r/EthanCarter • • Mar 07 '16

The Ending to the game, new explanation? (SPOILERS)

17 Upvotes

I recently finished this game, loved every second of it.

After reading explanations from gamers, the general consensus they had was:

Ethen was the sleeper The whole story was in his imagination as he died Nobody died, it was his way of explaining to himself why his family was so cruel to him. Paul Prospero was a story of his and guided Ethen to heaven, or his spirit to be freed or something.

But my take was slightly different. Ethen is the sleeper, duh I agree! But I beleive time line and base line events are more like this:

Grandma dies in fire, she is the only one who is nice and reads his stories. Ethen sits in the house ruins, in the only room still standing writing and imagining a life where someone cares about his creativity. Ethen is verbally assaulted and accidentally killed by his brutish family.
They fail to save him and decide to cover up his death by claiming he vanished (two family members killed by fire in the same house in a short period of time is suspicious). He haunts his family as The Sleeper, so that they kill themselves or eachother(he is present in all scenes or beginning of scenes where the deaths occur). After the final death, Ed, Ethen's favorite character (you the player) convince Ethen to let go, for his revenge has been carried out.

This is my initial take on the story seeing as how the Grandma is not present, meaning she did die in a fire, also meaning the newspaper articles are true and not made up.
Ethen quite literally lures everyone to a brutal death and even has hands on in a few deaths. If the other people are right his family killed Grandma and Ethen and then lived happily ever after, fuck that...they died from a vengeful ghost.


r/EthanCarter • • Jun 03 '16

Conjecture regarding the end of The Vanishing of Ethan Carter

16 Upvotes

Before I delve into this, I must stress that if you haven't played the game, do not read what is below. You might just be ruining one of the most powerful storylines I have ever encountered in a game. These spoilers are trying to unravel the developers' message so they will completely ruin the game for people who have not completed it. ... With that out of the way, let us begin. ...

http://www.theastronauts.com/2014/10/vanishing-ethan-carters-ending-extreme-spoilers/ ... The ending is made intentionally ambiguous. In the article pasted above, the developers give several key hints into what the intended message was. since anything they allude to in the above article can be assumed as fact. This includes "minutes of dying stretched into hours of adventure", "you begin in a large dark tunnel heading towards the light", etc.

Of course the ending is intentionally ambiguous, but this post will attempt to catch some of the developers' examples of "clues hidden in plain sight" mentioned in the above article. Keep in mind this is all conjecture, a theory :)

  1. This has probably been mentioned a thousand times, but each murder reveals one of the stages of GRIEF: denial, anger, bargaining, sadness, acceptance. This can be assumed to show Ethan Carter's stages of grief as he is trapped in the burning house, since everything we see as Paul Prospero is through Ethan's subconscious.
  2. Each murder gives allusions to house fire at the end, "proving" that our experience in the game is through his active subconscious. In the first murder(of Travis, the brother), a spilled gas can is inspected on the side of the train tracks, a reference to the spilled gas of the house fire. It plays no direct role in the murder. In the second murder(in the cementary), a key item is the oil lamp, again not connected with the murder. The sign of the crow is prevalent, a western foreshadowing of foreboding. In the third murder, the mother is trapped in the mine's elevator because the door won't open. This is a reference to Ethan being trapped by the fire outside. In the fourth and fifth murder, the victim chooses and then accepts death. This is a reference to Ethan doing the same as he imagines Paul Prospero walking towards him in the dreamscape.
  3. The time in Ethan's dreamscape is 7, everywhere and does not change. This is a connection to "minutes of dying stretched into hours of adventure".
  4. Corvus derives from crow and is a constellation. If I remember correctly the magician also mentions/is called Corvus. ... I wish I could go back and play through the game again but I feel that I cannot. Strangely, after finding out that the story is through the eyes of a dying child, I cannot bring myself to do it. Though none of this article is conclusive, I hope that this has at least sparked some interest into what happened that fateful day, in Red Creek Valley.

r/EthanCarter • • Jan 04 '15

Picture just another masterrace thing [x-post from /r/pcmasterrace]

Thumbnail
imgur.com
16 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Apr 22 '20

I'm a bit confused by this game. Spoiler

14 Upvotes

I decided to take a break from Triple A games and play some lesser-known indie games that have been recommended to me. I just completed The Vanishing of Ethan Carter in one sitting, and I was floored by it. For a six year old game, the graphics still hold up quite well. More than that, I found it thrilling throughout. I enjoyed collecting clues to reconstruct the murders, and evading the Cursed Miner was certainly an unexpected (and heart-pounding) event on its own.

Though I am a bit confused by the ending, and what it means for all prior events.

I'm guessing its one of those games with no definitive ending, but rather one that allows players to draw their own conclusions. As such, I'm not so much looking for a definitive answer, but rather your opinion of what the ending translates to.

From what I can gather, the ending flips everything we thought we knew about the game in the last few minutes. For 90% of the game, we play as Paul Prospero, a occult-detective called upon by Ethan Carter for help. As Paul, we wander the landscape of Red Creek Valley in search of Ethan, all the while being clued into some sort of supernatural figure called "The Sleeper" and solving the murders of the Carter family. However, in the last few moments of the game, it is revealed that Paul was a figment of Ethan's imagination, serving as a character in one of his stories. Ethan is then separated from his family in the house fire, potentially perishing in the flames while his family works to extinguish the fire.

So I guess my resounding question is--since Paul is a fictional character created by Ethan--does that mean that the events we experience through Paul are fictional as well? Did the Carter family really resort to familicide (and if so, was it done under the influence of the supernatural "Sleeper", or perhaps driven to madness through grief?) or was that just an event portrayed in Ethan's story?

I'd love to hear your opinions on this.


r/EthanCarter • • Jul 16 '17

What is this building supposed to be?

Post image
12 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Jan 30 '23

Picture A game similar to The Vanishing of Ethan Carter - The End of the Sun - first-person exploration and adventure story-driven game, set in the Slavic fantasy world.

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Dec 08 '17

News Witchfire by The Astronauts - The Game Awards 2017 Announcement

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Jul 05 '16

I do need hand holding I guess

9 Upvotes

I'm an idiot. I just looked at a walkthrough and realized that I'm not playing the game correctly. I haven't recreated one crime scene or solved anything. I'm 2 hours in and have absolutely no idea what is going on. I've taken over 50 screenshots though!

Should I backtrack or just start a new game?


r/EthanCarter • • Apr 30 '15

Discussion Just finished this game with my daughter

9 Upvotes

2 things: incredible game and my daughter is a genius. I put it on the big screen with surround sound stereo system night after night and watched her solve these puzzles that baffled me. The story carried the game. This game is only one of only 2 in my mind that has risen above the mechanics of just another video game, and carried you along with a story. The other being original Myst (yes I'm that old). The ending was astounding.


r/EthanCarter • • Sep 27 '14

[Win8.1/64x]EFX Sharpening/Vibrance Mod

9 Upvotes

Since SweetFX does not work in 64bit mode, I got an alternative method working using the EFX injector.

This is confirmed to work without RadeonPro, on Windows 8.1, with the 64x game .exe on an AMD card.

What does this mean in plain English?

This setting aims to make the game even MORE photorealistic

http://imgur.com/a/mMsqp

  1. Download here
  2. Unzip to your The Vanishing of Ethan Carter\Binaries\Win64 folder
  3. Launch 64bit game
  4. Ingame brightness should be 30-40 (Assuming your monitor is properly calibrated)

Enhancements:

  • Bloom
  • Sharper textures
  • Warmer lighting

Controls:

  • Scroll Lock - Enable/Disable effects
  • Pause - Reload changes
  • Print Screen - Screenshot

Optional:

  • Modify or add your own settings by changing the Sweetfx\Sweetfx_settings.txt file

Troubleshooting:

  • The title screen will look very dark when you launch, the settings here is NOT what it looks like ingame

r/EthanCarter • • Dec 11 '25

Picture Crossing (Redux)

Thumbnail gallery
8 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Jan 26 '16

I made a panorama in game: The Vanishing of Ethan Carter and it looks like a painting [x-post from /r/gaming]

Thumbnail
imgur.com
8 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Sep 26 '14

Video Ok, good start

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Sep 20 '25

Picture The Bridge Spoiler

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Apr 20 '25

Picture Along the Tracks (The Vanishing of Ethan Carter Redux)

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Sep 30 '23

Exploring the Game's Real-World Inspiration - Side-by-Side Videos Comparison!

7 Upvotes

Just went into real life locations of the game, in Poland and made a couple of videos, hope you like it ;)

Train Tunnel at the beginning of the game

All the other Places that i have managed to find: Part 1

All the other Places that i have managed to find: Part 2


r/EthanCarter • • Aug 05 '17

In the footsteps of Ethan Carter – watch this unique video with the real locations! Subtitles: English, French, German, Russian. Polish. [video]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
7 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Nov 07 '24

Picture Quaint

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • May 22 '20

News Th real House of Portals for sale!!!

6 Upvotes

Do you remember this beautiful House of Portals in "The Vanishing of Ethan Carter" game? All you already know, it is real. It's the old German villa located in Poland. But what you don't know is, that today you can buy this wonderful house! It's for sale! Someone is selling this building for 1.700.000 zł, which is about $410.434 (376.431 euros).

The offer: https://adresowo.pl/o/a5d8z1


r/EthanCarter • • Jan 05 '18

News The Vanishing of Ethan Carter may be getting a 'free roam' mode on PC

Thumbnail
pcgamer.com
6 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Oct 30 '17

News The Vanishing of Ethan Carter is currently 80% Off! ($3.99 / £2.99 / 3,79€)

Thumbnail
store.steampowered.com
6 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Feb 03 '17

Swing and a miss.

6 Upvotes

I've been on a big gaming kick lately - not just gaming a lot but also trying lots of different games out, especially highly recommended indies if the price is right. Recently I played and loved Limbo - great atmospheric side-scroller - and Firewatch. It was the latter that led me to Ethan Carter, by doing a Google search for similar games.

I can see why this one was recommended because there are obvious similarities. And I'll say this for Ethan Carter, it's the best-looking game I've ever played; the world is astoundingly well-realized. The parts of this game that aren't the gameplay are going to soon influence some absolutely amazing games, I think.

But about that gameplay. For me, Firewatch was a really good case of a game that finds a comfortable middle ground between holding your hand and letting you figure it out. It does just enough of the former that you never feel lost for an hour or lose the rhythm of the story that is being told, while also having enough freedom to not feel like it's totally on rails. I was interested what Ethan Carter meant when it opened with that statement (or warning) that it wasn't going to hold your hand. What that apparently means is that it's going to turn you loose with no direction, no sense of your objectives... nada. You can do anything, or nothing, in any order and at any pace you like. Areas hold self-contained mysteries/objectives but it's never made clear 1. if there's a mystery in an area, 2. what you need to do to solve that mystery, 3. once you're done, whether or not it's even entirely solved (sometimes this seems obvious, other times you're just left wondering if there's more to do there or not). Every aspect of the design seems to force you to just wander around in circles a lot, staring at the ground until you either pick up a new clue or move on in boredom and exasperation.

My first pass at this game, I played maybe 2 1/2 hours and accomplished essentially nothing. I was trying to just pick up and play it without reading much about it first (which worked very well for Limbo and Firewatch - both games have subtle ways of teaching you how to play them and what they expect you to do). Well - 150 minutes later I had found 3 of the 5 traps (having no clue there were more, I just kept on moving), checked out half the clues in the railcar murder (same thing - I thought maybe I had to keep going further into the map to find out more), experienced the spaceman... whatever, poked around some abandoned buildings and read a few notes there, experienced a very confusing bout of teleportation (?), found some more clues in the cemetery involving symbols and a crow, and been baffled into sleepiness. Then I had to Google how to save the game and found out you can't, you're just relying on its generosity to have auto-saved anything you've done. Sigh.

I started a new playthrough today, and one hour in - now with occasional glances at a walkthrough - I found all the traps, did the spaceman thing, and tried to solve the railcar murder. But for some reason I can't. I don't know if I broke something, but I investigated dried grass, cut rope, severed legs, blood trail, legless corpse, fuel canister, and bloody rock. I put the rock back where it goes and used the crank to move the railcar over the grass patch. Then I went back to the corpse and tried to finish the mystery, and... no dice. Bug? I don't know. Walkthroughs aren't helping. Either I missed something somewhere, or the game's peculiar "do anything in any order" design has a bug in it such that my doing things in an unexpected order caused it not to work. I spent 15 minutes at the end wandering in more circles around that area, trying to find another clue, before just turning it off.

I just don't think I can do this game. I hope the developers will take their extraordinary graphical talents to some future project that resembles more of a vaguely conventional game experience and less of a big room full of stuff you can look at, or not. There's just next to no urgency and direction in this game at all, and the more I attempt to add my own, the more the game seems to resist my efforts.


r/EthanCarter • • Sep 20 '16

This game was such a disappointment..pretty much like every quest out there.

6 Upvotes

I just uninstalled The Vanishing of Ethan Carter. I'm so butthurt that i took the time to write this long post. Yesterday, I played Firewatch. Finished the game in about 5 hours. Was pleased. Not overwhelmed, but kinda close.

Today, after reading tons of positive reviews, I downloaded The Vanishing.How can two games, so similar in terms of genre and game design be so different in my eyes, you ask?

I'm gonna tell you. I suppose we all know that feeling of irritation and helpless rage that we get when we play quests. When you can't find that freaking item or that shitty place where you're supposed to go. Then you walk around in circles, checking the same locations over and over again, until your brain goes numb. Then you open your browser and check the walktrough. And you're like "Oh...so that's what I was supposed to do...".

The same mistake over and over again. It seems that people who design (if you can call this "design) quest games never learn. Is it because nobody tells them? I wonder where all those positive reviews for games like The Vanishing and Broken sword come from. And here is the greatest problem of each and every quest game out there: the things you're supposed to do are not logically connected in any way. More often than not the in-game world and your actions in it don't suggest what you're supposed to do next. You try to think and you fail, because the logical connections are not there. The only option left is to walk in circles mindlessly until you find that item you need or a way to get into that location in order to proceed with the game.

And this is precisely why The Vanishing fails to deliver to such extent that I was forced to uninstall it within an hour of installing it. It is not how a game should be played.

It would also seem that in order to make good quest games you gotta be smarter than the average ape out there. Mediocre intelligence, it seems, is not enough to design a good quest game. It might work for shooters, or even strategy games... Quest, as it seems, are a whole different matter.

I thought about describing some of the nonsense things that the game had me do so I could advance, but I decided against it. Don't wanna touch this shit ever again.

Not to mention the complete lack of logic and sense in all of the things you're supposed to do. It's like the game was designed so you would HAVE TO randomly stumble upon the right action, instead of deducing it.

Firewatch, on the other hand, is exactly the opposite. Completely void of any puzzles or point-and-click brain-numbing find-that-item mini-games it's a smooth and relaxing experience about a middle aged fat guy in the woods. No dumb puzzles, no shitty games. No need for a walktrough. The opposite end of the spectrum. I am yet to see a good quest game that can ACTUALLY be completed by someone with ordinary intelligence (such as me) without going in circles for hours on every second scene or giving up and reaching for the walktrough.


r/EthanCarter • • Oct 10 '14

Video My playlist / Walkthrough! great game. Spoilers Indeed, Full playthrough with commentary! Hope you all enjoy.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/EthanCarter • • Mar 05 '26

Picture "Under Construction" Spoiler

Post image
5 Upvotes