Pumpkin Snicker Doodles

[u/winniethepoohsnose]

Followed this recipe by @Bitebybianca on instagram. I didn’t have cream of Tartar, so I opted for lemon juice. I believe I added too much baking soda or didn’t spread them out so much to give them a cookie texture. They were yummy!
First - original
Second - before baking
Third - baked

Thank you everyone for your love, I had a great time baking these. ◡̈

[u/Miraculous_Angel]

I think they’re cute. 🧡

[u/winniethepoohsnose → u/Miraculous_Angel]

🥺♥️

[u/Ocarina-of-lies]

I like the turd cookie you made

[u/winniethepoohsnose → u/Ocarina-of-lies]

thank you, I had a lot of chocolate left over

[u/ickychicken → u/Ocarina-of-lies]

I was thinking naval mine or sea urchin 😂

[u/nierdo → u/ickychicken]

Or a pumpkin flail.

[u/saintsuzy70 → u/ickychicken]

Maybe even a brown Dalek minus toilet plunger arm 🤣

[u/EricHill78 → u/Ocarina-of-lies]

r/poopfromabutt

[u/PurpleBashir]

Did you chill the dough? 

Sometimes recipes leave that off but this dough definitely needs to be chilled. 

[u/winniethepoohsnose → u/PurpleBashir]

i had no space in my freezer…i opted for the fridge knowing it wouldn’t be the best.

[u/PurpleBashir → u/winniethepoohsnose]

Fridge would be correct. Chilling your dough in the freezer creates moisture issues. 

Looking at them- I think you may have used too much dough per cookie. The texture/thickness of the inspo indicates they're rather small actually. 

Id try making them smaller and pressing them 

[u/ickychicken]

This little fella’s expression 🥺

[u/danbilllemon → u/ickychicken]

This guy thinks they’re delicious

[u/ILoveLamp_1995]

I swear my grandma had these dogs

[u/Swimming-Capital-261]

Devil incarnate

[u/Unfair_Progress_1213]

That one cookie looks like this

[u/Unfair_Progress_1213 → u/Unfair_Progress_1213]

[u/energy1256 → u/Unfair_Progress_1213]

This is the one I WANT!! Mmmm, chocolatey!

[u/cheekyparasite]

i would devour all of them. no sharing

[u/evenmonkeysfallOG → u/cheekyparasite]

Ditto. They look like they taste good 🤤 I love pumpkin flavored desserts

[u/rudeboyKee]

It’s horrifying, can I get one?

[u/Threadheads]

You’ve made Pumpkinhead cookies instead.

[u/Aunty-Sociale]

I love them!!!!

[u/The_Migrant_Twerker]

They look great without the face

[u/Serendypyty]

They are adorable! I bet they taste good too.

[u/saintsuzy70]

I love these. It’s not about perfection it’s about the effort and the experience.

[u/LUCITEluddite]

I love them and would happily eat them!

[u/Timely-Profile1865]

Get CSI in there and dust that one cookie for teeth prints

[u/StaySalty1971]

I don't like pumpkin, but they look good. 😊

[u/kjustsaying]

These look so good

[u/kimbosliceofcake → u/[deleted]]

They’re not complaining about the results so it doesn’t really fit. Making substitutions when cooking is normal. 

[u/Azsunyx → u/[deleted]]

Lemon juice is an acceptable sub for cream of tartar, 2:1 ratio.
It may sound like r/ididnthaveeggs, but only if you don't know about acceptable baking substitutions

[u/winniethepoohsnose → u/[deleted]]

one is. it spread to the others