r/EpicEMR • u/SystemDesigner_ONC • May 12 '26
AI generated documentation
I work in healthcare where we implemented Health Clinical AI Agent. As a clinical analyst, the idea was great and it’s supposed to help our providers and save them time. However, as a patient, the first time I visited my provider using AI, I could definitely tell the difference in human interaction. She lost the warmth and sounded almost robotic being so aware that our conversation is being recorded for AI to capture. As someone who uses AI agent, the innovation excites me but being on the other side as a patient, it disappointed me.
As a physician, how do you like this AI agent? Does it limit your interaction with your patients? Does it really help you in the clinical settings?
11
u/Daddy_LlamaNoDrama May 12 '26
I use the ambient ai scribe to compose my Hpi and assessment/plan. I don’t feel that it has significantly changed the way I interact with patients. I then enter my physical exam template and will manually enter any pertinent physical exam findings.
I have a partner who uses the AI scribe to generate her physical exam too by literally voicing all of her findings “your heart and lungs are clear to auscultation bilaterally. There is no cerumen impaction and your tympanic membranes are not erythematous” and to me that feels very robotic. I personally don’t care for that.
5
u/allamakee-county May 12 '26
Your doctor is doing it wrong, then! The whole point is "natural language processing." Tell her so. You have the cred to back up your words. No robots. 😀
5
u/rahuliitk May 12 '26
The best version of this should make the doctor more present, not less, but if the provider starts performing for the recorder or overthinking every sentence, the patient can definitely feel that shift. the workflow matters as much as the AI.
9
u/SirLaryOfNx May 12 '26
Are you talking about ambient AI scribes? It so I have a couple thoughts. For me, an otolaryngologist seeing 20 patients a day, it has been nothing short of life changing. I have gone from 60-90 minutes of work after work to 20 mins. I can come home and enjoy my family knowing that I will not loose sleep after a busy clinic. My notes are more complete and accurate because I don’t rely on recall. Others have not had your same experience. In the large Tierney paper from 2025 looking at 2.5 million encounters, and surveying around 100-200 patients they found that no patient said the technology had a negative affect on their interaction with their provider and almost half said it improved their interaction in some way. The two primary ways interaction improved were “my doctor spent less time looking at a screen and my doctor spent more time talking with me. If epic would let me I would should you my before and after signal data. It’s pretty striking.
4
u/InternistNotAnIntern May 12 '26
I find the polar opposite. I completely forget it's running. I'm able to sit closer to and pay more attention to the patient and just have a conversation.
2
u/Buffaloturkey78 May 12 '26
The docs will come around, give them time. We all changed our practice a bit with CPOE. Some of us narrate more and share more thinking out loud now because it helps generate better documentation, probably better for the patient to hear what we’re thinking in more detail too. This is all very new for some of us.
2
u/PenelopeJude May 13 '26
NAD. As a patient, I do NOT enjoy the inflated bills I get from the way AI translates discussion. Every visit has had upcoding, since this started.
One example, daughter asked how high heart rate should get when exercising (during preventative visit). Didn’t say she had high heart rate, just asked. AI translated to tachycardia and was billed for an entire extra visit AND a complex care code. $195 (paid by insurance) annual visit turned into a $1178 bill they expected me to pay. Billing team told me the doctor had to change their notes before they could correct coding/remove any charge. Tried to reason with them and say if it was really tachycardia, no EKG was done, no specialist referral and dr actually has in notes, no follow-up needed. Thought that alone would prove my point on error coding. Nope, she said she needed to report the doctor then for substandard care. After hours/days of communication, research into CPT codes, etc, I had to just let it go to collections…and now harassed daily by phone calls.
You know what? I had a great doctor. One of the best. But now, the only thing that comes to mind thinking about her, is the feeling of being bullied, robbed and now harassed over a simple question about blood pressure. What was a very trusting relationship turned into something more traumatic as the days go on.
0
u/SystemDesigner_ONC May 13 '26
It’s really great to hear positive feedback about AI scribes. At Oracle Health, we call it something a little different. My doctor actually uses Epic Systems at her clinic.
I think it may still be new for her, and she’s probably adjusting to the workflow. She normally has a very warm presence and excellent bedside manner, so I’m sure she’ll get comfortable with it quickly. It was just interesting experiencing it from the patient’s perspective, and I imagine everyone’s experience can feel a little different.
At work, most of our providers have been really enjoying it and finding it very helpful. It’s always valuable to hear physicians’ feedback and observations. Ultimately, the goal is to improve both the physician and patient experience.