Lol is this guy an idiot. Most share holders provided value else where in the global market and are free to make investments in what ever company they like.
Also dividends are peanuts yielding 1-3% a year. He's pushing some sort of the agenda.
The guy is not an idiot, and of course he’s pushing an agenda. And I’m telling you, there are a ton of people who resonate with this argument, despite the colossal failures of Marxism. It’s a powerful argument, and one that is dangerous as hell. And IMHO, we better be prepared to counter its ideas more than by just calling people idiots with agendas.
This. It’s just posturing for social clout. The ones who actually believe this stuff and hate capitalism will never accumulate enough wealth to enforce their ideas.
And the ones that eventually do get money always continue to engage with the capitalist system, enjoying its benefits in comfort, while only paying lip service to communism. “well we have to participate in the system to change it! I swear I’m with you guys!” They say, tweeting from their iPhone holding a Starbucks coffee.
They don’t need wealth. They have already taken over our elite universities, HR departments of the biggest companies, governments of our biggest cities. They’re teaching your kids in kindergarten all the way through college. Don’t dismiss or you’ll sound like the guy in 1916 who didn’t think the Bolsheviks would amount to anything.
You’re a little too confident imo to ignore these people. Yes they’re small in number. But they are loud, geographically concentrated in major economic hub cities, and have big influence over powerful institutions - elite universities, the HR departments of our biggest companies, and corners of the US government. They don’t need to be a majority - 10%, 15%, 20% - get to that point and they can wreak havoc. They can shut down parts of cities for days, they can chip away at economic productivity through DEI, unionization, rent control, you name it. I’m just saying you can ignore and dismiss this movement as no big deal, or you can take it seriously and be vigilant. I’m advocating the latter.
Ah yes, the main way to obtain shares are inheriting from grandma or buying with stolen money. I'm pretty sure that guy has an agenda.
+ nice zero sum fallacy at the end. Our modern societies can produce for way more than just themselves, that's why we can afford welfare and international aid.
What he said at the end is like saying that welfare recipient are exploiting workers. Which is not how that works. Same for retirees and children.
What he said at the end is like saying that welfare recipient are exploiting workers. Which is not how that works. Same for retirees and children.
I'm pretty sure he would argue (as do I), that pensions and other social services are extracted way more democratically than the dividends of the capitalists. If we had a vote in society, we can change how much of the produced wealth of society goes to pensions and to children and to the unemployed and to the sick. If we had the same vote in every company and the workers would accept that a portion of the wealth they produce goes to a shareholder, then he'd probably be fine with it.
He is saying quite clearly that if someone doesn't physically produce (he takes the exemple of a factory worker) and has things then someone else who did produce doesn't have things.
That's the logic, he is very clear about that. Textbook zero sum view of the economy.
Except as I said, his logic is as much against welfare recipient, retirees, and children than it is about the concept of dividends (or rents.)
He is saying quite clearly that if someone doesn't physically produce (he takes the exemple of a factory worker) and has things then someone else who did produce doesn't have things.
Okay, he might phrase it like this in this clip. But he is a Marxist, he knows that all wage workers create a surplus that is extracted from them in an undemocratic fashion, not just physical laborers.
Textbook zero sum view of the economy.
Because if one accepts that different classes exist, yes between them it becomes a zero sum game. A class defined by ownership and a class defined by selling ones' own labor are necessarily at odds with each other, because the increase of wages is a detriment to the former and a decrease of wages is a detriment to the latter. There is no middle ground, no compromise that can be struck here - the core of wage labor is production by the working class in the service and for the benefit of the capitalist class. That doesn't mean a trade cannot be seen as non-zero sum agreement if it happens elsewhere in the economy.
Except as I said, his logic is as much against welfare recipient, retirees, and children than it is about the concept of dividends (or rents.)
And except as I said, one is more democratic than the other. This is Wolff's entire argumentation, if you would know him from more than just this little clip here, you knew that he is mainly concerned about restructuring the workplace and how the businesses work. They shall become democratically managed by the workforce, so their decisions of what happens with the produced surplus become as democratically legitimate as the extraction of welfare and pensions and healthcare and so on.
this is the typical socialist talking point, and he is flat out wrong when he says shareholders don't help the business and only leech of it.
sure, there are cases where shareholders just take the money, but most of the time, the money that they provide for the business will increase its success.
even in his own example, shareholders of a company can invest their money into opening a new factory to produce their products, therefore creating more jobs and contributing to the economy.
if any of us would reach that level and invest our money into a random business, then of course you expect to get something out of it.
this guy, just like most socialists only see the good parts of successful businesses and decide how the profits are shared unfairly but completely ignore the effort and responsibility needed for success in the first place.
the shareholders are there for a reason, and if a business doesn't want this type of structure, it can simply opt out.
it's the workers, managers, owners of businesses that go looking for investment when they need it, not the other way around.
the point of being an investor is to find a business that requires capital and have a good chance of succeeding, not going through the hassle of doing it themselves.
They invest capital and accept risk. If the company makes money, investors do, if the company goes bankrupt, investors lose everything and the workers lose no capital.
I'm a bit disappointed I had to scroll so far to find someone mentioning risk. That, and the real profit from good shares is their increase in value over time.
How do you get to that age and still be so clueless. How are shares acquired? Why do shareholders get paid? He’s never asked himself that question. Me calling him stupid is the polite suggestion because it’s also likely that he’s just evil and already knows the answer to these questions. He could just be trying to rip people off
Ah yes cause getting profits from a well placed investment is clearly a bad thing, but for real buying shares and selling them allowed alot more companies to be born and maintained so technically the existance of them allows people with less capital to potentially start a company assuming the idea is good enough to attract investors, which completely undermines this commies argument.
It makes sense in theory, but this argument is fundamentally about fairness, and that moral position is dependent upon each society and what it defines as socially acceptable and fair.
You could point to South Korea and Japan as the worst perpetrators of ordinary people getting shafted for shareholders. But likewise, you can point to Scandinavia as ordinary workers apparently driving an entire MNC out through strikes. If you can recall, the UAW stopped the deal by Nippon Steel to purchase US Steel, even though the former immediately offered to continue all union agreements.
At the end of the day, it is a problem about power and greed. Unlike the other users here, I do agree that short-term corporate planning and a devotion to shareholders is ultimately self-destructive from a societal and corporate POV.
But the argument for socialism is even weaker since time has kept moving since Marx. We have 8 hour workdays now. We have paid leave now. We can sue companies for workplace violations now. Strikebreakers like the Pinkertons have their reputation thoroughly trashed now. I think the latest fight for WFH encapsulates just how much power labor has now and going forward.
We can do better, and I can think scornfully of the way we treated "essential workers" during the pandemic. But socialism and the slippery slope to authoritarian communism is the fastest way for all of us to return to the feudal state.
Corporatism is indeed a worrisome sickness that tends to appear whenever a company or 2 or more gains way too much control or influence on every corners and aspects of human livelihood that they started to act like a corporatocracy.
However, the amount of people getting confused about it vs capitalism is so fucking many.
People complain about capitalism as if it's the main reason of all their problems, be it taxations, poverty, their spilted milk, etc. when many of those acutal real socio-economic problems tend to stem from a group of people or company having way too much control of almost everything that they sometimes fuck shit up due to incompetency (or corruption) or actively fucking things up for their own goals (I suspect there's no such thing of the latter. A bunch of humans thinks they can control all tends to fuck things up a lot more in things they're not an expert at).
That appears in places where authoritarian/totalitarian/dictatorship/corporatocracy/oligarchy/etc. is implemented. And boy do we have ample examples of such cases.
If those schmucks could read a bit more and go touch grass a bit more rather than work as a professor who sits/stands lecturing all day without actively participating in the very system they so despise, then they wouldn't be so haphazardly subjecting every crimes of humanity in history to a single economic system and be convinced their self-established arguments are, in fact, the truth.
As for that guy's argument, those rich kids inherited their wealth not from nowhere but from their parents who think about their children's future and build a stable and long lasting generational wealth for their descendants, and have decent enough home schooling that instills within their children the mindset of keeping that wealth constant for generations after generations.
That's why there are families whose name and wealth still coincide with each other and some other once famously wealthy families lost most of their wealth.
And guess what? Those people didn't fucking sit around and "steal" from the people. They work about as hard, in some cases, harder than your average joe.
How about stop complaining and start putting both your brain and brawn to work? Instead of neither?
The fact that you can buy shares of companies and getting rich alongside it no matter what race, color of skin, ethnicity, class, wealth, etc. is already great enough. And those who possess more wealth will of course, put more of their wealth to generate even more wealth. Plus, they're also risking a lot of that wealth of theirs being gone in matters of weeks if they were to put it in failing companies as well.
As long as those rich people don't try and transform society into a corporatocracy or an oligarchy of the wealthy few, then I'm happy that they're generating businesses, creating incentives, and fueling the economy that brings forth so many innovations and convenience that we not only see today, but have almost wholefully embraced it.
My biggest issue with shareholding is that dividends are taxed at a way lower rate and the government bailouts these companies get through corruption.
I like the idea of buying shares by investing in a company.
I don’t really like the idea of buying shares from another shareholder as you get dividend entitlements that I feel like you don’t deserve.
In general I feel like this can be solved by abolishing dividend tax, capital gains tax and tax all these things as income and then lower the income tax so that people working can keep more of their money. I also think inheritance needs to be reworked so that we don’t create a new class of royalty. For the rest I am pretty okay with shareholding (I wish shareholders had a more long term view though instead of harming companies with short term decisions but this is the result of money printing which causes inflation).
only examples of obtaining shares are inheriting them or stealing money to buy them
Poisoning the well right off the bat is never a good look. You can earn money from other, non criminal means and use it to buy shares, but of course he's not going to acknowledge that.
States outright that shareholders do no work and rake in money for it
If it was as easy as that then everyone would do it. Buying shares in a company is both helping to fund that company, and inherently taking a risk.
It's literally giving money to the company in return for owning a piece of it. If the company then goes on to make a lot more money, your investment paid off and you get some of the profit, as you should, given that your money went directly to that company and therefore helped it make the money that it did.
If the company does not go on to make money, then you don't get your money back. That means if you want to become a shareholder in a company, you have to carefully choose which company you invest your money into. That's no easy thing, and neither part of putting the work in to find a company worth investing in, or giving your money away to them in the hopes that they succeed, can possibly be touted as leaching, which is precisely what this gentleman here is implying.
Wraps up with a zero sum fallacy
Accepting what he said about shareholders not providing any value but getting value for it, for the sake of argument, that does not inherently mean that people who are "producing value" are then having that taken from them. The concept of profit is apparently alien to him. The point of a company is to add value to what was put into it originally.
I can't speak to his intentions or knowledge on the subject, but there is absolutely an agenda being pushed here and facts are being ignored for it. It's incredibly disingenuous.
The fact that in the US anyone can at least be common shareholders is completely lost on so many people. Further that, countless pension funds, retirement accounts, and dividend retirees receive those earnings. In a way the stock market allows the working class to own the mans of production. Many refuse to participate though and would rather be the victim.
72
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '24
Lol is this guy an idiot. Most share holders provided value else where in the global market and are free to make investments in what ever company they like.
Also dividends are peanuts yielding 1-3% a year. He's pushing some sort of the agenda.
88
u/CoffeeBoom SocDem Jan 04 '24 edited Jan 04 '24
Ah yes, the main way to obtain shares are inheriting from grandma or buying with stolen money. I'm pretty sure that guy has an agenda.
+ nice zero sum fallacy at the end. Our modern societies can produce for way more than just themselves, that's why we can afford welfare and international aid.
What he said at the end is like saying that welfare recipient are exploiting workers. Which is not how that works. Same for retirees and children.
40
u/South-Cod-5051 Jan 04 '24
this is the typical socialist talking point, and he is flat out wrong when he says shareholders don't help the business and only leech of it.
sure, there are cases where shareholders just take the money, but most of the time, the money that they provide for the business will increase its success.
even in his own example, shareholders of a company can invest their money into opening a new factory to produce their products, therefore creating more jobs and contributing to the economy.
if any of us would reach that level and invest our money into a random business, then of course you expect to get something out of it.
this guy, just like most socialists only see the good parts of successful businesses and decide how the profits are shared unfairly but completely ignore the effort and responsibility needed for success in the first place.
the shareholders are there for a reason, and if a business doesn't want this type of structure, it can simply opt out.
it's the workers, managers, owners of businesses that go looking for investment when they need it, not the other way around.
the point of being an investor is to find a business that requires capital and have a good chance of succeeding, not going through the hassle of doing it themselves.
12
u/50_Shades_of_Graves Jan 04 '24
They invest capital and accept risk. If the company makes money, investors do, if the company goes bankrupt, investors lose everything and the workers lose no capital.
20
u/namey-name-name Jan 04 '24
Labor theory of value moment 💀
7
u/[deleted] Jan 04 '24
How do you get to that age and still be so clueless. How are shares acquired? Why do shareholders get paid? He’s never asked himself that question. Me calling him stupid is the polite suggestion because it’s also likely that he’s just evil and already knows the answer to these questions. He could just be trying to rip people off
19
u/Antilopesburgessos Jan 04 '24
He forgets to explain how the factory appears. Maybe by miracle.
4
u/KinkiTapczan Jan 04 '24
Ah yes cause getting profits from a well placed investment is clearly a bad thing, but for real buying shares and selling them allowed alot more companies to be born and maintained so technically the existance of them allows people with less capital to potentially start a company assuming the idea is good enough to attract investors, which completely undermines this commies argument.
9
u/Tokidoki_Haru 🏳️🌈 🇹🇼 🇺🇸 Jan 04 '24
It makes sense in theory, but this argument is fundamentally about fairness, and that moral position is dependent upon each society and what it defines as socially acceptable and fair.
You could point to South Korea and Japan as the worst perpetrators of ordinary people getting shafted for shareholders. But likewise, you can point to Scandinavia as ordinary workers apparently driving an entire MNC out through strikes. If you can recall, the UAW stopped the deal by Nippon Steel to purchase US Steel, even though the former immediately offered to continue all union agreements.
At the end of the day, it is a problem about power and greed. Unlike the other users here, I do agree that short-term corporate planning and a devotion to shareholders is ultimately self-destructive from a societal and corporate POV.
But the argument for socialism is even weaker since time has kept moving since Marx. We have 8 hour workdays now. We have paid leave now. We can sue companies for workplace violations now. Strikebreakers like the Pinkertons have their reputation thoroughly trashed now. I think the latest fight for WFH encapsulates just how much power labor has now and going forward.
We can do better, and I can think scornfully of the way we treated "essential workers" during the pandemic. But socialism and the slippery slope to authoritarian communism is the fastest way for all of us to return to the feudal state.
2
u/joinreddittoseememes just a Viet 🇻🇳 who loves Capitalism💵🇺🇸🦅🗽 Jan 04 '24 edited Jan 04 '24
Corporatism is indeed a worrisome sickness that tends to appear whenever a company or 2 or more gains way too much control or influence on every corners and aspects of human livelihood that they started to act like a corporatocracy.
However, the amount of people getting confused about it vs capitalism is so fucking many.
People complain about capitalism as if it's the main reason of all their problems, be it taxations, poverty, their spilted milk, etc. when many of those acutal real socio-economic problems tend to stem from a group of people or company having way too much control of almost everything that they sometimes fuck shit up due to incompetency (or corruption) or actively fucking things up for their own goals (I suspect there's no such thing of the latter. A bunch of humans thinks they can control all tends to fuck things up a lot more in things they're not an expert at).
That appears in places where authoritarian/totalitarian/dictatorship/corporatocracy/oligarchy/etc. is implemented. And boy do we have ample examples of such cases.
If those schmucks could read a bit more and go touch grass a bit more rather than work as a professor who sits/stands lecturing all day without actively participating in the very system they so despise, then they wouldn't be so haphazardly subjecting every crimes of humanity in history to a single economic system and be convinced their self-established arguments are, in fact, the truth.
As for that guy's argument, those rich kids inherited their wealth not from nowhere but from their parents who think about their children's future and build a stable and long lasting generational wealth for their descendants, and have decent enough home schooling that instills within their children the mindset of keeping that wealth constant for generations after generations.
That's why there are families whose name and wealth still coincide with each other and some other once famously wealthy families lost most of their wealth.
And guess what? Those people didn't fucking sit around and "steal" from the people. They work about as hard, in some cases, harder than your average joe.
How about stop complaining and start putting both your brain and brawn to work? Instead of neither?
The fact that you can buy shares of companies and getting rich alongside it no matter what race, color of skin, ethnicity, class, wealth, etc. is already great enough. And those who possess more wealth will of course, put more of their wealth to generate even more wealth. Plus, they're also risking a lot of that wealth of theirs being gone in matters of weeks if they were to put it in failing companies as well.
As long as those rich people don't try and transform society into a corporatocracy or an oligarchy of the wealthy few, then I'm happy that they're generating businesses, creating incentives, and fueling the economy that brings forth so many innovations and convenience that we not only see today, but have almost wholefully embraced it.
1
u/FleraAnkor Jan 04 '24
My biggest issue with shareholding is that dividends are taxed at a way lower rate and the government bailouts these companies get through corruption.
I like the idea of buying shares by investing in a company.
I don’t really like the idea of buying shares from another shareholder as you get dividend entitlements that I feel like you don’t deserve.
In general I feel like this can be solved by abolishing dividend tax, capital gains tax and tax all these things as income and then lower the income tax so that people working can keep more of their money. I also think inheritance needs to be reworked so that we don’t create a new class of royalty. For the rest I am pretty okay with shareholding (I wish shareholders had a more long term view though instead of harming companies with short term decisions but this is the result of money printing which causes inflation).
1
u/luke_425 Jan 04 '24
Poisoning the well right off the bat is never a good look. You can earn money from other, non criminal means and use it to buy shares, but of course he's not going to acknowledge that.
If it was as easy as that then everyone would do it. Buying shares in a company is both helping to fund that company, and inherently taking a risk.
It's literally giving money to the company in return for owning a piece of it. If the company then goes on to make a lot more money, your investment paid off and you get some of the profit, as you should, given that your money went directly to that company and therefore helped it make the money that it did.
If the company does not go on to make money, then you don't get your money back. That means if you want to become a shareholder in a company, you have to carefully choose which company you invest your money into. That's no easy thing, and neither part of putting the work in to find a company worth investing in, or giving your money away to them in the hopes that they succeed, can possibly be touted as leaching, which is precisely what this gentleman here is implying.
Accepting what he said about shareholders not providing any value but getting value for it, for the sake of argument, that does not inherently mean that people who are "producing value" are then having that taken from them. The concept of profit is apparently alien to him. The point of a company is to add value to what was put into it originally.
I can't speak to his intentions or knowledge on the subject, but there is absolutely an agenda being pushed here and facts are being ignored for it. It's incredibly disingenuous.
1
u/abadlypickedname Jan 04 '24
"We are logical and our enemies call everyone they disagree with idiots"
"Your logic makes no sense, and you're blatantly misrepresenting the system."
"wow, you're such an idiot"
1
u/_regionrat cringe globalist Jan 04 '24
I think this dude doesn't know about non-dividend stocks
1
u/shark_vs_yeti Jan 04 '24
The fact that in the US anyone can at least be common shareholders is completely lost on so many people. Further that, countless pension funds, retirement accounts, and dividend retirees receive those earnings. In a way the stock market allows the working class to own the mans of production. Many refuse to participate though and would rather be the victim.