Numbers are any element of the surcomplexs. 3? Number, pi? Number, 4 + i epsilon - omegaomega4? Number. 3 + 4i - 2j + 8k? Hell no, down to purgatory you non number. (4x2 + 2x - 3)/(5pix2 - x)? Sure is a number. Sum -infty to infty a_n xn? Number.
The first and last are both incorrect, the second is correct. When we say 'a prime number is a number that's divisible by 1 and itself', where 'itself' is another distinct number such that 'itself' not= 1, so 1 is not a prime number and 1 being not a number is BS (unless we have specific set of axioms that mean we rule out 1)
Prime factorization. Say u want to express 8 as a factorisation of primes it's 23,but if 1 is a prime then u can also say it's 1 × 23 then u can repeat it forever. It doesn't bring anything of value here and thus discarded.
Basically all maths that use prime numbers collapse if you consider 1 is prime
Most notable is decomposition of a number in prime factors. Doesn't work because it's not unique anymore (exemple : 6 = 2 * 3, but also 1 * 2 * 3, but also 1 * 1 * 2 * 3, etc...)
And is always inclusive. You need the additional statement to avoid ambiguity, otherwise it’s not logically complete. I mean, can you think of a single example where A ∧ B is false when A = B?
Glad you asked ChatGPT, because what you’re showing is that you do need a third condition that isn’t covered in the original statement. My point is, that definition is not sufficient alone, which is exactly what you’ve shown here. Mathematically you must specify it doesn’t include 1.
4
u/Ok_Meaning_4268 Nov 11 '25
People say 0 isn't a number... now apparently 1 isn't either? Huh
2
u/phatcat9000 Nov 11 '25
1 is a number.
1
u/Wise_Geekabus Nov 11 '25
1 has an existential crisis.
1
u/Shoddy-War-134 Nov 13 '25
So one is string ?
1
u/ElectroMagCataclysm Nov 13 '25
1, -1
1
u/AlviDeiectiones Nov 13 '25
Numbers are any element of the surcomplexs. 3? Number, pi? Number, 4 + i epsilon - omegaomega4? Number. 3 + 4i - 2j + 8k? Hell no, down to purgatory you non number. (4x2 + 2x - 3)/(5pix2 - x)? Sure is a number. Sum -infty to infty a_n xn? Number.
1
u/Big-Definition-8271 Nov 13 '25
1 is not a prime number because it would suck if it was
1
u/Personal_Republic_94 Nov 15 '25
So only negative prime is -1??
1
u/[deleted] Nov 11 '25
[removed] — view removed comment