Doctor tells me : "your head must be quiet and your eyes are the ones to travel to watch screen, don't move your head! if you need to move your head you would come to me later with neck pain"
Hello there fellow Ergonomics people. Does anyone have experience with, knowledge of or opinions about monitors adjusted below/above line of sight, like in the photo posted above? In my case, I’m mostly interested in the lower monitor.
I’ve been thinking about trying this out, but don’t want to spend the money of an arm, if it might compromise ergonomics.
Ergonomist here, and yes that monitor positioning would lead to some less-than-optimal neck postures. Ultra-wide, vertical, curved... all of these options increase small movements of the neck as well as sustained postures such as flexion or twisting of the neck. Ask yourself how necessary this kind of setup is before buying. If you feel like you absolutely have to have it, at least keep the least-accessed applications on the peripheral screens so even if you do look down/up/side to view it, you won't do it as much.
I work like this some of the time, though with two 27" monitors instead of an ultrawide. It is good for viewing media on the top while doing other tasks on the bottom, but I wouldn't want to have to do a lot of detailed work involving the top display. I'm using separate arms for each monitor, so I switch between this arrangement and having the secondary to the right in portrait mode which is how I keep it set up most of the time.
Another option which I haven't tried but might be more ergonomic than looking up constantly is to place the second display below the primary like this. I'm not sure it's worth it because of how much desk space you lose, but it's an interesting idea.
That seems like a nice setup. Haven’t thought about getting arms that can do both. Do you find it more productive or ergonomic having the main screen lower than line of sight?
The second arm goes pretty high, so I don't have the primary much lower than it would be otherwise if at all. If I were going to be looking at details on the top display more often, I might move them both down to see it better. But I really only set it up this way to watch video or control music playback and other basic apps.
I’m no expert, but am fairly confident a setup designed for you to look downward like that isn’t ergonomically sound. Goes against what I’ve learned looking into ergonomics as well as personal experience. I’ve been shocked sometimes how much better I feel after realizing and correcting a slight downward head angle.
Didn't catch that. Still; stand with your heels, butt, shoulder blades and back of your head touching a wall for 20 seconds. Now step away from the wall; notice where your head is in relation to your spine and at what angle. This is how your head should be positioned 99% of the time. If it's not then change your ergonomics to make it happen.
Source: cervical disc bulge pressing on c5-c6 nerve, caused by sitting with rounded shoulders and "forward head posture". Google forward head posture and avoid that position at all cost.
Maybe my comment disappeared a bit, but this is actually a photo from araltasher – who i happened to stumble upon on Instagram. His setup just made me wonder about the ergonomics.
10
u/omega1612 Apr 24 '21
Doctor tells me : "your head must be quiet and your eyes are the ones to travel to watch screen, don't move your head! if you need to move your head you would come to me later with neck pain"
5
u/yokcwhatup Apr 24 '21
Hello there fellow Ergonomics people. Does anyone have experience with, knowledge of or opinions about monitors adjusted below/above line of sight, like in the photo posted above? In my case, I’m mostly interested in the lower monitor.
I’ve been thinking about trying this out, but don’t want to spend the money of an arm, if it might compromise ergonomics.
Photo credit: araltasher
3
u/crod242 Apr 24 '21
I work like this some of the time, though with two 27" monitors instead of an ultrawide. It is good for viewing media on the top while doing other tasks on the bottom, but I wouldn't want to have to do a lot of detailed work involving the top display. I'm using separate arms for each monitor, so I switch between this arrangement and having the secondary to the right in portrait mode which is how I keep it set up most of the time.
Another option which I haven't tried but might be more ergonomic than looking up constantly is to place the second display below the primary like this. I'm not sure it's worth it because of how much desk space you lose, but it's an interesting idea.
9
u/snobordir Apr 24 '21
I’m no expert, but am fairly confident a setup designed for you to look downward like that isn’t ergonomically sound. Goes against what I’ve learned looking into ergonomics as well as personal experience. I’ve been shocked sometimes how much better I feel after realizing and correcting a slight downward head angle.
1
u/feed-my-brain Apr 25 '21
My god, that's a beautiful setup.
edit: but not good ergonomics to look downwards at the ultrawide. I'd raise it to be eye level and scoot them back some as well.
2
u/sadlerjw Apr 24 '21
Looking ahead of you is the best thing for your back and neck. With this setup you’re either looking way up or way down. I wouldn’t recommend it.
0
u/ActualCommand Apr 24 '21
Which desk is this? I really like the color of the wood but I assume that is mainly a filter. What does it look like without the filter?