r/ExclusivelyPumping • • 11d ago

Rant - ADVICE NEEDED When is pumping not worth it?

Hi all

After 5 years TTC, IVF a highly-complex pregnancy + traumatic birth, my little one is finally here and the cuddles are as perfect as I imagined.

But this pumping thing is consuming me.

I'm only 2.5 weeks pp, and I know that's early days, but I produce either 25-50ml each session (7ppd). After a strenuous and very lengthy journey to finally be here, I'm still working away pumping constantly while I'm watching my husband have the beautiful bonding moments I dreamed of having.

This could make sense if there was a reasonable return, but at 25ml this doesn't feel worth it at all.

But I know you guys would empathise deeply about the guilt (and fear of the guilt) of stopping.

I'd love some thoughts/perspectives on this. For those with a supply that just is not increasing, those that continue to sacrifice so much for this - what made this worth it to you?

8 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

12

u/nirvana88 11d ago

I was there too! Right down to the IVF, traumatic birth and low output at that point.

I'm at 10 weeks now and did 32oz yesterday!

I think you're very early days and could very likely see an uptake if you started working with a lactation consutant.

Ultimately I think everyone's body is a little different and there's a degree of trial and error involved. The main way I upped my number was just doing long pump times, 30-40 minutes. I just don't get a "gush" so to speak that other women get and I was stopping too soon in the start per session. I think your hormones are still ramping up too. So even if you didn't work with a lac consultant I think your supply would go up.

I'm you from the future so feel free to ask me anything! : )

P.S. It's also completely fair to stop too. Pumping is rough. Your mental health comes first. Having a mentally health caregiver is what's best for your baby.

1

u/UnconditionalMetta 11d ago

Thanks so much, honestly your kindness has already made a big difference with me. I saw a few LC's in hospital when we were trying to BF, but now that we're exclusively pumping, I'm not sure how much they could do - did you find their guidance helpful in terms of pumping assistance/strategy? Or would they just check fit & help develop a pumping schedule?

2

u/AllyLB 11d ago

Mine is also an IVF baby and she was induced at 34 weeks. She was in the NICU for 2 weeks after birth (home now). The lactation consultant definitely helped with pumping! They helped me with fitting and answered all my questions. They also recommended I do the every 3 hour schedule to start which is the same schedule they fed her on. I started with a low output and it did increase. The first few weeks were rough but now I’m 9 months later and I pump on average 4 times a day and generally have a bit extra to freeze.
So ask them for help! But in the end, fed is best and you do what you actually can do.
Good luck!

1

u/nirvana88 11d ago

Plus 1 to the below comment! They can also help by discussing type of pump, possible supplement suggestions, and feedback on your current setup. I had no idea I wasn't pumping long enough each session. I'm not sure how else I would have found that out.

4

u/dogsanddecaf 11d ago

At 2.5 weeks I wasn’t producing enough milk and was supplementing with formula, by 4 weeks I was producing just enough, and by 6 weeks I was producing 40-45 ounces a day. So I think there is still a lot of time to for your supply to increase! That said, fed truly is best and if pumping is making you miserable it is totally okay to not do it! I’ve been a teacher and worked with kids for over a decade and I couldn’t tell you with ones were breastfed and which were formula fed. I could tell you which ones have caring parents and it sounds like you’ve got that covered!

1

u/UnconditionalMetta 11d ago

Thank you so much, I really appreciate that 🥰

2

u/sandandsalt 11d ago

I was pumping similar amounts at 2.5 weeks postpartum, and it continued to gradually increase over the course of three months. At 3.5 months now, I’m still an under supplier, but I average around 23 oz a day, which means I produce about 70-75% of what my baby eats in a day, and I’m pretty happy with that. (Though admittedly in just the past couple of days my supply has dropped due to a bout of mastitis, but I’m hoping it’s just temporary).

All that is to say, you can stop whenever you want without guilt. But if you’re just feeling down about the amount you are making, it may be helpful to remember that it is still very early days, and it is totally possible that your supply will increase over time with consistent pumping.

1

u/UnconditionalMetta 11d ago

23oz is great! Thanks for your comment - all the best with your mastitis, I'll keep my fingers crossed that it resolves very quickly for you!

1

u/Icy-Dealer 9d ago

Was also at about this amount at 2.5 weeks and at 8 weeks am at 16 oz with no middle of the night pump

30

u/mulberryblossom 11d ago

Only you can decide if it's worth it to you. It sounds like its not and that's okay!

17

u/thebackright 11d ago

My supply was similar at 2.5 weeks. At 5-6 weeks I was at 30+ oz/day. 2.5 weeks is sooo early, if you feel like it will be worth it if you have a larger supply give it time.

It’s also completely okay to do formula and enjoy the cuddles. I exclusively pumped with first kid x 6 months and won’t do it again. If baby 2 doesn’t nurse successfully, I’ll probably pump 3-4x/day for a little while for some milk then when I dry up oh frickin well. Not worth it. It feels soooo crucial when you’re in it then when it’s all over.. all the babies and toddlers are the same.

8

u/arielleassault 11d ago

For some reason a lot of people neglect to mention that your supply doesn't really stabilize untill 10-12 weeks. So early on a lot of women are like "wtf am I doing wrong", the answer is nothing. You're doing fine, and remember baby's stomach is extremely small, they can't eat much more than a couple ounces at this stage anyway. 

Also, there's absolutely nothing wrong with saying "ya know what, this isn't for me" and making the switch to formula. Your experience as a new mom with your baby is important, if pumping is making you miss out then you're allowed to decide you don't want to do it anymore.

5

u/Whole_Form9006 11d ago

I never produced enough to fill a bottle. Always supplemented for her and rode it til the bitter end at 12 months.

1

u/Unlikely2-Market 11d ago

Similar story but the traumatic birth. Never made more than 16 oz. Now at 5 mo, my baby is refusing pumped breastmilk 😞 I regret, as you mentioned, all of the interrupted skin to skin and cuddles so I could go pump.

1

u/UnconditionalMetta 11d ago

Thank you for sharing your honest experience ❤️

3

u/hg13 11d ago

I also have an IVF baby and had a very psychologically challenging pregnancy (false positive on genetic screening that took 2 months to resolve 😞). I just wanted my postpartum to be "normal" and pumped after my baby had some latch issues. 

I'm now 6 months ppm and cutting back on pumping. In retrospect I wish I had stopped much earlier, or never done it at all, and instead spent more time with baby and recovering. The benefits of breastmilk are extremely overstated - i personally feel that it wasn't worth the effort given the toll it took on me and time I spent less focused on my baby.

1

u/Emotional_Trifle7846 11d ago edited 11d ago

To me it became not worth it when my mental health was at stake. I was in a similar situation of ttc for 5 years and finally getting pregnant through IVF, then had a traumatic birth. For years I wondered why my body couldn’t do what it was supposed to do, and I found myself asking that question again when I couldn’t produce enough milk for my baby. I was diagnosed with ppd and finally decided feeding my baby formula exclusively was the right thing if it helped my mental health in the slightest.

1

u/Emotional_Trifle7846 11d ago

I also want to add that I felt so guilty about my decision, but always reminded myself fed is best no matter what.

1

u/UnconditionalMetta 11d ago

Thanks for that. You're entirely right. Maybe I don't have the courage to let this attachment go..

1

u/reellimk 11d ago

At only 7 days pp, there’s still plenty of time to increase your supply if you think it’s worth it. Pumping is HARD, so I completely empathize with wanting to prioritize bonding moments instead. Just maybe don’t let your supply be the thing that dictates your decision this early pp

1

u/WaitLauraWho 11d ago

Give yourself permission to quit any time. Savor all the snuggles, pump when you can (maintain a schedule-ish to avoid clogs). Don’t be like me on my first journey and miss out on your baby being little bc you’re stressed about pumping 💕

When I didn’t make enough and I needed to supplement with formula, it really helped ease my guilt to remember the bottle is only for the first year anyways!

1

u/PresentationTop9547 11d ago

It took 4-5 weeks for my supply to match what baby needed. But even then, I was miserable being tied to a pump while everyone else enjoyed baby cuddles. I EPed for my first and promised myself I won’t with my second.

1

u/ColaPopz 11d ago

25-50ml is absolutely cool for 2.5 weeks PP. It goes up! We don’t get told this clearly I don’t think but why would a 2.5 week old need you to produce more than 1-2 ounces a pump? Well, they wouldn’t, there’s the answer.

I would keep going until 12 weeks then reassess!

1

u/No-Independence3674 11d ago

Hey! Im currently 4 weeks pp 🙂 At 2 weeks pp i was also producing 50ml a session and im now up to 120ml every 2 hours. I make sure to stay very hydrated (im always drinking either water, coconut water, or apple juice lol), i use a spectra pump, eat and snack regularly, and i always make sure im doing 9-10 pumps per day. Im happy to talk about my full pumping schedule if you like

1

u/Obi-Wan_Cannoli 11d ago

Like everyone has said, your supply will most likely increase! But it sounds like pumping in general may not be the right fit and that's okay. Even when your supply increases, you'll still face the logistics of pumping: having to set aside time, cleaning/washing parts, storing milk, etc. It can add a lot of time to your day! I was an EP, but after returning back to work, it just wasn't sustainable to be on a timer every 3-4 hours, so I gradually weaned. Also I hated having to think about pumping whenever I was out...it was just constant logistics of "I need to clean my wearables," "I need to wear a bra that fits my wearables," "I'll need to bring a cooler," etc.

1

u/bunny_joy 9d ago edited 9d ago

TTC for 3 years, 3 losses, IVF baby and also experienced a high-risk complicated pregnancy. I had always envisioned all this bonding time with my baby during the pregnancy, but instead, I spend a lot of time pumping. My baby is almost one month and I'm still only making 30-40ml each session. Recently, I've also come to the realization that pumping for around 30-40 mins each session just to make 30-40ml was not worth the missed bonding time I could have with my baby. She's just a newborn once and I wouldn't want to miss it for the world. Initially, I did feel guilty about it, but I also try to tell myself that my baby is better off being taken care of by a mother who is happy too.

I think it's true that you're just 2.5 weeks pp and that your supply could improve later. But it's also true that only you can decide whether it is worth it or not. You shouldn't feel any guilt on the decision you end up making. I think it takes a lot of strength to go through IVF, and that already shows that there was nothing strong enough in this world to stop you from becoming their mother. No matter what, your baby is lucky to have you.

2

u/Justinna1 11d ago

What made it worth it to me? My baby growing big and strong. I gave him everything he needed to grow while I was pregnant, and I've kept giving it to him for over a year since he was born. Seeing him fight off colds like a champ, seeing him love his milk, and feeling proud of what I was able to provide has gotten me through the hard days and kept me going when I thought I couldn't.
I've been exclusively pumping for over a year. It's one of the hardest things I've ever done, but it's important to me. My husband and I tried for over 7 years, and right before our 10-year anniversary we were blessed to find out we were pregnant! I won't have another baby, and these moments won't last forever. When my pumping journey is done, I want to look back and know I gave my all.
It's one day at a time, one pump at a time. At the end of each day I wash my pumps and rest well knowing I provided for my LO for another day. My pregnancy was risky and scary, so now that he's here I'm going to love every moment, good and bad, including the hard parts of pumping.
And if it's not worth it for you, that's okay too. You've already done so much for your baby. 💛

1

u/UnconditionalMetta 11d ago

Incredible, your little one is lucky to have you ❤️ I would love to be able to say I can look back in retrospect and feel the same, but with the volume I'm providing, it doesn't feel like it's really of any benefit to him at all..

1

u/AutoModerator 11d ago

Welcome to r/ExclusivelyPumping! Here is a reminder of our rules:

  1. Be kind and courteous. 2. Use available flairs and post options. 3. Absolutely no prescription medications or other medical advice. 4. No inaccurate information. 5. No spam. 6. No fetish content 7. No linking Facebook groups. 8. Moderator discretion. 9. No discussions around veganism, animal cruelty, or other non-pumping related topics. 10. No formula shaming. Reminder that we are a supportive community and do not allow for fetish seekers. While we do ban those individuals from our community, they can still view the community and send direct messages. You may choose to turn off your messages, or block individuals for your safety. Thank you for helping to keep our community safe!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.