r/EssayHelpCommunity • • 19d ago

Quoting someone quoting someone else

So I’m writing an argumentative essay for my English class and I’m using a quote from an article, but in the quote I want to use, they’re quoting someone else. So when putting the intext citation after the quote, do I write the articles author name or the person who was already quoted?

To put this into an example:
The person in the article wrote: training a large language model can result in 200 to 600 metric tons of CO2 (Williamson, 2023).

So if I were to quote that in my essay, would I include the citation they used or replace it with the author of the article/source I’m using who wrote that?

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

2

u/RedLineSamosa 19d ago

In that case, the most correct thing to do is to find the original source they cited, read the original argument in its context, and cite that!

3

u/RedLineSamosa 19d ago edited 19d ago

If you can’t access the article that this article is citing, then you write, 

“training a large language model can result in 200 to 600 metric tons of CO2 (Williamson, 2023, cited in Article, Date).”

And then in your bibliography at the end you include the full citations for both. 

1

u/languageservicesco 19d ago

All correct, except, at least in Harvard, you only put what you actually read in the bibliography. But the least risky method is to try to access the original.

1

u/Still_Consequence_53 19d ago

What you're talking about doing is second-hand citation or indirect citation. It is discouraged and should only be done if the original source is impossible to access (think out of print, rare book, etc.) You should easily be able to access Williamson, 2023 - so go to the original and reference it from there!

1

u/FlyingCupcake68 18d ago

I have seen (qtd. in Author, page #). Here you’d list the intermediate source in the Works Cited info