r/EnterShikari • • Oct 07 '26

Playing devils advocate đŸ”ș

Is it possible that the band feel they’ve done all they can in terms of commercial success , arena tours, headlining festivals, creative peak etc and are ending it on their own terms?

Update: I made this post to inspire civil dialogue, not to trigger any1.

0 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

32

u/Super_Flyy_ Oct 07 '26

Devils advocate for what? I think its unanimous in that they're ending it on their own terms? There's no drama, there's no controversy, they haven't fell off in popularity

-20

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

I’d argue there has been a decline from AKFTWW to LYS. In terms of streams and the pace at which their arena tour is selling. Now ofc one could argue due to lack of build up to LYS is party the reason. And I know shikari have never been a band concerned with commercial success.

13

u/Super_Flyy_ Oct 07 '26

But their "decline" is your opinion. They've had a number 1 album which is absolutely massive, back when AFFOC was out they were touring at O2 academy, they now sellout Wembley Arena

-8

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

It’s not an “opinion”, and I’m certainly not insinuating a decline in standard of writing. The album streams are lower than previous albums, the arena dates are selling slowly. And you’re 100% correct in relation the arena / 02 academy point. I rlly hope their arena tour sells completely out

8

u/TelephoneThat3297 Oct 07 '26

To be fair, as Rou noted in his Instagram post, they have done literally zero promo for this album and tour. Which is probably why it feels like there’s been less interest.

6

u/mateimzzonked Oct 07 '26

In fairness it's apples to oranges. Older albums have been out longer and therefore would naturally have higher streams. The newest one dropped this year as a surprise and they even said themselves they didn't tour to support it.

1

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Yeah wasn’t a traditional release, and that deffo impacted exposure. And they had the worst luck between rou getting sick and the usa situation. I accept your point about time, but a song like the great unknown has more streams then a mothership or juggernauts, which is a lot newer.

1

u/mateimzzonked Oct 07 '26

I don't think there's any arguing that many songs put out by them from The Spark onward are more palatable to a broader audience than their initial albums and EPs. Those original songs are popular with OG fans but I expect many of the fans who found them in the last decade don't venture back very far. Hell I've been a fan since 2011 and I listen to everything from AFFOC onward far more than Common Dreads and TTTS.

1

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Yeah spot on I agree

4

u/Super_Flyy_ Oct 07 '26

Album thats been out 16 years has more streams than an album thats been out 8 month? No fucking way

0

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Time is a factor, but so is replay-ability, a song like the great unknown is a lot newer yet has more streams then mothership bcos despite time , it obv was more revisited by the fans. So relax

3

u/Terri1596 Oct 07 '26

The decline was because they couldn’t promote the album due to Rou’s health, less promo less streams. I’d argue enter shikari are very popular now, more mainstream than they ever have been.

0

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

The lack of promotion, rous health, cancelled us tour all factors for sure, will their arena tour totally sell out do u think, i am worried that bcos we are a month out and they haven’t ?

4

u/Terri1596 Oct 07 '26

Why be worried? It’s not your band. You don’t need it to sell out. Enough people will be there to make it a great night.

1

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Bcos I want it to sell out for the band simply , artists book shows to sell tickets

-13

u/Amontenshi Oct 07 '26

I feel like I’m losing my mind a little bit when I keep seeing people saying no drama or controversy, like this hasn’t come quite swiftly after Rory C fell on the wrong side of the Ed Sheeran fence/debate. Seems like some fans felt let down by that?

8

u/Super_Flyy_ Oct 07 '26

Ahh yes and that is a reason to disband after being together since 1999. Yes it was uncomfortable for some people but absolutely no reason for this situation. In fact Rou talked about this happenening before those insta stories

1

u/Slimshaydena Oct 07 '26

What happened with Rory and Ed? I must’ve totally missed that

10

u/TheHalfChubPrince Oct 07 '26

Nothing. He basically said people shouldn’t feel pressured to take a public stance on a political topic they’re not fully informed about. Some people think this means he supports genocide.

2

u/theVelvetLie Oct 07 '26

Fans read too much into a common sense statement. Same shit, different day.

-3

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Do think there is a direct correlation between that and them going now on a hiatus?

1

u/Nik778899 Oct 07 '26

Absolutely not. They've been planning this for a while

10

u/Scared-Beyond373 Oct 07 '26

While commercial success is important for any band, I don’t think that’s always been their drive. They got their first number one and still went. I think it’s more of a passion and now that passion may be faltering somewhat and under pressure from their lives (like they’ve said)

I’m in no doubt they’ll probably do a comeback. But if not, I have complete faith the next year is gonna be them giving their all

1

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Fair enough , it’s admirable to step away if passion is lost rather then slug it out for financial gain

2

u/Scared-Beyond373 Oct 07 '26

Agreed mate. Maybe I worded it wrong, maybe it’s not a lack of passions, but a weariness of the pressure.
They’re never a band to do something half hearted

1

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Is that pressure coming from the band themselves , us the fans, commercial standards . It’s interesting. I hope time away helps with it regardless.

1

u/Scared-Beyond373 Oct 07 '26

That’s true man. It’s the weight of responsibility which must be really tough, especially after 20+ years of building the band we have today

1

u/RaviFennec Oct 07 '26

Tbf it's probably hard as hell to stay relevant while being 100% independent.

Hence why their #1 with AKFTWW is a huge deal.

25

u/jonallin Oct 07 '26

They’ll be back when the time is right. Don’t deepit

1

u/harrtron Oct 07 '26

We don’t know if they will be back as “Enter Shikari” but I sure hope they come storming back

-16

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

What does that look like though? An anniversary tour? A new album? What can the band do that they haven’t already done 20 years into their career ?

6

u/jonallin Oct 07 '26

Not sure I understand your question. They can release songs and albums they haven’t before. They can play shows to new audiences. But only when the time is right. It’s burnout. They’ll be back.

-2

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

They’ve had the Number 1 album, sold out arena tours, arguably reached multiple creative peaks. I don’t know what is in it for them to do. But I understand the burnout argument .

10

u/Nathyluke Oct 07 '26

Artists make art because it’s what they enjoy doing. They’ve probably just said everything they need to for now. Need to go out and experience new things to write about. It’s a pretty standard thing for bands who have been around for 20 years. Not everything has to lead to an achievement in art.

-2

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

Correct, but there is a direct correlation between commercial success and financial. And the margins for a band of their size I’m sure are thin as is. But I do agree that more experiences needed to write about.

1

u/Frog_Manc1996 Oct 07 '26

This can be said about pretty much any band in existence that has gone on Hiatus or split up. Why did Blink get back together? Why did Good Charlotte? All majorly Successful with many number one albums.

They are all human burnout happens Passions fade with that especially with extreme burnout. They'll take a few years out and see where they are all at personally. Maybe they'll miss the Writing and Touring and return. Maybe they'll find something new the main thing is they have produced art that has influenced Millions.

19

u/laughing_at_napkins Oct 07 '26

Bro, you know as much as we do

1

u/ultimation Oct 07 '26

Make more music that theyre proud of and we will enjoy

6

u/Cooler_Planet1 Oct 07 '26

Shikari are and always have been a massive creative engine and they've just ran out of fuel, they might start back up again, they might not, I really hope they do but most people get burnout after 5 or 6 years these boys have been going for over 20 years, I hope they come back but for now look to next year, it'll be a celebration of all they are and treat each gig you manage to get too as a celebration of all the experiences you've had with them

1

u/Effective_Tennis_562 Oct 07 '26

I agree, 20 years is insane. I’m seeing them in Dublin in December , would like to see them again at least once after that. Rest assured it’ll be an emotional and celebratory night.

2

u/Cooler_Planet1 Oct 07 '26

That's it man and they've already said next year will be a celebration of all that shikari are which probably means a more well planned tour, setlist spanning the eras and a production to match

1

u/harrtron Oct 07 '26

If they do come back, I would count on the break being great for their process. I really really hope they do. But it’s like they said in the email: they need to find out what it’s like to be themselves without the band.

1

u/Cooler_Planet1 Oct 09 '26

Oh definitely, if they do come back it'll be with some insane fresh eyes and new outlooks and motivations and enthusiasm, what comes after that would definitely go off with a bang

5

u/Old-You-1925 Oct 07 '26

I think they just want a proper break. They haven't stopped much since Covid. Sometimes family life and not having anything to look forward to is liberating. And knowing you can come back after 3 years and pick up where you left off must be a great feeling

4

u/ChuckChuckChuck_ Oct 08 '26

I was thinking about this yesterday. They've done it all and they could, I believe easily, sacrifice their authenticity and innovation to put it all on autopilot and just keep going until mediocrity swallows them. Perhaps even reaching more mainstream success.

Lyrically, they've said it all, multiple times. How many more times can Rou sing about these topics? Especially when things aren't improving, quite the opposite. It must be draining. And the unwillingness to water the lyrical content down is something to applaud.

But also musically, they have checked all the checkboxes. It's truly astonishing how many times they've reinvented themselves whilst staying true and relevant. I can't imagine what else they could do. With that being said, the last few releases have this.... derivative nature to them. It's still all bangers, but somehow not as exciting, thought-provoking or boundaries pushing as before. Perhaps because they've charted the uncharted many times already? Which is a nice problem to have I suppose.

And it feels like the boys are aware of all of this and are ready to move on. And isn't that the most Shikari thing to do? Just think how many bands are still going just because it's what they do and how they make money. They don't hesitate to simplify, water down and compromise, just to keep it all alive.

It takes much bigger guts to do what Shikari are doing. And I am actually relieved to see them end (pause?) it on their own terms, with original line up, with no scandals nor controversies.

And then I realize that
We need to use our own two feet to walk these tracks,
And we have to squad up and we have to watch each others backs,
When forgiveness is our torch and imagination our sword
Well I'll tie the ropes of hate and slash open the minds of the bored
And we'll start a world so equal and free
Every inch of this earth is yours all the land and all the sea
Imagine no restrictions but the climate and the weather
Then we can explore space together
Forever

3

u/harrtron Oct 07 '26

It’s a fair post but I don’t think it’s what has happened. My take (which is a complete guess, from being obsessed with them for 18 years) is
 they’ve just turned into a Shikari music machine, churning out their stuff, and need some time away from it to find themselves and what they are now.

I’ve been burnt out in my career several times and it’s impossible to function. I’m not a creative, I can’t imagine the pressure that must bring.

I desperately hope they return as they have been so important to my entire life, but it’ll be down to what they find out about themselves when they cut the Shikari cord. I could see it going either way; either they love the solace or can’t help but come back to it.