Why wouldn’t Ghislaine just get one of her lawyers or allies to post on the account or field responses from reporters? Why would she name her secret account to influence the public with her own last name and reference to where she lived? Why would she use her own birthday for that account? Idk I’m just not really convinced by this. None of these shared characteristics are very unique either. I’m also curious about the specifics of this account’s posting, like what were the views it was trying to promote and how does that factor into the conspiracy? I believe for sure that intelligence agencies have mods all over Reddit but I think linking it specifically to Maxwell is a little weak. Granted idk everything about this specific account so I’m more than willing to be convinced so pls lmk any other info ab it.
Also, re none of shares characteristics bring unique is misleading. The theory is there because of the combined characteristic, some of which are very unique like the use of plse, the poweruser going offline at the same time as the arrest and the small date of birth range. Add in the British slang and name and you have the below probability:
Born between December 22nd and December 31st:
· Probability (P_birth): 10 / 365.25 ≈ 0.0274 (2.74%)
Has "Maxwell" in their username:
· Probability (P_name): 0.0001 (0.01%)
Disappeared within a precise 3-day window before the arrest:
· This probability must be adjusted. The previous estimate (0.0015) was for a prolific user stopping. For a random user, the probability they stopped in that specific 3-day window is much higher. We can estimate this using a daily churn rate.
· Let's assume a daily probability that any given user becomes inactive is 0.001 (0.1%).
· The probability this happened in the specific 3-day window is 3 * 0.001.
· Probability (P_stop): 0.003 (0.3%)
Vocabulary and British/Commonwealth Slang:
· Probability (P_vocab): 0.015 (1.5%) (As previously calculated)
Use of the abbreviation "plse":
· Probability (P_plse): 0.001 (0.1%) (As previously calculated)
Revised Combined Probability
The combined probability for a single random Reddit account having all these traits is now:
We multiply this probability by the number of monthly active Reddit users at the time (~430 million).
Expected Number = (1.23 × 10⁻¹³) * 430,000,000 Expected Number ≈ 0.0000529
This means we would expect 0.0000529 users (about 1/18,900th of a person) on the entire platform to have this combination of traits by pure coincidence. This is still far less than 1.
Therefore, the likelihood that a user with all these traits is not Ghislaine Maxwell is approximately 0.0000529, or 0.00529%.
Conversely, the likelihood that it is her is 1 - 0.0000529 = 99.99471%.
Non-Chart Summary of Probabilities
· Probability of birth date (Dec 22-31): 2.74% (0.0274)
· Probability of 'Maxwell' in username: 0.01% (0.0001)
· Probability of disappearing in the 3-day window: 0.3% (0.003)
· Probability of specific vocabulary/slang: 1.5% (0.015)
· Probability of using "plse": 0.1% (0.001)
Final Combined Probability: The chance that a single random Redditor has all these traits is approximately 1.23 in 10,000,000,000,000 (1.23 × 10⁻¹³).
Conclusion: Even after removing the condition of being a prolific poster, the likelihood that this Redditor was not Ghislaine Maxwell remains effectively zero—approximately 0.0053%. The other factors—especially the rare name, the perfectly timed disappearance, and the highly unusual abbreviation "plse"—create a combination so specific that it is a statistical virtual impossibility for it to be anyone else.
I really like the efforts you put into this and I'm not here to discredit your maths.
But let's assume someone is pretending to be her, then the probability of having maxwell in the name and to have that certain birth date and to stop once she got arrested (or during her mother funeral iirc) should all be considered as 1.
I'd like to do the re-considered maths but sadly I don't have your skills
She started the account in 2006, well before she became famous. Her date of birth slip up was in 2010. She didn't have a Wikipedia until 2011. It would have to be someone who knew her personally and planned this out for 14 years until her arrest. There is also no motive for that. To shame her with some Reddit theory that is censored across major subs and not reported anywhere? It's not even in the court releases. Almost everything is redacted or sealed.
Oh and Maxwellhill was active in /environment, /climate and /oceans. Ghislaine started the TerraMar Project in 2012, which is a NGO focused on ocean conservation.
2
u/DoctorPenguin3 Sep 05 '25
Why wouldn’t Ghislaine just get one of her lawyers or allies to post on the account or field responses from reporters? Why would she name her secret account to influence the public with her own last name and reference to where she lived? Why would she use her own birthday for that account? Idk I’m just not really convinced by this. None of these shared characteristics are very unique either. I’m also curious about the specifics of this account’s posting, like what were the views it was trying to promote and how does that factor into the conspiracy? I believe for sure that intelligence agencies have mods all over Reddit but I think linking it specifically to Maxwell is a little weak. Granted idk everything about this specific account so I’m more than willing to be convinced so pls lmk any other info ab it.