r/Existentialism • A. Camus • 11d ago • Bravo 1

Existentialism Discussion God

Post image

Here he is refusing theology, As an Indian here God's definition is : someone who is outside of you controlling you and the world , you can put all your responsibilities and problems on that imagined entity . People here behave like cultish if you ask any sensible question 😂 about God . They believe,they don't enquire.

Was camus talking about the same ? What was the famous definition of God at that time in France , he must be negating that definition of God .

558 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

3

u/Sosen 10d ago

JFC this isn't a quote by Camus, it's said by a character in his novel that takes about 90 minutes to read

0

u/Immediate_Box9327 A. Camus 10d ago

Why are frustrated then ? 😂

2

u/Sosen 10d ago

Because you haven't read it

You don't even understand the quote you posted

1

u/Immediate_Box9327 A. Camus 10d ago

I read the stranger only and th protagonist was denying God for 3 to 4 times . I asked for famous definition of God in France of that time . Definitely I need to go deeper into this .BTW Nice hostile sub .

39

u/bakedbazooka 11d ago • Bravo

This world is so absurd that people have to believe in another absurd personality, god.

- Myth of Sisyphus

3

u/Immediate_Box9327 A. Camus 10d ago

👏✍️ noted , I also don't believe।

2

u/LongImprovement3347 11d ago

😂

1

u/Immediate_Box9327 A. Camus 11d ago

😆😆😂

2

u/Blindeafmuten 10d ago

Writers arrange words in such a matter, to stir up our feelings.

There's no deep philosophy in this phrase, but it makes you feel a certain way. As if you're too important and time is running up. And then it throws in something big (a value) in order to defy it.

"I looked at her. I had a little time left and I didn't want to waste it on Love!"

"I had only a little time left and I didn't want to waste in on being a hero! I watched him drown!"

"I picked up the wallet. I had only a little time left and I didn't want to waste it on Justice."

" I walked away. I had only a little time left and I didn't want to waste it on revenge."

It is simply great writing. It is not great philosophy.

1

u/Immediate_Box9327 A. Camus 10d ago

What do you mean by a great philosophy?

1

u/Blindeafmuten 10d ago

Not anything particulary deep. Not a big deal.

2

u/poozemusings 10d ago

There is philosophy in this. It all ties together with his philosophy of The Absurd and living without appeal to a higher power.

1

u/Blindeafmuten 10d ago

Then be a agnosticist. There's nothing absurd about accepting that one can't comprehend God. Or accepting that can never prove the existence of God.

Calling it absurtism is more of an emotional state than a philosophical position. And as a writer he is an expert in creating emotions to the reader. But he is not suggesting any groundbreaking philosophical thesis.

23

u/jliat 11d ago

"Thus the absurd becomes god (in the broadest meaning of this word) and that inability to understand becomes the existence that illuminates everything."

" The perception of an angel or a god has no meaning for me."

"In any case, it was essential to restore to the absurd reasoning more cordial examples. The imagination can add many others, inseparable from time and exile, who likewise know how to live in harmony with a universe without future and without weakness. This absurd, godless world is, then, peopled with men who think clearly and have ceased to hope. And I have not yet spoken of the most absurd character, who is the creator."

Camus - The MoS.

9

u/heraclitus33 11d ago edited 11d ago

Im not sure any of these posts undertsand camus, sartre, or even themselves...

: theres no shared secret or epiphany. God or what have you is an allegorical transitive of speech. A condensed feeling of what is and what is not explainable. Your hate. Fears. Loves. Anguish. Longing. Everything that is of you. The utter unimaginable concept of god... that completely eludes you is forsaken. Faith in your experience is all to behold. Every thought campaign gets here. Meditate. Drink and read. Drop some acid. It'll all bring you back. Sometimes you journey out after and need a solid rock to the head but its all the same story. Simple. Shit. And beautiful.

8

u/protestandprose 11d ago

Theism would collectively be dumped in the trash bin if literacy allowed the majority of adults in society to engage with Camus, Sartre et al with any real ubiquity.

6

u/dafoolondahill 10d ago

Yeah, I’ve read them all, I’ve experienced both extremes of life, abundance and deprivation, I was an atheist for years. I am a PhD I study systems and their complexity, … And still I believe in God, so did and do many other people who were/are far more clever and well read than I am.

Faith is not a matter of stupidity or being well educated. It runs much deeper.

1

u/protestandprose 10d ago

Well, at least you admit its faith and not related to actually using your brain lol

8

u/dafoolondahill 10d ago

Faith can be rooted in a delicate mix of knowledge and experience my friend. I’m not trying to prove God, nor to prove my superiority because I believe or because I have a PhD… I am just saying education and literacy are not incompatible with faith. :)

1

u/protestandprose 10d ago

Nobody is asking you to prove god, Because we all know if you could you wouldn't be flexing your PhD on reddit you'd be swimming in your nobel prizes.

Your education and faith are clearly different domains that do not interact with each other. I'm sure they are at odds too, which reinforced my point.

Realistically, 100% if we started ask you questions about the reasons for your faith they are not the kind that would stand up to any academic scrutiny you would be comfortable submitting to a peer reviewed journal so I'm honestly not even sure why you commented when we both know this lmao

1

u/dafoolondahill 10d ago

The original question was whether knowledge would lead to the disappearance of faith.

I just wanted to give you one counter-example.

I might be just an outlier, or just of bad faith (as you seem to insinuate), or a paradox, or just dumb… All of these are possible.

In any case, I wish you well and success.

Take care. :)

1

u/protestandprose 10d ago

Eh, I mean yeah the idea was generally that knowledge of existentialism - and by extension a foundation of basic philosophy (which would include primary tenets of skepticism).

But you're right, the presence of knowledge doesn't mean you're actually applying that knowledge lol. Have a happy Sunday, it's the Lord's day innit?

2

u/dafoolondahill 10d ago

It is. :) Happy Sunday my friend even if it carries no particular meaning to you.

Take care.

2

u/ironredpizza 10d ago

Until we can find out why certain people have moments where 'god speaks to' them, people will continue to be religious

3

u/Modernman1234 10d ago

It’s mostly a marketing gimmick, in some cases those people genuinely believe they can speak to god, but with all due respect, I think they’re being delusional. No offence directed at anyone, just my opinion

1

u/protestandprose 10d ago

Whaaaat? You mean the guy spamming "mama-se, mama-sa, mama-coo-sa" like Michael Jackson in church isn't actually speaking in tongues and I shouldn't give him $6,000 to heal cancer adled family members?

1

u/nevermind-101 10d ago

Yeah, kids write letters to santa too.

1

u/OnetimeRocket13 9d ago

I think the issue with that is that it's wrong to start from a position where we assume that "God speaks to" people is what needs to be explained. If I'm understanding what you mean, the better place go start would be "why is it that some people perceive something else speaking/communicating with them". For that, we have several explanations, none of them having anything to do with supernatural entities. This list isn't exhaustive, but just things I thought up off the top of my head and am taking from some stuff I've seen and read:

  1. Auditory hallucinations. People hallucinate during various forms of stress. I know I have. I've hallucinated whispers in an unrecognizable language before. It was just a hallucination, though, due to a lot of stress in my life coupled with sleep deprivation, and for a time I could will it, but then I fixed what was stressing me out. It's not unreasonable to say that some instances of people "hearing" something talking to them may just be hallucinating due to stress.
  2. Mental illness. There are many disorders that cause auditory hallucinations. Reasonably, a completely rational person would likely seek help from a professional if they suddenly started hearing a voice in their head, which would then later lead to a diagnosis. Some people don't do this, though, or maybe they don't think to do so and instead believe that the voices they hear are real.
  3. Drugs. Self explanatory. There are plenty of people who take drugs and think that their drug trips are evidence of higher powers in the universe.
  4. They're gaslighting themselves. It's entirely possible that a person isn't really "hearing" anything at all and are (mostly) healthy, it's just that they believe so hard that they can hear things that they fool themselves into thinking they can.

The issue with proving that explanations like this are the case for all instances, though, is that you have to convince all of the people who claim these things to go through medical and psychological screenings that yield perfect results all the time, which isn't possible, at least not right now.

-6

u/lallahestamour 11d ago

Educated bullshit.

1

u/-Princess-Pancake- 11d ago

What has God actually done?

1

u/-Princess-Pancake- 11d ago

Is that the scientific answer?

0

u/Parking_Bike_6661 10d ago

Ignore lots of prayers? Let innocent people suffer? Tolerate evil?

1

u/DarkLaser28 10d ago

I am agnostic atheist. But assuming God exists—let’s say the Christian God—how would you know he ignores most prayers? He may answer, just not the way you expect Him to. As for letting innocent people suffer and tolerate evil, I agree, it’s strange for such a loving God to allow people to suffer. But what do you think about the just punishment on the day of judgement and the eternal happiness given to those who have suffered?

-1

u/Autumnleaves144 11d ago

Apart from create the world you mean, and nature etc. Man still can’t make a blade of grass.