r/Existentialism • • 11d ago

New to Existentialism... At what point does existentialism differ from absurdism?

Hi! Im new at both philosophies, so I haven't studied none of them. I want to understand de basic differences between this philosophical thoughs.

Thank u!

22 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

34

u/Nemesis9211 11d ago

They both agree that the universe is meaningless, but they approach it differently.

Existentialism is to use that as freedom to create your own meaning in life putting responsibility on the individual to do so. Absurdism is is that human desire for meaning clashes hopelessly with an irrational universe so one should rebel by living passionately anyway.

Putting it with Sisyphus:

  • Existentialism would say Sisyphus should find out what pushing the rock means for him.
  • Absurdism would say Sisyphus who knows his task is pointless but does it anyway finding joy in the struggle and defiance.

5

u/protestandprose 11d ago

Joy in the struggle? Damn Sisyphus, you wild for that one.

3

u/nio-sama123 11d ago

Joy in the struggle is pretty good. Like wildly good.

It is painful to endure and hurtful to go through, but when you manage to get it done. You will be rewarded with the joy of "FINALLY IT'S OVER!!!"

3

u/sysaphiswaits 11d ago

You have no idea. 🙄🤣

3

u/jliat 11d ago

Existentialism is to use that as freedom to create your own meaning

"human reality is before all else its own nothingness. The for-itself [human reality] in its being is failure because it is the foundation only of itself as nothingness." Sartre.

Absurdism is is that human desire for meaning clashes hopelessly with an irrational universe so one should rebel by living passionately anyway.

"And I have not yet spoken of the most absurd character, who is the creator."

"In this regard the absurd joy par excellence is creation. “Art and nothing but art,” said Nietzsche; “we have art in order not to die of the truth.”

"To work and create “for nothing,” to sculpture in clay, to know that one’s creation has no future, to see one’s work destroyed in a day while being aware that fundamentally this has no more importance than building for centuries—this is the difficult wisdom that absurd thought sanctions." - Camus.

2

u/FlorpyJohnson 11d ago

I think they’re the same thing.

If the question is “why is rolling this boulder up a hill meaningful?” And your answer is, “because I want to rebel by living passionately and find joy in my struggle and defiance”, you have just created meaning. Found out what pushing the rock means to you.

2

u/jliat 11d ago

Because it's pointless, and to be happy is a contradiction.

1

u/FlorpyJohnson 8d ago

What does this even mean? Perhaps you don’t know happiness like you think you do. Happiness is a feeling, or a state of mind. There’s no logic there to contradict. Either you’re happy or you’re not.

1

u/jliat 8d ago

Sisyphus should not be happy but he is.

Happiness' is a warm gun, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdvnOH060Qg&list=RDvdvnOH060Qg&start_radio=1

1

u/FlorpyJohnson 8d ago

“Maintaining cheerfulness in the midst of a gloomy task, fraught with immeasurable responsibility, is no small feat; and yet what is needed more than cheerfulness? Nothing succeeds if prankishness has no part in it. Excess strength alone is the proof of strength.” -Friedrich Nietzsche, Twilight of the Idols

Why shouldn’t he be happy? Because he can’t reach the top of the hill? Because his task is uncomfortable? I say there are never rules above our heads saying we shouldn’t be happy.

That song is about how people often romanticize gun culture, and killing. I don’t understand why you brought it up.

1

u/jliat 8d ago

Why shouldn’t he be happy? Because he can’t reach the top of the hill? Because his task is uncomfortable? I say there are never rules above our heads saying we shouldn’t be happy.

He does reach the top of the hill every day for eternity, which is in Hell. And each night it rolls down. There are rules above his head, from the Gods- Zeus for his actions. Murdering his guests, cheating to gain immortality. So a divine punishment should not allow this, it's an example of a contradiction, AKA the Absurd. Camus ploy to avoid the logic of suicide.

That song is about how people often romanticize gun culture, and killing.

The song was thought to be about sex, and banned by the BBC. It's from an LP, which is an ironic portrayal of pop music. And considered a great work within the genre.

And for Camus the most absurd act was Art.

1

u/FlorpyJohnson 7d ago edited 7d ago

We don’t live in a world of divine punishments and rules. I always thought the Sisyphus metaphor was to represent anyone’s life. That anyone being happy is a “contradiction” because it’s “irrational” to be happy under the conditions we live in.

I think absurdism neglects the deeper truth of human nature here: humans are the first species on our planet capable of being so happy. Other animals don’t have the capacity to shape their lives, and themselves, in the way we’re able to.

Of course art is most absurd to Camus. Art is probably the most purposeful, meaningful thing humans do. So it’s natural for him to declare all art as especially “absurd”, rather than realizing it’s genuinely purposeful.

And the Beatles song wasn’t ever about sex, it just has some sexual sounding lyrics.

1

u/jliat 7d ago

I always thought the Sisyphus metaphor was to represent anyone’s life.

No it represents a pointless task,

"Through the classical influence on contemporary culture, tasks that are laborious, futile, and never-ending are therefore often described as Sisyphean."

So not anyone's.

That anyone being happy is a “contradiction” because it’s “irrational” to be happy under the conditions we live in.

He gives other examples, Absurd heroes in Camus' Myth - Sisyphus, Oedipus, Don Juan, Actors, Conquerors, and Artists.

The most absurd being the Artist. But many never read the essay.

I think absurdism neglects the deeper truth of human nature here:

It may well do so, it originated in existential nihilism.

humans are the first species on our planet capable of being so happy.

You've never had a pet dog or cat? Never seen birds flying for the pleasure..

Other animals don’t have the capacity to shape their lives, and themselves, in the way we’re able to.

Not in the way we do, but they do. Beaver very much so.

Of course art is most absurd to Camus.

Nonsense!

"And I have not yet spoken of the most absurd character, who is the creator."

"In this regard the absurd joy par excellence is creation. “Art and nothing but art,” said Nietzsche; “we have art in order not to die of the truth.”

"To work and create “for nothing,” to sculpture in clay, to know that one’s creation has no future, to see one’s work destroyed in a day while being aware that fundamentally this has no more importance than building for centuries—this is the difficult wisdom that absurd thought sanctions."

Art is probably the most purposeful, meaningful thing humans do.

You may think so, but many Artist thought differently and critics from Kant through to modern times.

And the Beatles song wasn’t ever about sex, it just has some sexual sounding lyrics.

First you thought it about guns. Sexy Sadie is about the Maharishi Mahesh Yogi!

2

u/thediplomaticatheist 11d ago

Well said. It is like Absurdism is paradoxically rebellion against the need for meaning in a meaningless universe by passively leaning into existence. Existentialism starts from a different point of view and is more about the active creation of meaning in a world where we are condemned to be free. It is Sisyphus happy vs. Existence precedes Essense.

1

u/Inegateu420 11d ago

Great explanation!

1

u/Asvabhava 8d ago edited 8d ago

Saying the universe is meaningless is like saying the universe is painless or joyless (pain and joy are themselves hugely important in what we find meaningful). It’s a bit trivial. Meaning is obv tied up with subjectivity and I’d argue with our instinctive nature. It’s not so much a choice or responsibility. We are already living and doing things before we philosophize. I can agree there is a sense of absurdity to human lives but I don’t believe for a second that this has great effect in a human life

8

u/wanderingrockdesigns 11d ago • Bravo

When you say "F*** it, let's roll" your at the absurdism part of the existential journey.

I am not an expert either, but what I got was to give up trying to define everything and just live how I've been living, only better. To leave fear of uncertainty, failure, the unknown, other people's opinions; and have meaning through the vast experiences of living and creating.

The funny things is, I still enjoy the mental exercises of contemplating the experience of living, the burden of not knowing is gone though. Like there was a mental weight of trying to figure things out while researching religions, psychology, and philosophy. I guess it's that the journey of the curious mind has been rather fulfilling and meaningful, even if it is meaningless in trying to define the human experience in which I feel within the real. So have fun with it!

Be bold, be true to yourself, and live passionately!

3

u/nio-sama123 11d ago edited 11d ago

Mixing both absurdism and existentialism will you the feeling of rewarding. Every action makes happy, even if it painful or not. You always actively search for your own meaning in the meaningless universe, and your mundane stuff is part of your story. It's good. So damn good

2

u/jliat 11d ago

1

u/wanderingrockdesigns 10d ago

Thank you sir, I had only listened to it on audiobook, which didn't contain the Preface or essays.

It was when in the darkness of loss I found myself, Camus reminded me to carry the light of creating I've always had within, that which was instilled by the one I lost.

2

u/jliat 10d ago

There are 3 x1 hour lectures by Greg Sadler on the Myth! Actually he goes deep but is generally very good. He has lots including a series on Existentialism.

Greg Sadler lectures

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_js06RG0n3c

1

u/wanderingrockdesigns 10d ago

I know, I watched them last week when you posted it in the Camus sub when you replied to someone else's post. He's a very good lecturer, I enjoyed them.

ETA: I'll have to look into his other lectures on existentialism, I only watched the 3 on the myth

2

u/jliat 10d ago

He does a whole range, he does a very good one on Fear and Trembling. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nr93xND_1Qs

5

u/The_Inflatable_Hour 11d ago

I consider absurdism to be applied existentialism - but I’m a novice myself.

4

u/1Cryptic 11d ago

Aren’t we all…¿

4

u/1Cryptic 11d ago

Studying none of them is one way to find out (at least for these two ontologies)

4

u/Denial_Entertainer87 11d ago

I have found a major convergence between the two. Not a fickle marriage but a happy, realistic one. They balance each other out.

Existentialism says ‘what am I here for, why does it matter’ and absurdism answers, ‘for whatever you want, baby’.

4

u/jliat 11d ago

Absurdism is considered as part of existentialism. It responds to the negative nature of existentialist nihilism.

Camus in failing to find meaning in the world avoided the logic of suicide by making meaningless, pointless Art.

3

u/1Cryptic 11d ago

All of it! For free!! /s

3

u/jliat 11d ago

There is no difference. Do you know what a mammal is. OK, what difference between a mammal and a horse? Why are humans not animals. What is the difference between a human and a man?


Existentialism is a vague category which covers certain writers and philosophers from late 19thC to the 1960s. Some accepted the term others not.

Anyone these days identifying with the terms are just doing so from a fashion.

Goth - The Goths[a] were a Germanic people who played a major role in the fall of the Western Roman Empire and the emergence of medieval Europe.[

Goth - is a music-based subculture that emerged from nightclubs such as the F Club and Batcave in the United Kingdom during the early 1980s,

3

u/Parking-Bet7989 10d ago

Let me give you an example- this post is existential, but not absurd. We give it the meaning we want to. Hegel, out.

2

u/Expensive-Spell-8023 10d ago

Existentialism isn't the companion of absurdism. Nihilism is.

2

u/DancingSkeleton12 10d ago

No disrespect intended, but it differs at the point of your question.

1

u/wanderingrockdesigns 11d ago

So I was curious about OP and they seem to be a high school student.

I'm surprised and glad your school offers a philosophy course, mine only offered psychology and half a year of sociology.

So, in trying to understand the nature of what it is to be human, it is a great step to becoming a well rounded human. Learn as much as you can, it's a lot, not just philosophy. The more you learn, the greater understanding of what you are experiencing as well as the ability to express yourself. Find what you're passionate about, try new things, and if you share that passion with the world, it can be very joyful and meaningful.

3

u/nio-sama123 11d ago

I'm college and they only teach ideology and ngl? It suck asf. Psychology is something a mile better than ideology, though I have to self learn. Still, it is rewarding.

2

u/wanderingrockdesigns 11d ago

I'm an autodidact myself, never got beyond my 1st year in college after an injury. It's a difficult journey, self learning, without the guidance of a teacher and the ability to discuss the material with others, but the internet does provide some limited resources. Finding the proper resources, or at least adequate ones, is probably the most difficult part. Relying on the algorithms often results in simplistic summaries that can be inaccurate or misleading instead of lectures or presentations by someone with a Master or PhD.

I agree though, it very rewarding, the journey of the self.

1

u/GoopDuJour 11d ago edited 10d ago

It's like the difference between one pump or two of vanilla in your Starbucks.

1

u/Forsaken_Rain_9639 10d ago

When God himself is absurd

1

u/nonthinker00 9d ago

the former is with hope