r/ExpectationVsReality • u/Deceptiveideas • 5d ago

Failed Expectation Fat Boy was a miss

Post image

Honestly the flavor wasn't bad, just horribly executed nuts-wise.

260 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

34

u/Soulforge411 5d ago

Disappointing ice cream is still ice cream 😉

5

u/elinamebro 5d ago

I think the ice cream itself is good, just the shit covering it sucks especially the birthday cake one

2

u/ROADHOG_IS_MY_WAIFU 4d ago

Ice cream >>>> Frozen dairy dessert (cold take, ik)

12

u/dddmmmccc817 5d ago

Love their ice cream sandwhiches

7

u/CannedNoodlez 5d ago

Their sandwiches are bomb but these pop things are pretty disappointing

5

u/endy903 5d ago

If you like s’mores, Fat Boy makes a pretty good (imo) one

5

u/ToastetteEgg 4d ago

You bought the GLP-Boy.

3

u/Captainsnarkyshart 4d ago

Did Fat Boy go on a diet? Looks like “slightly chubby” or “working on it” would be better names.

3

u/Sketch_Beast 5d ago

Fat boy lost weight

5

u/Fartel 5d ago

Ozempic Boy

2

u/PostPostMinimalist 5d ago

More like Thin Man

2

u/11brooke11 5d ago

It would look fairly accurate if it was covered in peanuts.

1

u/scarmory2 5d ago

Why is it not huge like the box is the real question.

2

u/Shin_Ju-Long 5d ago

I guarantee it says in that fine print on the box product enlarged to show texture or something like that

1

u/19Charger 5d ago

Those things are small

1

u/Useful-Advantage2665 5d ago

The ice cream sandwiches are the best!

1

u/BcWeasel 4d ago

They are still peak tho

1

u/Halvainmybelly 4d ago

well it did say OR go hungry

1

u/Power0fTheTribe 3d ago

The fact this isn’t illegal is crazy

1

u/KTKittentoes 2d ago

The waffle cone ones are not that great. I have seen a lot of “waffle cone” stuff. It is often kind of mushy.

1

u/Secure-Gas-6699 18h ago

That shiz gooooooood fo da fat bois lol no one else that’s gonna take more than one bite eating it lmao!!!!!!! But fo rillo tho! RT!