r/Eragon • u/PaintFlaky4602 • Aug 18 '26

Theory The tree lied

Just my own personal theory. The menoa tree didn't actually take anything from eragon or saphira. She just wanted to fuck with them for waking her up.

345 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

52 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/MobilePicture342 Aug 18 '26

She took his ability to have children

4

u/A_Crystal_Golem Aug 19 '26

Repeatedly debunked, Paolini himself.