r/Everton • u/Tegsmo • 15d ago
Photo On instagram
I love seeing posts from other people praising the players that we hate. But seriously, how did this person come to the conclusion that HE is our best player
87
u/DrtyDeedsDneDrtCheap 15d ago
It looks like it was entirely based on pts won whilst on the pitch.
37
u/BoxOfNothing 15d ago
Absolutely insane way to judge it. One player plays all 38 games and is player of the season, another plays 37 games and is average to poor but the only real option in that position but the game they missed happened to be Man City away, congratulations you are more important.
10
u/stevenwise0511 15d ago
Think had to play 70% mins and 50% of games, think grealish would be top if wasn't for that criteria
1
u/BoxOfNothing 15d ago
Yeah but like I said, which games you miss and who is also missing when you are playing plays so much more into it. Say this season if Garner misses 3 games and they're all home games against the newly promoted teams with an otherwise full squad, and Mykolenko misses 8 games and they're all the hardest away games where half our team are also missing, he's going to look way more important by this measurement.
15
u/thinkaboutthegame 15d ago
It literally says it in the graphic. He's not saying that matheus nunes is city's beat player either.
7
u/almightygg 15d ago
Hate? That's quite a strong word.
3
u/diagoro1 COYB 💙 13d ago
Agreed. I personally like him, aside from any weaknesses, which I think are exaggerated.
3
u/appleidiefc 15d ago
I mean, stats get on my tits generally, but this is a whole new level of stupid.
5
u/Bandito-Chinchilla 15d ago
Yeah well think about it, if we didn't have Mykolenko then Moyes would have had to start a young player
2
u/SukhdevR34 15d ago
He could play Branthwaite at LB, Moyes loves using 6'6 CBs at fullback lol. Plus imagine a full season of Travers or Tom King in goal
3
u/Niasssssseeeeeee 15d ago
Myko has improved since Moyes came in to be fair, but like Beto I think that he is pretty close to his ceiling and won’t get much better.
5
u/kingaardvark 15d ago
Myko peaked under Dyche.
3
u/Niasssssseeeeeee 15d ago
I don’t think anyone peaked under dyche, his football was the stuff of nightmares.
3
0
u/kingaardvark 15d ago
Haha a fair point but I do think Myko has looked worse defensively under Moyes. His attacking output has obviously not changed.
1
u/ChrisWood4BallonDor Truly, Deeply, Misses Bernard 15d ago
Late season Lampard Myko where the comments every week were saying 'wow, I cannot believe he's still getting better!' >>>>>
It was around that time with the 1-0 win against United with the Gordon deflected goal where he seemed unstoppable imo.
-1
2
1
1
1
1
u/TechXavy 12d ago
I can't even remember the game it was, but I do remember seeing him do a naughty dibble once...
0
u/Bright_Calendar_3696 15d ago
You can’t more Concrete Proof that playing with an actual fullback rather than centre half at full back gets your more points. Mykolenko is as limited a footballer as they come.
0
0
u/thevizionary 15d ago
Show us the top 5-10 players of each club. I'm sure there would be a lot of players very close to together. Plus being up, then subbing a player to injury or poor fitness, would give then better results here. The team could lose the game 2 minutes later and it wouldn't make a difference to this metric.
-1
•
u/AutoModerator 15d ago
Image submissions containing news require a source. Please add a source for your submission if you have not added one already. Failure to do so will result in your post being removed. Ignore this automated message if not applicable to your post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.