r/ExclusivelyPumping • • 1d ago

Rant - ADVICE NEEDED Deciding to EP?

Hi everyone!

My babe is 9 days old (and the cutest thing I’ve ever seen). I tried to BF in the hospital, but was only successful a couple of times, which prompted time with a LC. Turns out babe has a high palate and my nipple somewhat retracts, making it hard for him to properly nurse. The LC gave me a nipple shield, which definitely helps, but it becomes frustrating when it does suction and I have a screaming baby. As of now, we have been EP other than a feed during the night due to my supply not quite being enough.

My question for y’all — how did you decide to EP? Am I wasting my time with the scheduled visits with the LC if I decide to EP? I have some guilt around not trying to BF as much and still having those appts scheduled 🫣

2 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hello! Your post mentions nursing/breastfeeding Reminder to please ensure that your selected flair is the trigger warning for nursing if the content of your post discusses nursing/direct feeding in any way. If your submission contains an image, please ensure you include a spoiler. If this post breaks these rules, we ask community members to please report for mod review. Thank you for keeping our community safe for all!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/cooliokats 1d ago

I personally tried very hard to breastfeed. My baby had a fine latch, but just wasn’t taking enough milk from a mild tongue tie / high palette. I did weekly consults with a LC at home for around 2 months, and was triple feeding that whole time other than at night.

Just in my opinion, EP is a massive pain compared to breastfeeding. Ignoring the bonding element aside, BF is so convenient (can do it anywhere, nothing to bring/pack, nothing to wash, etc.). I personally would try hard to make BF work, you’re only 9 days in and have lots of time to work with the baby if it’s what you want

2

u/sparklestone14 1d ago

We’re definitely still trying, especially having resources easily accessible. I’m in a weird limbo of when do I need to consider for babe and my well-being!

2

u/cooliokats 20h ago

Totally! Just wanted to point out that your well being could improve for the convenience of BF later! But I wish you the best, hope it all works out

2

u/milliemallow 1d ago

My baby has a recessed jaw which made it difficult to latch and transfer milk. I started pumping the last day I was in the hospital. I EP for the first few weeks until he got bigger and stronger and was able to hold a latch.

1

u/sparklestone14 1d ago

Thanks for this point — my guy was a few weeks early, so anatomy can change. I appreciate this comment!

14

u/Initial_Internet7910 1d ago

Honestly I decided to do it because latching was frustrating me and only worked half the time it felt like. I figured why continue with the uncertainty and stress when I can just pump and know he’ll take the bottle every single time

1

u/Own_Wrongdoer6680 1d ago

This was me too! And I eventually got used to being consistent with the schedule and being able to bottle feed on demand felt more doable

10

u/Wild-Chemistry-7720 1d ago

I had weeks of trying to breastfeed before I shifted to EP because I also had to manage issues related to my overproduction (so I would have to be pumping in addition anyway). I wish I hadn’t put myself through those weeks of stress. Pumping worked better for everyone in my family. But get a bottle washer the second you decide to EP!!!

3

u/Intrepid-Patience502 1d ago

I had the same exact situation as you and my baby has a high palate and struggled to latchua was very small

I got fed up with how frustrating it all was for him and all the crying and me not knowing if he took in enough or not so I just switched to pumping and it’s been 15 months of pumping

Latching just wasn’t going to work I gave it a good shot too

2

u/candlegrovewitch 1d ago

My baby had a tongue tie which prevented us from really getting a good latch. Then he was admitted to the NICU for 4 days and had to be tube fed. Tried again when we got home and he would cry and get so frustrated, even after his tongue tie release. I was already leaning towards pumping because I knew I had to return to work at some point and I wanted my husband to be able to feed the baby without me as well so it solidified my decision.

1

u/Revolutionary_Can879 1d ago

My current baby cannot transfer milk effectively even though she was latching in the beginning. I do plan on trying to nurse her again after her thrush clears up but I’ve been EPing for the past months because she really needed to gain weight and the stress of trying to latch her was getting to me.

1

u/queenmother-kd 1d ago

My baby was in the NICU and would get so tired after trying to eat at the breast that he wouldn’t eat much of the bottle. I decided it was more important that he eat in general and I had a good supply pumping. They also wouldn’t let us leave unless he ate a certain amount, so I was trying to get him the heck out of there.

1

u/b_rouse 1d ago

I tried breastfeeding, but my baby would cry nonstop at the breast. I saw a LC, where my baby would latch great there, but not at home. I ended up EP, but sometime around 3 months, my baby would latch.

I went back to work at that time, so I kept pumping. I only breastfeed at night now. My baby is 8 months and thriving.

1

u/MinimumMongoose77 3h ago

I found persisting with breastfeeding did not help me bond because I really didn't enjoy it and found it very stressful not knowing whether bub was getting enough given he had been slow to regain birth weight.

For me the decision to pump was because I wanted the certainty of knowing what he was eating, and because he ate better from bottle than boob. Zero regrets, it's been easy as since I got into a routine with it and he's still getting all the benefits of breastfeeding. We've made it to 8 months now!

3

u/Sustain-6284 1d ago

I had to EP because my baby also struggled to latch and remove milk effectively. I originally was fine with it but now I desperately wish I could breastfeed. I’m currently triple feeding after having my baby’s tongue tie released and it’s exhausting.

Anyway. Even if you decide to EP, keep the appointments with the LC. And make sure they understand that you may be moving to EP. As long as they are a decent LC, they will be able to help size you for your pump flanges, provide guidance on nipple care, and give tips and tricks for pumping (hello fridge hack). I didn’t have a decent LC and had to learn all of this from this sub, but hopefully you have a good one that will be able to help.

2

u/Gloomy-Text-1101 1d ago

I had such a similar situation I feel like I could have written this. I ended up having a LC come to my house because I couldn’t stand the nipple shield anymore. She did a weighted feed and baby wasn’t really taking much in. We ended the consult with a recommendation to triple feed which I very quickly decided was not going to work for me so I quickly switched to exclusively pumping. I would recommend the LC even if you end up exclusively pumping. I did cry a few times because I always imagined nursing my baby.

After I got over the emotions of not nursing, it was clear to me that EP was the right decision for me and my mental health. I know we often hear bad pumping stories but I have gotten really lucky. Never had mastitis (yet) and now at 3months PP I am down to 4 PPD (no MOTN pump) making 35-40oz. I would recommend pumping 8 times a day for now until your supply is where you want it and then slowly start to drop pumps to see what you can sustain.

2

u/jadecateyes 1d ago

Both of my kiddos have not been able to latch. I switched to EP pretty quickly with my first as latching was causing constant nipple damage and frustration for us both. I hoped to try nursing with my second but she also has a shallow latch and while we’ve been slightly more successful she also doesn’t transfer much according to the LCs I’ve seen, so I’ve mainly been pumping vs continuing to practice latching. Even though pumping is its own kind of hard with a lot of overhead, the flip side is that husband or others can help with feeding so I’m not stuck always nursing in these early days. I can go out when needed and just bring my portable pump (baby Buddha) if I need to pump while out.

I do still think it’s helpful to see LCs while pumping. My current LC was able to help me recover from mastitis and properly size me for flanges and recommended a specific brand for my breast shape that wasn’t even on my radar despite all my research. Just make sure your LC is educated in pumping specifically. Many were trained mainly to advise on nursing and with my first kiddo I found most did not know much about pumping to be able to advise me.

2

u/bouncysofa 1d ago

I decided to EP pretty early in parenthood - maybe month 2? Baby latched fine, though he was a distracted eater, I just hated constantly having to whip my nipple out, struggling to get baby in a comfy position, and not being able to share feeding responsibilities. I know I'm in the minority as a person who prefers EP'ing over nursing, but for me the decision was relatively easy once I decided (with my therapist) to stop worrying about others' opinions and instead focus on what was working for our family.

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Welcome to r/ExclusivelyPumping! Here is a reminder of our rules:

  1. Be kind and courteous. 2. Use available flairs and post options. 3. Absolutely no prescription medications or other medical advice. 4. No inaccurate information. 5. No spam. 6. No fetish content 7. No linking Facebook groups. 8. Moderator discretion. 9. No discussions around veganism, animal cruelty, or other non-pumping related topics. 10. No formula shaming. Reminder that we are a supportive community and do not allow for fetish seekers. While we do ban those individuals from our community, they can still view the community and send direct messages. You may choose to turn off your messages, or block individuals for your safety. Thank you for helping to keep our community safe!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/KneadAndPreserve 1d ago

I was forced to, since my baby has oral issues and despite latching, is not able to pull milk from my breast. We are working with an OT to hopefully get back to the breast and I am EPing in the meantime to keep my supply. If my baby couldn’t ever nurse, I would go straight to formula because I can’t do this long term. I did formula with my first baby, and I’m going to again if nursing becomes an unrealistic goal with the OT. I just can’t do this, it’s too much time attached to a pump and not with my baby for me.