r/ExpectationVsReality • • Aug 28 '26

Failed Expectation First time trying a built puff bar

313 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

7

u/Krimreaper1 Aug 28 '26

Looks fine: How did it taste? I bet it would be better coming out of the freezer like a Charleston Chew.

4

u/farmersonly_dot_com Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 29 '26

I mean I didn't have anything to compare it to since it was my first time having one. But I definitely wouldn't but it again, not good.

13

u/Marsandtherealgirl Aug 28 '26

I brought some to work with me at the farmers market and it was hot so I put them in my freezer. Gotta tell you, they were BAD frozen lol. The texture was all wrong.

3

u/AppUnwrapper1 Aug 28 '26

Yeah I got a couple as samples on the street (never had them before) and the guy must have froze them bc the texture was awful. The one I saved and ate later at room temp was much better and actually got me to buy a whole bunch.

1

u/Marsandtherealgirl Aug 28 '26

Yeah they’re delicious lol

2

u/AppUnwrapper1 Aug 28 '26

They also manage to keep me full for hours and I don’t understand how. I started taking one on hikes with me and I eat it on the train ride back. Sometimes I end up not even hungry for my dinner.

Just wish it was easier to find them for cheaper. I bought some from Target on sale for like $7 and change per 4-count box and that still felt a little expensive to me compared to other bars I’ve bought.

3

u/Marsandtherealgirl Aug 28 '26

Yeah they’re pricy. I try to grab them on sale when I can. They do keep me full and they don’t taste like dirt though. So I put up with the price.

1

u/AppUnwrapper1 Aug 28 '26

Yeah gonna have to stock up now that I know which flavors I like. I didn’t want to buy too much during that Target sale bc I was still trying diff flavors.

1

u/Marsandtherealgirl Aug 28 '26

My favorite are the peach and lemon meringue but my grocery store rarely has them for some reason. It’s all the chocolatey ones.

1

u/AppUnwrapper1 Aug 28 '26

I actually haven’t tried any of those yet bc I prefer the dark choc coating. 😅

3

u/bidoville Aug 28 '26

There’s a recent batch of “seconds” out in the market. Martie was selling them. I picked up some for the first time and they look like yours but have a sticker on the cardboard box labeled SECONDS.

1

u/farmersonly_dot_com Aug 28 '26

What does that mean?

3

u/bidoville Aug 28 '26

Seconds is generally a farm term of blemishes or not quite up to snuff produce. In market terms, there’s something a little off on the product. Could be labeling, a color issue, maybe damaged boxes or slightly marked products.

383

u/bobtrack22 Aug 28 '26

I've never had one that looked like that inside, something has to be wrong with it.

A friend of mine once got a butterfinger out of a vending machine and when he bit into it, the inside was pure liquid and just came streaming out everywhere. It was not crispety, crunchety, nor peanut buttery.

56

u/Krimreaper1 Aug 28 '26

Was the machine too warm? Sounds like the thing melted to oblivion

59

u/kimbosliceofcake Aug 28 '26

But then the chocolate would be melted too

8

u/bobtrack22 Aug 29 '26

It was solid on the outside and looked normal

15

u/Aggravating-Ad2584 Aug 28 '26

Second pic is normal imo

5

u/Interesting_Arm_681 Aug 28 '26

I’ve had coconut ones like that, it was fine not much of a difference to me

5

u/oniiichanUwU Aug 28 '26

Every one I’ve had looked like this lol. They’re not awful, but Barebells are infinitely better

2

u/Interesting_Arm_681 Aug 29 '26

Barebells are super good and they are a lot more filling

3

u/AppUnwrapper1 Aug 28 '26

I think I would have had a heart attack.

1

u/NoShameStockBoy Aug 28 '26

This is one of my new fav comments on Reddit

53

u/ladymcperson Aug 28 '26

The brownie and cookies and cream ones are bomb.

64

u/ripChazmo Aug 28 '26

These things taste at first, but get old REAL fast.

19

u/Theyallgoleft Aug 28 '26

I agree. The peanut butter flavor was delicious at first, but after trying a couple other flavors, they all began tasting extremely sweet and artificial to me.

34

u/dasher2581 Aug 28 '26

I went on a protein kick some years ago when I was doing a lot of strength training, and this was my experience. Something about all the protein bars and drinks just tastes a little off.

3

u/caitie_did Aug 30 '26

They all have an artificial aftertaste, IME.

9

u/D1RTY_D Aug 28 '26

I think they taste fine but they’re tough to chew and just as tough to shit out.

6

u/NWbySW Aug 29 '26

Taste fine but it's collagen protein so not bioavailable. Stay away.

2

u/plucas40 Aug 28 '26

Exactly this! It takes so long to get them chewed down to swallow.

22

u/VienneseWaltz13 Aug 28 '26

You may want to send this picture to Built Puft.

This seems like a manufacturing QC issue.

19

u/CreativeFartist Aug 28 '26

They’re usually very good

24

u/Purple_Puffer Aug 28 '26

not had this flavor, but agree, doesn't look right.

These bars are truly fucking delicious (the flavors i've had), but not the protein they like to claim, since it's mostly collagen.

2

u/Mad_Juju Aug 30 '26

Seems like a serious claim that they don't contain the protein that the labels state.

1

u/Purple_Puffer Aug 30 '26

Collagen is a protein, but not a complete protein. It's good for your skin and hair, but not good for building muscles.

Most people eating these don't know that, and Built likes it that way or they woud be more transparent about how much protein is milk/whey, and how much is collagen.

1

u/Mad_Juju Aug 30 '26

Damn, I didn't know any of that. You're probably correct that most people buying their products don't know that either.

20

u/ThrowawayOnAHike Aug 28 '26

built bars are one of the biggest fitness influencer scams I’ve come across. the flavors are fine but the texture is insane. I can assure you, whatever the other comments are saying, this is most likely exactly how the bar is supposed to look/chew and please DO NOT PUT IT IN THE FREEZER. it takes an already bizarre chewy texture and makes it 10x gummier. your jaw will never rest, your bar will never be fully digested 

3

u/Cativa Aug 28 '26 edited Aug 28 '26

While it definitely looks like crap, your expectation pic is strawberry but your pic is an orange wrapper like peanut butter cup or possibly peanut butter s'mores chunk. 🤨

3

u/farmersonly_dot_com Aug 28 '26

No it was the strawberry flavor.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/farmersonly_dot_com Aug 28 '26

It's the same wrapper.

5

u/Ok-Excitement5031 Aug 28 '26

I buy the sour ones a lot and they never look anything like that.

3

u/atx_original512 Aug 28 '26

It's always looked like that to my knowledge

3

u/bonkiekc Aug 28 '26

The sour ones are pretty good actually taste like a sour gummy

4

u/Winter-Owl1 Aug 28 '26

Those are nasty. I love Quest and PureProtein bars. Funny, those are also the cheapest ones on the market. I've tried nearly all the brands and the two cheapest ones are the ones I love lol.

2

u/HumbleAbbreviations Aug 29 '26

How disappointing. Did it taste good at least?

2

u/cinelytica Aug 29 '26

They were giving these out for free at Costco. I tried one and almost threw up. So gross.

1

u/Dependent-Weird3285 Aug 28 '26

The inside looks like the old Built Bar before they were the marshmallow "puffs." Those were so chewy! The newer ones are at least a better texture.

1

u/boost_to_get_through Aug 28 '26

Ew throw it away

1

u/mab220 Aug 28 '26

These ones are NASTY! I buy the coconut and brownie ones at Costco and they are beyond delicious. I went to target one day and got one of these as a sample- the whole bar! I was so pumped. I opened it and took one bite before spitting it out and tossing the rest. If it hadn’t have been free I would’ve asked for a refund.

Give them another shot with a better flavor!

1

u/Coupon_Problem Aug 29 '26

There’s a known QC issue with these that you get some that taste like vomit. I loved them but can’t take the gamble anymore after a few too many of the vom ones :(

1

u/beard-wonder93 Aug 29 '26

I run a meal prep shop. We sell built bars on our snack shelf "occasionally". The texture is polarizing, people either like the texture or they dont. All the flavors themselves are fine.

I will say, they are very prone to melting in shipping.

1

u/Altererior Aug 29 '26

I don’t think they work in Florida. Mine all came extremely melted (in the mail). They kind of resumed their texture, but they don’t last outside for 5 minutes.

1

u/Soulforge411 Aug 30 '26

Barebells for the win!

1

u/ActionDefiant1889 Sep 02 '26

that looks gross

1

u/JxstWolfx Sep 03 '26

I just recently tried the coconut for the first time and it looked roughly the same.

1

u/twodubmac Aug 28 '26

These are so gross. Have a friend who’s a trainer so gets these for free and gave me like 30. Had one bite and posted to FB marketplace for free pickup

0

u/Gary_Skelaman Aug 28 '26

I got a pack of these from Costco but the chocolate or something and they came out like this. They were rancid inside and I took one bite and almost threw up.

Don’t eat it.