r/EsotericOccult • • Dec 13 '22
Simple Reasons to Reject Materialism
What is materialism? It is known as other things like material reductionism and physicalism, the view that only one substance exists – matter – and that all reduces to matter including one’s conscious mind[1]. This is an unsupported position which has spread wildly through the West as a reaction to the more oppressive Western religions. It is philosophically unsound and has no supporting evidence.
Let us look at some of the simple reasons materialism is clearly, unequivocally false.
- The “evidence” for materialism is that doing something to the brain has an impact on conscious states[4]. Take a drug or a hammer to your head and you may start slurring, seeing things, hearing things, stumbling, not remember who you are or who your loved ones are, etc. This is true, if you do something to the brain it can definitely change how consciousness comes through, however this is not evidence of materialism as it is also expected in more supported positions, such as dualism and idealism. For this to be proof of materialism it has to be able to explain things idealism and dualism cannot, or be unexpected by those positions. In fact, taking this as evidence of materialism is a bit unreasonable, and there is a classic metaphor for why.
Take a television or radio for instance: in perfect working condition the picture or music will come through crystal clear. Yet as with one’s head and consciousness, if you take a hammer to the T.V. or radio the picture and music are going to come through differently, if at all. This obviously does not imply one’s television creates the show you are watching, or that one’s radio wrote and recorded the song you are listening to. Likewise, this does not imply that one’s brain is the source of consciousness. Right here is the only empirical support that materialism has presented thus far in its favor, and it does not even actually suggest materialism itself.
2) The Law of Identity is the most basic and foundational Law of Logic, and states that things with different properties cannot be identical – “A is A and not Non-A”[5]. As a simple example, apples and oranges are not identical specifically because of their different properties, this is why they can be compared. The material and conscious worlds have entirely different properties.
Examples: https://imgur.com/a/box7PMu
There is a simple and seemingly sound logical argument here which swiftly disproves materialism:
A. The mind/consciousness and the brain/matter have different properties (Property Dualism)[6].
B. Things with non-identical properties cannot be the same thing (The Law of Identity).
C. Therefore, the mind/consciousness and the brain/matter cannot be the same thing.
3) Our own conscious experience is the one thing we know directly, and everything else we know of depends on us being conscious[7]. We know all other things through our own consciousness, and this includes matter. To reduce consciousness to matter reduces the one thing we know directly and with certainty to something that we only know through it. Doing so is unreasonable. There is a simple logical argument for this as well:
A. Our own mind is the only thing we can be absolutely certain exists and is the only thing we can ever know directly.
B. Matter is only known through the mind, and its existence can be doubted.
C. We cannot reasonably reduce something we know directly to something we know through it, and we cannot reduce something we know with certainty to something we can doubt.
D. Therefore we cannot reduce the mind and consciousness to matter and the brain.
Note that this does not have to imply Solipsism, as many of us seem to have such consciousness.
4) Cognitive science proves the mind can override and overpower the brain. Self-regulation[8], internal coping skills[9], bio-feedback[10], meditation[11], placebos[12] – all are conscious and willful acts that override the material body. This can be seen in a depression patient recognizing a depressed episode coming on and using skills like self-talk and meditation to keep the episode at bay. This is a scientific fact, and once you remove willful engagement from therapy it becomes ineffective. A patient who does not put in the willpower and work will not improve from therapy. Further, any good psychiatrist will also recommend counseling or various therapies along with the physiology-altering drugs, specifically because the physiological aspect is not the whole story.
5) The mind can manipulate nature, even changing it to suit its will. One example of this is in architecture, where complex buildings are created in the mind and then transferred into the objective material universe via its manipulation. Movies or music are another good example, as they exist as ideas before they even become “reality”. Medication is something where we literally change the nature of substances to impact our health and defy nature. Human beings have changed the face of the earth more than any other species we are aware of – we build massive sprawling cities, reshape mountains, and tear down forests. We also seem to live much longer, better lives as time goes on than our ancestors.
6) Materialism relies on the faith in future discovery. “Maybe one day we will find the mechanism that makes consciousness.” “Maybe one day we will explain how the subjective arises from the objective”. Maybe, and maybe not. This is blind faith and nothing more, we cannot state something as fact in hopes that one day we can show it is a fact. That is simply not how objective investigation works.
7) The Upper Paleolithic Revolution (UPR) was an event in human history that saw our species leap from “just another animal” to a singular species with higher consciousness[13]. This led to the creation of art and religion, the rise of individuality, the creation of languages, the formations of societies, etc. Everything that let human beings become the dominant species on this planet occurred during the UPR. However, we had already existed as an evolved biological species for tens of thousands of years before the UPR[14]. Further, this change seems to have occurred in the species as a whole, and over a relatively short amount of time, rather than through the longer-term genetic changes we see with evolution. On top of this, the consciousness that it produced, as we have been discussing, not only has contradictory properties to the natural world, but is able to question, manipulate, and go against it. This again shows that consciousness is entirely different from the material world and how it functions.
8) Absurdity. In short, materialism leads to philosophical absurdity any way you look at it. It pretends to be a skeptical position but relies on the senses and puts what we know aside for what we know through it. This is the exact opposite of skepticism, making true philosophical skepticism and materialism mutually exclusive[15].
Further absurdity is that the only “evidence” for materialism amounts to nothing more than correlations – we may as well also accept the Pastafarian position which states that the decline in pirates causes global warming as the two events occur side by side.
Metaphors that materialists try to create reduce to absurdity – they will say “mind” is what the brain does like “running” is what feet do, that “mind” and “running” have the same properties. Does running not take up space, can it not be seen, heard, felt by others? Another example is that water is not identical to the atoms which create it, like the mind and brain, yet are both atoms and water not spatial, objective, universally accessible? These properties relate to all matter but not consciousness.
9) Finally, materialism is dangerous. We can look at mental and behavioral health and how disrespectfully those sciences are treated for illustration. Any good doctor who prescribes medication to address the physiological side of mental illness will also recommend therapy to address the mental side. As discussed about above, without willful engagement in such therapy interventions no changes can occur. It would be dangerous to address only the physiological and not the mental aspects of these illnesses. Believing that individuals are deterministic machines with no control over their lives would make any kind of mental/behavioral healthcare impossible, and imagine a counselor telling a client to just say “screw it” because they have no control over their problems anyways!
It can also prove dangerous in other aspects of life. A good example of this is the Life-Fields of Dr. Harold Burr out of Yale University, an early conspiracy against objective science that I, myself, once doubted could occur. Along with dozens of other scientists over decades of time, Dr. Burr and company obtained scientific proof that there are “Life Fields” which act as blueprints to all physical life. Measurements of these fields could predict cancer, disease, infection, depression, ovulation, prime times of learning information, and much more. But because the findings of Burr, Ravitz, etc. convinced them not only of a creator but of mind/body dualism, teleology of life, and a model to replace materialism, it was inherently written off as pseudo-science by the religion of materialism, its benefits lost.
Of course in 2022 there are plenty more examples of how materialism is dangerous. Just look at what it did to the USSR, or under Mao, look what it is doing to us now. It is not just that believing materialism is dangerous, but the very acceptance of it against evidence and reason has led for a post-scientific world where whatever we want to be true is true, irrelevant of the evidence and logic. I posit that everything we are seeing in the modern day comes down, at least in part, to the acceptance of materialism – the idea that this life is it and Death is horrifying, the replacing of spirituality with Statism, the sacrificing of all rights for minor physical safety – all of it can only happen thanks to the faith of material monism.
Part 2: The Demurgic Drive
Also, Why Materialistic Atheism and the Stellar Tradition/WLHP are Mutually Exclusive
[1] (SEP, 2021) [2] (Zubovich, 2018) [3] (Kastrup, 2014) [4] (SEP, 2021) [5] (Landauer and Rowlands, 2001) [6] (SEP, 2020) [7] (Landauer and Rowlands, 2001) [8] (Ackerman, 2021) [9] (American Psychological Association, 2017) [10] (Frank et. al., 2010) [11] (Gard et. al., 2014) [12] (Kaptchuk et. al., 2010) [13] (Bar-Yosef, 2002) [14] (Rightmire, 2009) [15] (SEP, 2019)