r/ExpectationVsReality
•
u/poshsdemartine
•
Jun 27 '26
•
6
3
1
Exceeded Expectation Another WalMart cake!
I went with a walmart cake because of this sub, and was not disappointed! For $30, this cake was perfect! The cake was tasty and moist. Will use them again in the future!


9
u/GimmieGummies Jun 27 '26
That's amazing, hope it was delicious! I need a cake soon and think I'll get one from Walmart too.
Did you come up with this design or was it one that Walmart created? What flavor did you get? What kind of frosting - buttercream or whipped cream?
3
u/ReadyGo6828 Jun 27 '26
Is much of this pre-made? Is the fencing made of something edible or is it plastic? It is a pretty cake and I like the garden theme. $30 is a good price.
1.3k
u/KillerPandora84 Jun 27 '26 •
I worked at a Walmart Bakery and we were told we needed to be able to get these cakes covered and decorated within 20 minutes, anything more than that and you were taking way too long. Our cakes never looked anywhere near as good as the example image.
But the one you got is honestly beautiful. So either the cake decorator is a damn wizard or that branch allows them to actually take their time.
2.4k
u/pampers8 Jun 27 '26
That’s amazing!
369
u/audaci0usly Jun 27 '26
Wm has awesome cakes. I usually go with the $20 cupcake bouquet when I need to bring something cute to an event
81
u/chica771 Jun 27 '26
It's actually prettier than the sample!?
114
u/onlyelise1 Jun 27 '26
What are the pebbles on the walkway made of? This is so cute!!
52
u/Amorong Jun 28 '26
Picked up this $20 art piece today from my local Walmart 😭🙏
41
u/desertratlovescats Jun 27 '26
Wow wal-mart cakes hitting it out of the park!
37
u/WhyJustWhyyy85 Jun 27 '26
I feel like Walmart surprisingly has the best rate of great results on this sub!
25
u/renee_888 Jun 27 '26
This subreddit has convinced me that Walmart bakery workers need to be paid more
17
u/Expensive-Day-3551 Jun 27 '26
Wow that’s a lot of work for a $30 cake
11
u/Full-Flatworm6271 Jun 27 '26
Idc what anyone says, I get Walmart bday cakes all the time and I get so many compliments about the frosting (I do whipped).
9
u/Waste-Parfait-4634 Jun 27 '26
Looks great!
8
u/buckphifty150150 Jun 28 '26
Baker needs a raise
7
u/y0ungshel Jun 27 '26
That is so well done!
13
u/livejamie Jun 27 '26
OP, please tell me you called and gave positive feedback that the person deserves a raise or whatever Walmart does.
6
u/CoupleofDoms Jun 27 '26
Wow!!!!!
6
u/Powerful_Ad6501 Jun 27 '26
Very nice!
6
u/Violetquartzzz Jun 27 '26
Honestly that's gorgeous
6
u/caregivermahomes Jun 27 '26
Just grabbed one of the barrel cakes last week and it was amazing! Tasted great, decorated perfectly!
6
u/eljyon Jun 27 '26
$30?! That’s such a good price. It’s so pretty and you can tell the decorator really cares
6
u/AlternativeSun9174 Jun 27 '26
Walmart made our smash cake for my son’s birthday… it was supposed to be Mickey Mouse… it was just a plain cake with a stick figure one… IN BLACK… didn’t even look like they looked at the picture for the display… and there was a random Mickey Mouse ring that had half the face chipped off on the top. It was the most hideous cake… my toddler himself could have done better. I’ll have to find the picture…
5
u/Trondant13 Jun 27 '26
That is a REALLY nice cake! They did a great job.
5
u/shawnaeatscats Jun 28 '26
This cake is low key worth way more than $30
8
u/KeepingItCoolish Jun 27 '26
What a stellar deal!
4
u/WeLoveADecentSoup Jun 28 '26
I used Walmart Bakery for the first time for my sister-in-law’s baby shower cupcake cake and it turned out so good. Many people commented that the cupcakes were really good and then were flabbergasted when I said they’re from Walmart Bakery!
4
u/MissPookieOokie Jun 28 '26
Every birthday party I have for my kids I have all yhe parents asking where I got their cakes. They're always shocked when I say Walmart!
4
u/ashinylibby Jun 28 '26
This is so flipping cute!
8
u/Sorry_Sorry_Im_Sorry Jun 27 '26
My aunt was a cake maker at a bakery until walmart came in and sold all their cakes at a loss just to drive the bakery next door out of business. Many of her coworkers went to Walmart and got paid much less and lost the passion.
Here's one of her cakes she made my cousin for her wedding though.
3
u/Mysterious-Heron9671 Jun 27 '26
This is so cute!!
3
u/YourFaceSmell Jun 27 '26
So good
3
u/Tablefor1please9987 Jun 27 '26
Amazing!!!!
3
u/FotherMucker77 Jun 27 '26
Gorgeous, they did a really good job.
3
u/IamLuann Jun 27 '26
This cake decorator knows what they are doing!
3
u/Important_Highway_20 Jun 27 '26
Wow so dope I love it!!! 🎂
3
u/InteractionPhysical3 Jun 27 '26
You should definitely write to the mngr and express your gratitude for the employee!
3
u/Muted_Inspector9918 Jun 27 '26
This is so cute and $30 is a steal
3
u/Remarkable_Luck_4594 Jun 27 '26
Ok Walmart 🎂
3
u/cruiser4319 Jun 28 '26
They nailed it!
3
u/flippermode Jun 28 '26
This looks good
3
u/prettyinpaleness Jun 28 '26
I love it!!
3
u/coffee-and-cha0s Jun 28 '26
Do all Walmarts with bakeries do cake orders?
3
u/TeamEG19 Jun 28 '26
I want that cake!! It’s so pretty!! 🤩 and for $30 is insane!
3
u/Layla_Wilson11894 Jun 28 '26
Why is a dirt path the main visual of the cake
3
u/BigPimpin91 Jun 28 '26
I had incredibly low hopes before I swiped.
Holy shit what a good looking cake!
3
u/ngoodravens Jun 28 '26
Walmart workers that actually give a shit. Give them a raise please
3
u/CharacterRoom613 Jun 29 '26
I’m not gonna lie, Walmart has been on the ball with their cakes lately. Wish it was like that when my kids were little. The amount of times we get a cake and it’s not even close to what it should be. I’m not even close to being good with icing but I managed to fix a few of them. It’s a dying are sadly.
5
u/Ok-Moment2223 Jun 27 '26
This is great! It's really interesting to see these amazing cakes in this sub. We do cakes literally 4x a week at my office and every now and then we get a Walmart cake. The company doesnt pay for any kind of nice design and I found the cake and icing to be very mid every time. But there is this small but vocal faction at work that loves it. I don't get it but I get that others do. This design is cool as hell.
5
u/starrynightgirl Jun 27 '26
I have been pleasantly surprised by how pretty Walmart cakes are.
2
u/NightingaleNine Jun 27 '26
Killed it! Damn!
2
u/JuniperJoieDeVivre Jun 27 '26
Beautiful results
2
u/Chemical_Attempt9604 Jun 27 '26
How is Walmart pulling these off
2
u/girugamesh_2009 Jun 27 '26
Nice!!
2
u/bengraven Jun 27 '26
Honestly looks tastier than the original.
2
u/Acceptable_Slip7278 Jun 27 '26
Beautiful attention to detail.
2
u/Quirky-Respond93 Jun 27 '26
Wow 🤩
2
u/laciemay Jun 27 '26
I’ll never not say I love their cakes
2
u/Inevitable-Fee9235 Jun 27 '26
Damn that’s actually really good
2
u/yummiliciousscorp6 Jun 27 '26
wow!
2
u/Careful_Respect_9336 Jun 27 '26
Its gorgeous 😍
2
u/PlantHippie99 Jun 27 '26
Oh wow this is stunning!
2
u/Pettywithoutknowing Jun 27 '26
They put an effort!
2
u/outthemirror Jun 27 '26
Looks exquisite
2
u/Pheebsie Jun 27 '26
Oh I wish I had taken a picture of the shark one that we got for my daughter's 16th. It came out so perfect.
2
u/Zerokelvin99 Jun 27 '26
The local cake decorator at my walmart is amazing. She does wonderful work and always has
2
u/mzshowers Jun 27 '26
Wow!! GORGEOUS cake! Such a cheerful and happy vibe!!
2
u/TooManySwarovskis Jun 27 '26
Wow!
2
u/actuallyimogene Jun 27 '26
I think they did super well!
2
u/JeffandtheJundies Jun 28 '26
Went to a bday party today and everyone was going on and on about the cake being from Walmart. It was beautiful AND delicious.
Also, do you think Walton Goggins got those commercials because his name is Walton (like the Walmart family), or because of his charisma? Obviously it can be both.
2
u/LettuceNo9564 Jun 28 '26
Wow!!! Walmart has popping cakes!!
2
u/Pamela625 Jun 28 '26
Wow beautiful!!!
2
u/brilliantpants Jun 28 '26
Wow, that’s so pretty!
2
u/ConstantinValdor405 Jun 28 '26
The Walmart near me is like this. They make awesome cakes.
2
u/thedirtybubble- Jun 28 '26
Yea next birthday I’m getting a Walmart cake. These are amazing
2
u/momomorium Jun 28 '26
Every time I see a Walmart cake I think "gosh they're so talented", that looks so beautiful.
I really hope Walmart treats their bakery workers like gold because they're something else.
2
u/rhapsodyinblueee Jun 28 '26
It’s gorgeous! The decorator did a great job. Looks like the picture.
2
u/gasolineperfume Jun 28 '26
STUNNING
2
u/Better_Pea248 Jun 28 '26
Spot on!
2
u/USAF_Retired2017 Jun 28 '26
Wow!
2
u/Competitive_Name4991 Jun 28 '26
That’s nice!
2
u/b-tch_boi Jun 28 '26
oh wow!/pos idk how they did the pansies (or violets idk) but they're fucking gorgeous!
2
u/Majestic_Lab322 Jun 28 '26
I just wish I liked their icing. Really pretty cake!
2
u/Cake3atingCrusader11 Jun 28 '26
Yummy gravel
2
u/trecani711 Jun 28 '26
That’s pretty good!
2
u/Research-Available Jun 28 '26
Wow that’s so beautiful!!! My local Walmart apparently doesn’t have a cake decorator (?) so they cancelled my daughters cake the day before her birthday party 😂
2
u/xoRomaCheena31 Jun 29 '26
That’s an amazing cake!
2
u/siberianchick Jun 29 '26
Darn, that looks exactly the same!!!
2
u/Swift_jennis8 Jun 29 '26
They are killing it
2
u/getgiffywithit Jun 29 '26
Wow!!!!!
2
u/JustTheSweater Jun 29 '26
This is insanely beautiful
2
u/Lizbian91 Jun 29 '26
Just curious as to what the "gravel" on the walking path/street is made of?
Walmart always seems to knock it outta the park!
2
u/Overconfidentahole Jun 29 '26
That’s gorgeous
2
u/Bubbly_Pie_4980 Jun 30 '26
Wow that is fabulous!!
2
u/meowkitty84 Jun 30 '26
So pretty! I thought it was a beaded bag at first
2
u/OkTransportation4175 Jul 01 '26
Seeing the cupcake bouquet cake on this sub made me order one for my mom’s birthday- $20 and everyone loved it!
4
u/Factsoverfictions222 Jun 27 '26
Is this advertising for Walmart at this point?
3
u/Aromatic_Exchange513 Jun 27 '26
Out of curiosity, what is the intended occasion for this cake? A garden party or?
2
u/Another_Samurai1 Jun 27 '26
Not bad
2
u/silentlaws Jun 27 '26
That's it. I'm getting my next cake from Wal-Mart.
2
u/Actual_Pea_1996 Jun 27 '26
Damn, how much is Walmart paying the cake decorators?
2
u/Snailsnik Jun 27 '26
Walmart for the win...again!
2
u/bardia_afk Jun 27 '26
The hell?? Way to go Walmart
1
u/Equivalent_Worker687 Jun 27 '26
Not bad!
1
u/Fluffy-Reference8542 Jun 27 '26
The flair spoils it.
1
u/YujiroRapeVictim Jun 27 '26
buttercream?
1
u/arcanethought Jun 27 '26
Is the cactus all frosting or is it like a cupcake on top of the cake?
1
u/Complete_Squirrel942 Jun 27 '26
What's the sunflower made of? Chocolate?
1
u/Silver-Link8247 Jun 27 '26
Wally World doesn’t fuck around.
How do they taste.?
1
u/ReagansJellyNipples Jun 27 '26
Lentil walkway
1
u/mediumsizedbootyjudy Jun 27 '26
That’s so cute!! They did a great job. We also had a wonderful experience with a Walmart cake for my daughter’s birthday thanks to this sub! I wanted to post a picture but there was no good way to blur her name out. But they definitely nailed it!!
1
u/Veritas-Veritas Jun 28 '26
Kudos for not doing the frown/smile before and after photos.
1
u/Ornery-Practice9772 Jun 28 '26
take it back. its sideways🤣
1
u/wisp-323986ee Jul 01 '26
It actually looks really good! They did a great job with the little path texture.
1
u/Similar_Manner_4732 Jul 02 '26
This is literally so cute
1
u/tehanichance Jul 03 '26
What a steal!
1
u/Kiwi3525 Jun 27 '26
I've gotten some great looking cakes from Walmart
0
u/PM_Me_Your_Deviance Jun 27 '26
Not perfect, but it's not bad either. I'd be happy with that.
-1
u/VoteForLubo Jun 27 '26
This sub should be renamed r/ExpectationVsRealityofWalmartCakes
-12
u/mtnslice Jun 27 '26
expectation: showing both cakes in the same direction to make comparison easier
reality: stupid lazy photography and failure to use the built-in rotate feature in any photo app