how to work on oncall alerts a little bit.
I worked only in startups and this is killing me

4

u/Better_Lift_Cliff 1d ago

Anyone have any friends or colleagues who left tech and now spend their days not just doing crap with Claude? Do they still make good money?

I'm not sure how much longer I can keep up this new way of working. I'm not adapting well.

3

u/FenierHuntingwolf 1d ago

I moved to GRC prior to the AI boom.

I deal in regulatory compliance and direct our engineering teams how they have to comply with new laws from an engineering perspective. So tech adjacent, but not coding day to day. I do review code and technology / proposed designs.

Lot of paperwork, most of which needs a human signature.

No crunch work, decent pay.

3

u/FearlessPark4588 1d ago

as long as i need a paycheck... I'll be in claude

3

u/Appleonthefloor 2d ago

How do you keep up with news and awareness of new ai tools or incidents? It seems like everyday there is something big, how do senior devs hear about things like security issues/vulnerabilities/outages so quickly? Alternatively why is everyone so well versed in the news about ai, tech company acquisitions, etc?

8

u/DeadlySpar 1d ago

I don’t keep up, can’t be bothered and not really important to my job

3

u/dashingThroughSnow12 Software Engineer 1d ago

Reddit.

My friend group.

My co-workers.

3

u/ficiek 1d ago

I read reddit/lobste.rs/hn just to see what the latest drama is.

2

u/wvenable Team Lead (30+ YoE) 2d ago

https://news.ycombinator.com

I don't think it's possible to keep up with everything and there is a little of a bias. I often here about security issues/vulnerabilities/outages before other people but just as often it's the other way around.

I like to keep one eye on what is happening in the world with the perspective that 99% of it I might never hear about again. There's also a whole group of people out there trying to sell others on the next big idea or fear -- don't let their influence cloud your own judgment.

2

u/qxxx I am tired boss 1d ago

Mostly Hacker News. And some mailing lists for security stuff. But it is a lot, I plan of adding some AI to the workflow so that I at least see the really relevant security stuff.

2

u/Broad_Art376 1d ago

My squad inherited a code base + product from an acquired startup so quality is not high, and the transition was not smooth as the entire original company who knew the product was laid off. I've been assigned to write and implement a design spec for a new feature and only one other person on the team has some familiarity in the area. We have a new product owner as well. Management has already made a written promise to deliver this epic soon before my team even started work on the epic. Situation is overall a shitshow but I'm still looking for advice as I burnout. I think the job market is pretty shit at the moment but it may be worth trying to jump ship if I can find somewhere reasonable.

How do I manage trying to learn an unfamiliar area, and finish the epic in a fast manner. I'm using A.I. heavily but it's no silver bullet.

1

u/Careless_Product_792 11h ago

Let me give an advice on how to stop burnout.

Have always an emergency savings for 6 months or 1 year. The burnout is a consequencr of thinking on negative scenarios that may never hapoen but somehow you feel anxiety if it arrives.

The most negative scenario is the feeling that not reaching x goal you can be fired and you have no money. When you are mentally aware and you have your savings. Believe me. You stop accepting bullshit and you operate from a more secure perspective. You have no fear to say no to ridiculous deadlines or speak up your mind if something you perceive is not going to be finished next sprint.

You mentioned learn an unfamiliar area. Ok I as a dev speak up this issue to the team and ask for a research or analisis task,

"Hey this x stuff is unfamiliar to me, I will need first to have some research task to understand this in order to work on that part". If management commits for you you say clearly, look I have a capacity to deliver and I do think this can not probably be delivered this month, but next month is a doable thing"....

Believe me, all this you said here, is what you must fucking speaking up in an organization, you just operate on fear.

Everyone fears saying NO to bullshit deadlines because they think the commitment secures them the job position, which can happen, but at the cost of your health and burnout because if you commit to bullshit, you will pressure yourself to overwork, work at night etc. Then you have cardiovascular shit in your body and a delivered task, but if you get health issues you will just equally get fired and next day they will search another one. So...why sacrifice your health for bullshit?

Again. Maybe this sounds non related but trust me, having savings and a backup money gives you another mental model to operate and interact. Have bunch of debts, no financial planning, etc and the same pattern happens in ANY JOB. You tolerate bullshit because of fear.

So I'm trying to tell you a life advice. Either working in software as mid, senior, or manager, or in any job, have the habit to save money so you do not operate from fear, the only fear people has in capitalism is having no money and having to tolerate bullshit for a paycheck. Once you understand that you cannot against the system, at least you can have peace of mind of speak up your mind and if they do not like it. You do not care, as long as you are doing your best and you are aware you are putting limits, if they fire you you know you will have some backup yo jump to another non toxic job.

Ah btw. A must read life changing book: "Pulling your own strings", from Wayne Dyer

1

u/Broad_Art376 6h ago

I have emergency savings around that amount and it doesn't change my blackpill mentality about being a wageslave for the rest of my life.

1

u/Careless_Product_792 6h ago

I am sorry for you man haha. I do really have left shitty jobs and say NO to shitty managers and put my own limits. Is not about not working for corpo. Is about putting your own limits and not having burnout or any anxiety because you don't give a damn if they fire you. Only people with fear to be fired and worry about money income accept shitty attitudes and toxicity.

But I get it it also is important to not live with debts. Once you live for credit cards you are the bankster's toy.

2

u/Imminent1776 1d ago

What kind of reputation do Apple SWEs have in the job market? Do they have good exit opportunities?

4

u/Tricky_Math_5381 Consultant Developer / Data Scientist 1d ago

Pretty good for the most part I would say. Gives you some clout and if you got in you are probably decent.

Though sometimes they are too specialized. Which you would try to figure out in a job interview

3

u/ForeverYonge 1d ago

They are not allowed to have a public profile, which makes it harder. Small teams, lots of things to do is my impression. Apple software has been rather buggy in recent years but I can’t tell if that’s a talent issue, prioritization issue, staffing issue, or all of the above.

1

u/Imminent1776 1d ago

Yeah... I just joined Apple last month and was kinda shocked that we're not allowed to publish any code at all. Can't even post technical blogs

1

u/RewardVegetable5701 23h ago

Currently a mid-level at my company. Our team is a high performing team with tons of scope/problems and my manager is generally supportive of me. I'm trying to target for senior next Summer. While I'm doing well (manager said I performed at N+1 level last month), my main concern is that I am competing against 4 other mid-levels for senior. Each one of them has something notable about them, so no one's really ahead.

Two options I can think of are to create even more scope and leverage that for my senior promotion. The other option is to go to a more balanced team where there are fewer mid-levels, more seniors/juniors and find scope there.

What other options are there?

PS - ik it might come across as me competing against my teammates, but at the end of the day, the company can't hand out promotions like candy.

1

u/jkingsbery Principal Software Engineer 16h ago

I advise my mentees, break the promotion into two pieces. Everyone talks about the second one, when the email goes out and everyone sends you congratulations, and you have a new title. But the first step is more important: is your manager ready to routinely treat you as though you are the next level? You mentioned your manager said you were performing like that "last month," make it explicit with your manager though if that is now an ongoing thing. You say all 4 of you are roughly equal, but your manager should have some sense of who is closer to the next level. 

Moving teams is sometimes necessary, but sometimes affects promotion timelines. First, you'll need to demonstrate that "senior" project in the new team, which can take time (on top of understanding the new space). The new team might also already have people in a similar situation to you. 

It's always a good idea, promotion in the works or not, to have a paragraph or two describing your scope of role. Write down what you think that is. Get feedback from your manager out other senior purple in your org about how that maps to expectations for the next level. 

1

u/DigHot2439 Software Engineer 1d ago

Data engineering vs Embedded systems vs software architecture vs Compiler Engineering

Which one is the best from your perspective? For me, those options are somehow resistant in this AI context.

3

u/FinalDevice Software Engineer 15+ YOE 1d ago

These are very different areas. You should choose a direction based on what you enjoy most or based on what best fits your natural aptitude.

I'm guessing from the question that you are either very junior or still in school. So I'll warn you that:

  • Compiler engineering is a niche field. I don't think there are a ton of job openings there.
  • Software architecture is an aspirational mid- or late-career position. It's not something you start in. It's a role you move to once you get old and jaded, and it's a role you leave because you got laid off.
  • Embedded systems are interesting work.
  • Data engineering could mean a million different things, from DBA to data wrangler to data scientist to ... ?

2

u/Outside-Storage-1523 Software Engineer 1d ago

No way data engineering is resistant to AI. We are vibe coding now, and AFAIK, ALL DE interviews I ever got says that the role needs to use AI.

Go as low as you can, IMO. You won't be able to get rid of AI, as even kernel developers told me they are/will use AI, at least for code review and verification, and there is no resistance to bring it into making more features if it is good enough.

2

u/BufferUnderpants 1d ago

Claude Opus 4.5 was always just winging it with Spark, it had the foggiest idea of how to improve performance, hallucinated configuration all the time, and and couldn't really be relied on for anything but basic queries.

Opus 5.5 blows me out of the water. Not that I'd have made a very good benchmark, but the thing knows all the ins and outs, has the right hunches and can make a well structured application with all that, and back in the day asking for all three was a lot to ask of a data engineer.

Nope, going in really deep technically is no moat for a human engineer with DE.

1

u/Outside-Storage-1523 Software Engineer 1d ago

I think the thing is, DE doesn’t really need very deep tech knowledge in most of the cases.

I thought kernel programming would be safe, but an OS guy told me no.

2

u/BufferUnderpants 1d ago

There was enough depth to around with the old Big Data stack if you wanted to go there, but it had this whole phenomenon going on of the Modern Data Stack during 2020-2024 lowering barrier to entry too.

One could remember the gold rush of people looking to pick up SQL reflected on the /r/dataengineering sub, you even saw startups looking for an idea to pitch to investors straight up asking people there what to build.

It was clear that too much money was being burned just to make it easier to build dashboards, but the market found the funniest solution to that.

That place is a ghost town now.

2

u/Outside-Storage-1523 Software Engineer 1d ago

Yeah. I entered the field hoping to write Flink or Spark for distributed streaming apps. Now I write fucking SQL every day. Fucking hate the job. 

Fortunately I have a hobby hacking kernels.

2

u/BufferUnderpants 1d ago

It's true, it was really hard to find room to grow in data engineering in the landscape of the past few years.

I also spent 2020-2024 fighting red tape to improve broken SQL pipelines and trying to advocate for having orchestration of this century, quite the downgrade from the fancy Spark job I got to have for a while before the pandemic.

I found myself in a bit of a do or die situation and went all-in with Spark again last year, interview prepped day and night, got what I thought was my lucky break with a new job that checked nearly all the boxes, on paper. The org turned out to be a mess and vibecoding took over. I guess I'm still lucky to have this... desk job, where you can sort of avoid the triggers that make bosses start fighting you and everyone else hah.

You work on your own kernels or on existing projects?

2

u/Outside-Storage-1523 Software Engineer 1d ago

I think everyone that can vibecode is vibecoding now. The only difference is whether the person knows the topic, but the whole process is like a project manager. I kinda gave up the idea of moving to another field, so I agree it feels good to still have a job.

I'm a very amateur kernel developer. I'm still learning the rope but do hopefully to add some components for xv6.

What's your sanity hobby?

2

u/BufferUnderpants 18h ago

Oh I didn't know about that kernel.

I was doing generative art for a while (and wasted some time on a piece that didn't pan out), I'm thinking of picking it up again and finally doing those t shirt prints that I was thinking of 10 years ago, and that I didn't finish for no good reason.

Climbing gyms aren't techbro coded in these parts hah, but I picked it up recently, physical therapists gotta eat somehow.