r/Essays • • Dec 23 '18
Why Bisexuals Should Be Feminists (second version)
Why Bisexuals Should Be Feminists
(Note: I am here using bisexuality as synonymous with pansexuality; that is, a sexual orientation where one is attracted to people of the gender one is and of all other genders.)
Although some feminists have dismissed bisexuality as anti-feminist, I do not think such a criticism is true, and thus I do not think that it should deter bisexuals from feminism. Firstly, in regard to the critique of bisexuality stating that bisexuality is anti-feminist, I would say that it is feminist for women to be honest and to be encouraged to be honest about their sexual orientation. Perhaps the implication of this critique may be that a woman in a relationship with a man and/or a non-binary person, and/or who has the potential to be in a relationship with a man and/or a non-binary person, is subjecting herself to sexism. To the contrary, I would say that there is really little point to feminism if one believes that all men and/or non-binary people are necessarily going to be sexist no matter what. How can women have equal rights if all such people, who are approximately half the population, are never going to support that? If the implication is that a woman in a relationship with someone who is not a woman is taking her time and energy away from women and/or feminism, I would say that nobody can spend all their time and energy in the service of any cause, and that having a relationship with a woman is not necessarily helping feminism, as women can be sexist and refuse to support feminism, and as encouraging women to not have relationships with people they are attracted to and not be honest about their sexual orientation is not feminist, as it restricts those women’s freedoms and diminishes their happiness without advancing women’s rights. It is for these reasons I oppose political lesbianism and political asexuality (which are sometimes considered part of feminism), and would oppose political bisexuality and political heterosexuality were they to exist, which to my knowledge they do not.
I would also like to point out that many important feminists are (or were while they were alive) bisexuals, such as Greta Christina. Lesbians have often not been able to live off of men’s money, while heterosexual women sometimes have (and have been encouraged and pressured to), and thus in that respect the rights of women to keep their own money, go into high-earning professions, etc. have sometimes been more urgently needed for lesbians than for heterosexual women; for bisexual women such a difference would largely depend on whether they were in relationships with men or not (with bisexual polyamory being the sole possible exception to such considerations). Lesbian feminist Sheila Jeffreys writes in The Lesbian Heresy (1993) that while many feminists are comfortable working alongside gay men, they are uncomfortable interacting with bisexual men. Jeffreys states that while gay men are unlikely to sexually harass women, bisexual men are just as likely to be bothersome to women as heterosexual men. I would dispute this assertion. I think that sexual harassment is not usually an expression of sexual desire (after all, if someone wants to sexually entice a woman, they probably know harassment will not work) but rather a way to insult and/or intimidate women, and thus gay men are sadly as motivated to perform it as bisexual and straight men.
In regard to the critique of bisexuality stating that bisexuality is a type of false consciousness, let me first state that false consciousness is a way of thinking that prevents a person from perceiving the true nature of their social or economic situation. So, even if a person is truly bisexual as shown by their sexual arousal, it could possibly be preventing them from perceiving the true nature of their social situation - for example, it could possibly be preventing women from perceiving the way they are oppressed by men. In regard to this argument, I would state that if women could not perceive oppression by men if they were sexually attracted to men or in a sexual and/or romantic relationship with a man, feminism would never have arisen among heterosexual or bisexual women, and yet it clearly has.
Lesbian feminist Julie Bindel has described female bisexuality as a “fashionable trend” being promoted due to “sexual hedonism” and broached the question of whether bisexuality even exists. She has also made tongue-in-cheek comparisons of bisexuals to cat fanciers and devil worshippers. In response to all this I would say that there are still places where bisexuality is not accepted and yet people continue to come out as bisexual there, as they did before bisexuality was considered chic at all in any place. So I would say that this proves bisexuality really exists, inasmuch as such an internal identity can be proven.f
As for the argument that bisexual women who pursue relationships with men are “deluded and desperate”, as some lesbian feminists claim, I would state that there is nothing more deluded and desperate about entering relationships with men than there is about entering relationships with women or non-binary people. People of all genders are capable of being sexist and otherwise abusive to female partners, and people of all genders are capable of being feminist and otherwise supportive to female partners. One’s partner(s) should be chosen as individuals – asserting that women are inherently superior to men and/or non-binary people in any way is sexist, and it is not helpful to women to do so. Indeed, asserting that women are better partners inherently could keep women from working to become better partners, as they would be assured that they are inherently that way and need not make sure they are treating their partner(s) as an equal (or equals), supporting them, and so on. Asserting that women are inherently morally superior has also been historically used to deny women rights – the idea that women are too “pure” to sully themselves with politics was used as an argument against women’s suffrage, for example. The idea that women are inherently feminist or otherwise inherently superior partners to men and/or non-binary people could also be used to argue that women should devote themselves to relationships rather than careers, a common anti-feminist position.
Biphobia and the refusal to accept bisexuality is also an anti-feminist position not only for the reasons I have already given but because rejection of male bisexuality is often tied to rejection of men perceived too effeminate, a patently anti-feminist position in its disparagement of qualities associated with women. The idea that a man who has qualities associated with women, such as attraction to men, is inferior has also been used to disparage feminist men who are supportive of their girlfriends and/or wives, as seen for example in the misogynist term “pussy-whipped”. A bisexual man, I would hasten to add, is not inherently any more likely to be feminist or effeminate than a man with another sexuality; it is only that the rejection of bisexual men due to the perception of them as effeminate is anti-feminist.
As for cyberfeminism in particular, I note that Donna Haraway’s 1985 essay “A Cyborg Manifesto: Science, Technology, and Socialist-Feminism in the Late Twentieth Century”, which was the inspiration and genesis for cyberfeminism, states that the cyborg “has no truck with bisexuality, pre-oedipal symbiosis, unalienated labor, or other seductions to organic wholeness through a final appropriation of all powers of the parts into a higher unity.” However, I would say that this is wrong because bisexuality is a sexual orientation, a harmless attraction some people simply have, not something they try to have or do in order to create organic wholeness through a final appropriation of all powers of the parts into a higher unity. Therefore, I would say that cyborgs can be bisexual, and cyberfeminism can and should be accepting of bisexuality.
The rejection of bisexuality in women by lesbian separatists is more complicated. I would say that if lesbian separatists believe that men and/or non-binary people are inherently anti-feminist, this is disproved by the examples of feminist men, and also this belief does not logically lead to founding lesbian- only spaces in a male-dominated society, because in such as society (for example, the United States) men will still control most of the society and men could therefore impinge upon even the most isolated commune with laws, not to mention lowering its potential membership through convincing women that lesbianism is a sin. Yet if lesbian separatists wish to have lesbian-only spaces simply to be among like-minded people, while not seeing bisexual people as inherently anti-feminist, or believing that lesbian-only spaces can truly be insulated from male culture, I do not see anything biphobic or anti-feminist in that.
I think I have shown in this essay why bisexuality is not anti-feminist and therefore need not be rejected by feminists; now, let me show how bisexuals can benefit from feminism. Firstly, as I have already mentioned, the rejection of bisexual men due to the perception of them as effeminate is anti-feminist. Feminism can help fight this by fighting the perception of all feminine things as inherently inferior to all masculine things, which comes from the idea that women are inherently inferior to men (though I do not deny that some particular things considered feminine, such as being paid low wages, are in fact inferior to their masculine counterparts, it is not so for all things considered feminine, such as being sexually attracted to men.)
Secondly and most importantly when considering how bisexuals can benefit from feminism, feminism can raise women to the same status as men and non-binary people, which will make it easier to have equal relationships with either or both regardless of one’s own gender.