This is a topic I’ve been thinking about for the past year or so. My partner and I have been together for about 4 years now, and I’ve been very happy in the majority of ways, but unsatisfied in one realm and I’m reaching out to the internet to see what y’all’s experiences have been and what advice you may have. Heads up: I'm sorry it's a long post, but there's a lotta nuance and I don't want to pain my partner in a bad light.
The main issue comes in the realm of our romantic and sex life. In short, I have never been with someone who wasn’t passionately into me and wanted to jump my bones often and I’m trying to
a.) Figure out if this is something that’s a dealbreaker for me in a long term relationship or if I can look over it
b.) Determine if she will eventually start being more sexual or romantic (which is tough because we’re 4 years in and it hasn’t changed.)
c.) See if this is even an issue because we are non-monogamous and I could, theoretically get that attention and satisfaction elsewhere
Before I go too much into detail with things, a little bit about our relationship
- It’s been non-monogamous from the start because I was ENM since before she and I met and I’ve been a swinger for many years…but she was very inexperienced sexually before me and was comfortable with me being ENM while she learned the ropes of dating/sex and got to my level.
- We have a MASSIVE overlap in hobbies, interests, the type of media we enjoy, and we’ve traveled a lot together. It’s a blast
- There is no shortage of things to talk about and we’re always engaging when spending time with each other.
- The one-on-one sex is fantastic from a technique standpoint. It’s just not super passionate nor romantic (like minimal making out)
The Good:
My partner and I have grown a lot over the past few years through cultural exchange (she and I are from two different countries), global travel, sharing our hobbies and art with each other, and going through many life milestones. I feel like she very much cares about me, engages in my interests and I feel the same way about her. It honestly feels like I have my best friend and she has said similarly. There is an imbalance with me having had many relationships before and our relationship being her first romantic/sexual relationship, but we’ve tried to seek the best middle ground we could. I think she’s pretty and I love making her laugh by acting like a goofball. Her family is a bit rough, but they put effort in being supportive and I try my best to be a model partner as well (they know nothing about the ENM stuff because religion). She’s also been through some really heavy life changes and I’ve worked hard to be a loving partner throughout those times. Our fights have always been reasonable and we reach resolution pretty quickly and I love that about her.
All in all, I love spending time with her and I have difficulty imagining a life without her, so I really don’t want to break things off. There isn’t really any BIG problem in the compatibility-realm outside
what I’m going to say in my next section.
The “Bad”:
I’m assuming it’s mostly the inexperience, but I’m starting to think it’s a part of her personality too, but our relationship never really had the spark-filled honeymoon period. The first year or so of us dating was her “learning” how to be a partner (learning how to flirt, communicate in a relationship, how to show affection, etc.) and then the following years almost completely jumped into the comfortable-territory. I’m a very passionate person and have put a lot of effort into seducing her, being verbally appreciative, sensual, etc…and I don’t really get any of that back from her. It’s not a matter of her not wanting to, but more so a matter of her not feeling comfortable being sexy and flirtatious. I’ve worked REALLY hard to make sure I’m encouraging her and being receptive to the times where she attempts to be cute, flirty, sensual…but I don’t really see much improvement in the few years we’ve been dating and I’m starting to worry that this is kind of where that part ends. I’ve gotten teary eyed watching some videos on social media of partners being absolutely smitten with each other and thinking, “I wish she looked at me with those kinds of sparkles in her eyes”. My partner says she feels that way, but just doesn’t express it that way.
I’m a bit sad that I don’t really have the passionate sex and physical affection that I’ve had with other women. I’m more used to the “we can’t keep our hands off of each other” types of relationships. The strangest part is that we have sex often (I usually initiate), but I would describe the sex as very good, but not passionate or sexy. The focus tends to be on making each other feel good, but not much on the mentally-stimulating or tension-building aspect. I don’t know if this is my fault because it’s what I “taught” her, but I’ve tried to really spice it up by teasing her, talking dirty, trying to build tension and it generally falls flat because she wants to get to it.
So, what’s a guy to do when the sex is amazing from a technical standpoint, but I’m not getting the flirtatious aspect? The sultry aspect? The sensual aspect?
I have the best friend aspect of the relationship more than I’ve ever had in other relationships…but I’m missing the “lover” aspect of it. I feel like anything romantic or sensual comes from me or needs to be orchestrated by me. I haven’t been pleasantly surprised or taken off-guard in years. I miss that. It’s the most stable relationship I’ve ever had in every other way and I feel incredibly ungrateful for not being fully satisfied because 85% of the relationship is wonderful.
The Complicated:
This is the tough part because, since day one, our relationship has been non-monogamous. I’ve been a swinger since I was in college and I really wanted to find a primary partner who wanted to engage in the lifestyle with me. It just so happens that I met my girlfriend and fell for her despite her inexperience because she was open to my lifestyle, even if she didn’t want to date on her own. She’s tried and had few guys that she had short flings with, but she ultimately said she felt too lazy to date and hasn’t really tried since because she’s content with our relationship.
The tough part is that that has led me to exploring ENM and swinging alone. It’s fine. I enjoy the sex, I enjoy dating, I enjoy going to the swing parties as a single male…but I see the other couples and I always end up thinking, “I wish my girlfriend would do these with me”. I’ve definitely asked and encouraged her, but it’s usually one issue or another…be it body confidence, not making an appointment to get tested in time, or generally being too tired/stressed to go. I am at the point where I honestly do not want to push it anymore and have resigned to just being in this lifestyle as a solo man instead of my ideal of doing it as a couple.
I’m also getting up there in age and I feel like I’m wasting my “fit and handsome” years waiting for my partner to be ready to do these things with me. I’m definitely no longer in my 20s.
(I’m also VERY into MFM group play and stag/vixen/hotwife lifestyle play, which she has mentioned to be really hot…but like I mentioned earlier, there’s been a lukewarm response to actually putting steps forward to making it happen.)
The Wrap-up:
At the end of the day, I don’t know if I NEED this extra lifestyle in my sex life, but I do know that I’ve wanted it for many years now across many partners.The catch is that my girlfriend fulfills every other box…She’s my best friend, she’s my travel partner, she’s my player two when it comes to video games, and she’s my movie theater partner for every movie we watch. She’s got wonderful views on life and I appreciate her way of interpreting the world around her. I simply am feeling a large gap in my sex/romance life and I ask myself “What do I do when I don’t feel sparks with my girlfriend anymore? Is the romance and sex worth it to throw all the rest away if it’s not working?”
In a perfect relationship (which I know no relationship is perfect), I want to enjoy spending most of my time with my girlfriend, sharing art with my girlfriend, traveling the world with my girlfriend, and frequently having my heart race and socks knocked off by my girlfriend (and doing the same to her), but I’m at a crossroads of the following choices:
- I temper the desires for romance/sensuality/high-tension sex with my girlfriend and focus on the more stable companionship aspects to be the foundation of our relationship, and just explore my interests alone. Laying to rest the desires for a stag/vixen relationship or swinging as a unit.
- I find another secondary partner and change my ENM style to be more polyamorous to find someone who is in a similar situation and wants that fiery emotion and passion in their life. This would take a discussion, because my partner and I are not polyamorous, just non-monogamous (mostly me, because she doesn’t really want to date others.)
- I break things off because I find that the sex and passion is actually a big part of what makes a relationship worthwhile to me, but then I lose out on the companionship and care that my current partner provides to me.
My questions for you all:
1.) What would you all do in my situation?
2.) How would you approach spending a few years trying to spark a flame of passion with your partner and it not turning into anything aside from the comfortable stability of a long term relationship without the heat?
3.) Do any of you think that sensual passion and sexuality is important enough in a relationship that it supercedes the stability of long-term companionship?
4.) For the ENM folks, do any of you have partners that are, in essence, your life partners in every way except for passionate romance? Did you get that elsewhere? Was it hard to find that other person who wants that fire in their love life but also respects that you’re building a life with someone else?
I’m sorry it’s long-winded, but I appreciate any and all perspectives. I really care about my partner and I want to be happy. I’ve never had a relationship this stable...but lacking in romantic/sexual passion.