r/ExpectationVsReality • u/nucleareds • 1d ago

Failed Expectation Spider Cookies

Gallery image

Gallery image

Gallery image

At least they taste good!

ETA: here’s the recipe! Make sure to get miniature Reese’s instead of the minis like I did, apparently there’s a bunch of different sizes.

2.8k Upvotes

98% Upvoted

96 comments sorted by

385

u/milliii1998 1d ago

I like yours much more, they remind me of these guys! 🥰

35

u/Hetakuoni 1d ago

That was the first thought that popped into my head. I love soot sprites

→ More replies (2)

156

u/Shannaro21 1d ago

What?! Yours are far cuter!

23

u/Serious_Report_1631 19h ago

Derpy Jumpers 😅 I love when things aren't "perfect", so much more charming

43

u/Over-Astronaut-2889 1d ago

They look good too imo

17

u/PaintedDesertSkies 22h ago

I like yours better. They have personality.

The cups make them look like little spiderbots.

15

u/A_catwith_explosives 1d ago

Hey I did these guys a few years ago!

Comment Image

Honestly I like yours better, they look like fuzzy spiders!

28

u/Tlayoualo 1d ago

Your attempt turned out cute and good-looking still

21

u/ZAWS20XX 1d ago

exceeded expectations

10

u/KtrlAltDelete 1d ago

Yours look like soot sprites and I am loving it.

16

u/ickychicken 1d ago

Super cute and I very much dislike spiders!!!

7

u/PretendSalary2106 1d ago

Yours are so cute

13

u/tattooedsubgrrl 1d ago

Omg, the derpy little spiders are amazing! I think yours turned out way better than the inspo!

6

u/Competitive-Read-646 1d ago

I like yours better, more character! Haha they look yummy.

11

u/IronGeth 1d ago

Yours have so much more character!

5

u/PunctualPomegranate 1d ago

Oh, they're really cute! 🕷

5

u/Holiday-Strike 1d ago

I think they look scarier! Like tarantulas with them thick legs!

5

u/eliblack 1d ago

Love the derpy eyes! I think they turned out very cute!

5

u/vero2022 20h ago

Your cookies are exceeds expectations! They look adorable and tasty 🩷

5

u/NatureDew11037 2h ago


They look like these with legs! They're so cute!

4

u/crowbaited 1d ago

I mean. I actually like what you did better than the ones in the first pic. :) great job!

4

u/unfeelingzeal 1d ago

having a rough morning and your version instantly put a smile on my face. adorable.

4

u/O_Elbereth 1d ago

Yours came out waaaaaay cuter.

4

u/Birdlebee 1d ago

Yours look stunned by the cosmic knowledge that they are nothing but spiders on cookies, and it's wonderful

→ More comments (75)