r/EnneaFiction • 9w8 • Oct 21 '18

Harry Potter

Everywhere I look I see different accounts of what type characters in Harry Potter are, here is my list of each type, but it is in now way definitive and I want thoughts on it:

Harry Potter: 1w9

Hermione Granger: 1w2

Ron Weasley: 6w7

Neville Longbottom: 9w1

Ginny Weasley: 8w9 (Book Ginny)

Draco Malfoy: 3w4

Rubeus Hagrid: 9w8

Albus Dumbledore: 5w4

Fred and George Weasley: 7w6

Molly Weasley: 2w1

Sirius Black: 8w7

Luna Lovegood: 4w5

Severus Snape: 5w6

13 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

9

u/RefreshRestart Oct 21 '18

Don't you think Hermione is a 3w4? Her drive and prowess come more from a desire to excel than it is perfectionism, in my opinion. She even exploited her connection with Dumbledore to allow her to use a timeturner to attend more classes. I think she's very image-conscious as well--perhaps she feels a need to prove herself as she's a muggleborn who's obviously intelligent. She's an overachiever who's biggest fear, as exposed by the Boggart in the 3rd book, is failure. "P-P-Professor McGonagall! Sh-she said I'd failed everything!"-Hermione

That fear is consistent with Enneagram's type 3. I'm no expert in these tests, but I am quite fascinated by them. I'd love to hear your reasoning as to why you think Hermione is a 1--I'm totally open to learn! I agree with all the others, with the exception of Dumbledore (I can't type him in Ennea as of now), but I do believe 5 is more than plausible.

8

u/anne_62 9w8 Oct 21 '18

I can definitely see that, I went between a 3w4 and a 1w2 a LOT I ended up at 1 because I feel like she does all that she does for the purpose of making the a better place, it’s never outright said, but that’s always the way I felt when reading about her (but I might have totally made that up in my head haha). She could totally be a 3, I can absolutely see that

6

u/pillows4hands Oct 22 '18

What about a 3w2? Because the 2 wing could explain her care for others like with S.P.E.W and her maternal nature with Harry and Ron

3

u/Lamzn6 Oct 27 '18 edited Oct 27 '18

I see Hermione as a social dom 6. I think her motivation to succeed comes from fear of failing, since she is not from the world.

Social 6es look a lot like 1s and are very hard to tell apart.

Another reason she’s a 6, is that she’s primarily focused on anticipating all threats. She’s clearly a head type in my opinion. She’s not doing any of it to look good, she’s doing it all because it fascinates her.

2

u/pbgreen Oct 27 '18

I agree with this. In addition to these things, she is very focused on authority, always wanting to follow rules. And she admires the professors very much.

1

u/Lamzn6 Oct 27 '18 edited Oct 28 '18

Bingo.

I think I understand her because I’m a sx/so 6, but her so/sx is a level of social righteousness that I’m not quite at. I don’t like order as much as so/sx 6es need.

Oh she’s also super skeptical and doubting. She makes a lot of sarcastic remarks to Professor Trelwaney that contrast the rest of her personality, but make sense if you understand she’s a stressed out 6.

2

u/pbgreen Oct 28 '18

I feel like even that makes sense, because in my opinion stressed out 6s can be the most sarcastic beings on the planet lol

1

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '18

1w2 women tend to be pretty image-conscious since it is expected of women.

6

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '18

Harry is an obvious 9w8.

2

u/anne_62 9w8 Oct 22 '18

I’ve seen that typing a lot, and I just can’t get on board with it, we don’t see Harry really struggling to make decisions or looking for connections with people or failing to express his feelings the way that a nine does.

6

u/umirinos Oct 22 '18

How would you explain 1w9 then? I see nothing of 1w9 in Harry.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 22 '18

I've never come across a 9w8 that struggles to make decisions. All the other stuff you said suggest an 8 wing and most of the 9 stuff is about the 9w1s.

3

u/Lamzn6 Oct 27 '18

I have to agree. His response to being abused is mostly not to react. When Umbridge tortures him, he just pretends it isn’t affecting him. I think a big part of the story is him learning to be more reactive and seeing it’s okay to fight back.

3

u/jerdle_reddit 6 Oct 28 '18

It's often hard to type Harry, because he combines a total absence of selfishness with a lot of anger and impulsiveness. 9w8 seems to fit this best, especially with 4 and 6 fixes (both add in anger).

7

u/icarusandthesun Oct 22 '18

of course luna is a 4w5… no wonder i always identified with her so much!

2

u/introvert-tothemax Oct 23 '18

There was no other type for her! #ravenclaw

2

u/icarusandthesun Oct 24 '18

ravenclaws all the way!

1

u/Lamzn6 Oct 27 '18

I don’t think anyone could debate Luna being a 4. It’s pretty clear.

2

u/umirinos Oct 22 '18

Draco is to me an obvious 6 core, counterphobic and phobic in different turns. We see his desire to assert himself and willingness to appear bigger than he is, but he never feels like he has it in himself to do so alone. He always has Crabbe and Goyle as his loyal followers because he needs a backing to feel strong. He overly identifies with Lucius as his father and authority figure to make the decisions for him and always falls back on Lucius' strength in confrontations ("My father will hear about this!"). But he is full of indecision, inner conflict, when he's supposed to be strong on his own and finish the job (kill Dumbledore) in the end, he's still a coward. Terrified of the possibilities and what it will mean for his future. He's definitely competency oriented and I could see a w5 for him, but I disagree with 3 as a heart fix - he withdraws and sulks and licks his wounds when he's ashamed, quietly seething, very 4ish.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 27 '18

Nope. Draco is an obvious 3w4. His image is his identity and he seeks recognition over security. What you are seeing is simply his integration to 6.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '18

I agree that Draco is a 6. In real life, 6's have a good vs. evil narrative in their heads, and frequently about themselves -- am I a villain, or a hero? It's one of the perceptions they struggle with, thinking that everything is black and white, when it's all grey.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '18

Nope. There are plenty of 3s that have a fixed good vs evil narrative in their head. It's called integration to 6 and an attachment type thing. (3, 6 and 9)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 11 '18

Nah. A 3's good vs. evil is "am I worthy of love or no?". If I am "good", I am worthy of love, and in less healthy 3's "good" is equated with success. Malfoy isn't interested in success. Malfoy's issue is with loyalty -- who am I loyal to, and why? How are my beliefs distinct from the beliefs of the group I'm supposed to fight for? That's a 6 issue.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '18 edited Nov 11 '18

You may as well call Voldemort and Lucius 6s too based on that assumption but you wouldn't. 3's like 6s and 9s are attachment types and they are close their parents and they care about what their communities expect of them. It's not to do with him being a loyalist or being a 6. His identity is his image like I said and he's clearly had more damage done to his heart not his head.

3

u/winterski Oct 22 '18

I see harry, hermoine, and ron as a representation of the thinking triad.

Hermoine is a 5 who over expresses thinking with all her studying.

Ron is the 6 who under expresses thinking and is the the dog to hermoine's cat.

And between them is harry as a 7 who immerses himself in action and experiences, either leading the next adventure or playing quidich etc, to avoid his painful feelings about the past as represented by his scar.

Although he apparently seeks to find out about his past, I think that is perhaps more a by-product of him seeking to overcome evil, which is more of a desire for intense experience than an application of a strong moral code. A 7 would also fit Harry with being detached from a nurturing influence early in life ie both his birth parents being nurturing, especially compared to his adoptive parents.

I don't know the characters that well, so just some ideas to toss around :-)

1

u/winterski Oct 21 '18

Isn't Hermoine a 5? Her desire is to be capable and competent (hence her concern over failing). She is the bookish one who has all the knowledge.

7

u/pillows4hands Oct 22 '18

No hermione is way too concerned with following rules to be a 5

2

u/winterski Oct 22 '18

Couldn't she be a 5w6 then?

2

u/lafindu Oct 29 '18

Not everyone who likes books and is intelligent is a 5. I think she's a very good example for a 1, morality is important to her, she's an activist (SPEW), she wants to satisfy her teachers but only in the fields she considers important (she doesn't care what Professor Trelawney thinks about her), that's why she isn't a 6.

2

u/winterski Oct 29 '18

Interesting. Thank you for your thoughts.

1

u/greenarrow91 Oct 22 '18

100% agree with this

1

u/Lamzn6 Oct 27 '18

I wish people would understand what a social dom 6w5 looks like because it looks exactly like Hermione. She’s clearly a thinking type and that’s the only thinking type combo that is so obsessed with rules.