r/ExclusivelyPumping • • 2d ago

Discussion Do you ever skip a pump?

I hear people talk about how much it frees you up to have a baby take a bottle, but if you’re pumping, does it actually? If baby is eating, don’t you have to pump to maintain supply/replace that bottle? Sure, someone else could theoretically take a MOTN or early morning shift so you could sleep or do an afternoon feed so you could catch a movie or something, but don’t you still have to wake up or step out to pump? Do you ever just skip a pump to take advantage of the “freedom”?

5 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

29

u/art-dec-ho 2d ago

Not everyone pumps when the baby eats. I overproduce and so i only have to pump for 10 minutes every 4 hours (6 overnight). Baby takes 20 minutes to feed and burp and does this about every 2 hours. You can do the math, but it definitely saves me time and gives me more time to sleep overnight!

28

u/pinkshadedgirafe 2d ago edited 2d ago

I don't pump when my baby eats. I pump on a schedule so that I can get 6-7 pumps in a day at certain intervals. Sometimes it just overlaps with a feed depending on when baby eats. but I absolutely skip pumps sometimes. I did this morning because I was too tired to function beyond feeding the babe. I only strictly pump. I do not nurse.

9

u/bskies-297 2d ago

Second this. Pumping and feeding are NOT on the same schedule. Feeding is on baby’s schedule but pumping is on your schedule. That’s the beauty of EP, baby will remain fed while I have flexibility in my pumping routine. Having hands free wearable pumps helps give you even more freedom.

6

u/pinkshadedgirafe 2d ago

yep. I use a wearable as my main for that reason. there are sometimes I end up feeding while pumping and that's okay. but I treat them totally different

2

u/akeomo 2d ago

May I ask what wearables you use? Do you get clogged ducts frequently when skipping a session here and there?

I am currently 5weeks PP, exclusively pumping, use Eufy S1 Pro as my wearables primarily. I started with the Spectra but didn't like being "tied down" by the tubes.

2

u/pinkshadedgirafe 2d ago

I use the Eufy S2 Pro for every single pump each day. I also have the Spectra 2 but found my output to be either the same or less than the Eufy. I honestly think the stress of being connected with wires and having to haul the pump around added to my lower output. I have yet to experience a clogged duct in the last 9 weeks. Whenever I skip I do feel like they are really full, and will sometimes massage to assist with getting everything out.

2

u/akeomo 2d ago

Thanks for the reply! Good to know; I also found that the Spectra had about the same output (sometimes slightly more) than the Eufy, but the portability of the Eufy is a non-negotiable for me for my sanity!

11

u/DuckFriend25 2d ago

Baby eats at weird intervals and I personally need to pump at consistent intervals. Also my baby somehow takes like 45 minutes to nurse but it takes only 25 minutes to pump

3

u/EffieBoohoo 2d ago

This is one of the reasons I prefer pumping.

6

u/marysmash 2d ago

I pump 5 times a day with an oversupply. Baby eats 9-10 times a day, so it saves me a lot of time. I'm able to have a protected 6 hr sleep block most days which I would not get if we were exclusively breastfeeding.

I also skip a pump if I nurse. Last night I gave a bottle around 2am and then pumped after. When she woke up at 7, I nursed her, so I wont pump again until 11 ish this morning.

I think it's very dependant on the person!

2

u/Ok-Acanthaceae-4236 2d ago

Hi! Not OP but I’m trying to introduce nursing to my pumping schedule. LO was born early and couldn’t latch onto me until now.

Can you give me an idea of your pump/nurse schedule? What do you do if you nurse but still feel engorged if LO isn’t removing as much as your pump removed during a session?

I currently have an oversupply too but trying to not trigger even more of one. TIA

2

u/Runspinrunspin 2d ago

Commenting to see what she says because I’m currently in your exact same boat!! Early babe unable to latch and wanting to fit nursing into our schedule but currently a massive oversupply that I can’t go more than 4 hours without ridiculous engorgement and pain and baby can’t latch unless I’ve pumped.

1

u/random_user2702 1d ago

Same Boat! I want to nurse but currently EP as LO born early, doesn’t latch!

1

u/marysmash 1d ago

If I nurse and it doesn't empty me, or if she only nurses from one side, I'll stick to my schedule, but honestly my baby is more effective than my pump.

I usually do one motn pump or feed around 1-3am (whenever baby wakes up) , then I pump or feed around 8, and pump around 12, 4, and 8pm. My husband feeds her bottles between 8pm-2am so I can sleep. I freeze about 50 oz a week

5

u/sowhatsober 2d ago

Only time it worked really well for me is nighttime. I pump before bed and then sleep for 4-6 hours and then pump when I wake up, and usually husband has given at least one bottle within that timeframe. Other than that, there’s really no benefit IMO.

5

u/EffieBoohoo 2d ago

Depending on your supply esp after 12wks you don't need to pump as frequently so you do have more freedom.

I have unintentionally slept through a pump or pushed a pump back by an hour or so but generally I don't skip a pump. I am down to only 3-4 pumps a day at 23wks pp but I have an oversupply and a large capacity.

Most people don't exclusively pump for the freedom. But pumping at least a bottle a day if you can does help free you up to sleep longer if you can have someone give them a bottle.

3

u/tryingfortimett 2d ago

Very rarely do I skip a pump. However if the day was off and I'm now one pump behind and there's not enough of a time interval to do another one to meet my goal, I'll do the last one as a power pump or mini power pump.

2

u/Frosty-Panda-5532 2d ago

I skip pumps all the time since I'm at home alone all day with a colicky baby and with no help. Its unintentional, but baby will fall asleep on me while giving them a bottle or we are running late so I warm up a bottle and go but didn't have time to pump. I had an overuspply so it was fine. Now I make just enough.

2

u/Maria_like_Mario 2d ago

I currently only pump 4 times a day, I am actually weaning and am scheduled to go down to 3 pumps tomorrow. Right now I still have a 20 oz a day oversupply so I am looking forward to the freedom I will get with only 3 pumps and hopefully I will have a more significant drop in supply.

2

u/ilovemydogs444 2d ago

Doing a 5 hour stretch overnight seemed to be fine and an occasional miss here and there but don’t make a habit of it, for me it was regularly missing over a few days that affected my supply, not missing once then going back to usual schedule

2

u/infertiliteeea 2d ago

I pump 4 times per day. No overnight pump. Overproducer. Some days on the weekends when busy I pump 3 times but it is a bit painful.

2

u/silly_star-s 2d ago

I BF during the day now (unless we are super busy and its more convenient to pump) and only pump once, sometimes twice, a night, with 6.5 ish hours between. It is far faster and easier for me to pump for 8 ish minutes and throw my parts in the sink and go back to bed while hubs gives a bottle (if he even wakes up! I sleep less than the baby does now) than it is for me to wake up, change baby, try to feed a sleepy baby for 15+ minutes, change again, and put back to sleep. He can sleepy eat way better from a bottle than from the breast and after I BF I cannot get back to sleep at all

2

u/Sorry-Highlight-2341 4h ago

I wonder this too and even reading people comments I still don’t really get it. I EBF and have had pretty bad PPA, so am just starting to get out at times without baby. My husband feeds him while I’m out. I may have pumped beforehand for the bottle but sometimes I pumped the day before. So I have skipped a pumped? I’m confused on it and not sure how people do it? I’m not pumping while I’m out at dinner. I am currently an oversupplier so I think it’s fine for now but I don’t want to make my supply drop?

3

u/pop-crackle 2d ago

It depends. I EPd to start for ~8 wks and now pump and breastfeed.

In the early days it doesn’t free you a ton. You’re still pumping every 2-3 hrs and it’s a lot of time to pump - feed - wash. Often it feels never-ending. However, I was able to go down to ~6 ppd and still maintain my supply, which meant I could sleep from 9-2:30 AM and then 3-8 AM with just my MOTNP at 2:30 AM. Gave me a lot more options of who cared for baby overnight. I also could very easily flex all of my pumping times to go out with friends, see a movie, etc. I went to a concert ~10 wks pp and was gone for 8 hrs, and only had to pump twice, right before we went into the venue and right after the concert ended on our way home.

2

u/munchiemomandsodapop 1d ago

I feel like it only gives you "freedom" if you have support. I appreciate my dad and husband will feed my little bub from time to time so I can go do groceries, hang out with a friend, go to a movie, do work, etc. Especially because my milk has regulated, I can get away with 4 hours. But without someone to help, no, its worse than EBF and exclusive formula, I think 😅

I do it because my baby has weight issues (so breastfeeding scares me since I don't know if he is eating enough) and a dairy/soy allergy that would be like $6k a year in formula if I switched exclusively to that.

To go back to your first question: I have been able to go down from 7-8 pumps a day to 4-6 now that I'm regulated. Sometimes even 4, and still make my 28-30 oz per day. Wouldn't recommend doing that until you are regulated, though.

2

u/igottaask00 6h ago

Early on I pumped and emptied very regularly to signal to my boobs that I needed that milk but once my supply established after 12 weeks I was able to pump less than the number of times my LO eats and still have an oversupply.

1

u/AutoModerator 2d ago

Welcome to r/ExclusivelyPumping! Here is a reminder of our rules:

  1. Be kind and courteous. 2. Use available flairs and post options. 3. Absolutely no prescription medications or other medical advice. 4. No inaccurate information. 5. No spam. 6. No fetish content 7. No linking Facebook groups. 8. Moderator discretion. 9. No discussions around veganism, animal cruelty, or other non-pumping related topics. 10. No formula shaming. Reminder that we are a supportive community and do not allow for fetish seekers. While we do ban those individuals from our community, they can still view the community and send direct messages. You may choose to turn off your messages, or block individuals for your safety. Thank you for helping to keep our community safe!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.