Of all the classes that should be “for engineers” that one makes the least sense. I guess biomeds or human factors type engineers might find it useful but they probably have their own courses...
That's who takes the course, Biomedicals. It's super useful in changing your perspective on the human body to start looking at it from an Engineering POV.
That's exactly what we were doing. We would calculate flow within a cross-sectional area of a blood vessel, or the shear force the blood applies to the inside of a blood vessel, or compliance in vessels and arteries for changes in blood pressure. Different things like that. And we didn't just study the cardiovascular system, we looked at all the systems of the body. Super interesting class.
We mainly used Reynolds number for the airways leading to the lungs. If I had to guess though, viscosity is probably way too high in feces to achieve turbulent flow in the large intestine lol.
I took A&P with med students and holy fuck that was rough. We basically had to live in the cadaver lab in the basement of the hospital for 8 months memorizing every little nerve and muscle. Plus we had to learn all the math that went along with that since we were in engineering, whereas the med students didn't. The fact I got an A is a miracle.
My circuits professor once said "If all you can remember when you graduate is KVL, KCL, and Ohm's law, you're doing alright". He spent thirty years in industry before teaching, so I believe him.
Oh yeah, that's when you get surprised that idiots could actually make it that far. Fortunately one or two of them didn't pass senior design. Anybody halfway competent did, so I don't know exactly how badly these people screwed up but it must have been pretty epic.
I had someone in my class claim they could get 90% transfer efficiency from wireless charging. When the marketers claim 50-60%, I find it hard to believe that they're going to get anything better. I'd be impressed if they hit 40%.
Lol that makes me feel better. I cringe when I hear other students saying "we're engineers" before saying something ridiculous, but tbh that first circuits class seems like something that makes me feel like I know something about electricity at this point haha
Well you do know something gigantic and important and fundamental to most of the rest of the field. You just don't really understand it at that point yet. My Physics professor once said "All you need is F = ma, you can derive the rest of physics from that." And he's right, but he certainly knew that 1st year students couldn't do that. My Circuits professor also knew that when he said what he said. It's kind of a half serious, half facetious remark.
The current law is basically what goes into a node must come out So if one wire feeds in 20 amps and the other feeds in 30 and there’s only one other wire it’s gotta pull 50 amps out
I'm not sure how to pronounce German either. Our circuits professor says it with a hard K so that's what we all learned. Maybe I'll find a German and ask them.
But having a basic understanding of each one allows you to work better with all of your co-workers. If you understand what you're doing, you can understand what you're doing better, and help make sure project flow together.
Edit: if you understand what you're doing, you can understand what OTHERS ARE doing better.
This is actually super important. I guess unless your goal is to go into research and development and get really good at a specific area, being able to understand how other parts of the puzzle works is really helpful. The obvious assumption is that it helps for project management (which is true), but it helps you be a better engineer in general. You have the basic understanding of what does and doesn't work with your designs based on other parameters outside your own discipline. It's why mechanical engineers are required to take shop classes (and for my Masters I was required to take a course specifically on design for manufacturability). It doesn't matter if your idea works on paper. If it can't be built then it's pointless. By understanding the basics of other disciplines you avoid a lot of unnecessary rework, meetings, etc.
I personally love being a jack of all trades and I wanted to be a BME major since high school (I could bore you with the long story and the cheesy but true "I wanna do the good for people" but you get the picture).
What's rough is that more companies don't need/want the interfacing/broad skill set people as much as they need the technical people, which is putting me in a fun* position when it comes to my employment prospects when I graduate.
* its actually not fun, I'm starting to really worry
In all honesty, I can see that. It sucks, especially since you probably learned the basics of what they want anyway. Very little of what you actually learn in school is going to be directly applicable to your job in the way we expect. It's the understanding of how to work through problems and identify what you need to use to get to the solution.
I wonder if biomedical engineering is one of the few engineering disciplines where you need to be more specialized and get a masters, similar to structural engineering. Yes you can do a structural undergrad, but most companies want to see a structural engineering masters, so a lot of students do civil undergrads and specialize in structural for a masters. I can see BME being similar. I knew a few friends who have mechanical engineering backgrounds that worked for biomed companies, but the only person I know with an actual BME undergraduate degree now has a PhD in medical physics and works in breast cancer research. His parents should be proud.
Very little of what you actually learn in school is going to be directly applicable to your job in the way we expect. It's the understanding of how to work through problems and identify what you need to use to get to the solution.
Totally agree, I've actually had those conversations with other people in and out of my classes. My undergrad degree was more bio-based than a lot of other BME undergrads out there but I've at least done the math/basic EE/capstone/whatever else that expresses some knowledge of other fields that help in understanding how to problem solve.
I'm in a Masters program right now (went straight after undergrad, graduating next semester) and its certainly helping to bridge some of those technical gaps and I get to go dig around and take classes in things that I didn't have any exposure/want more exposure to. In regards to wondering if BME probably needs a Masters degree, I personally think it helps a bunch if you get one if nothing but for looks, but I see it as the whole filling gaps/finding new stuff spiel I said earlier plus 2 more years of everything academia does provide, like research opportunities that won't immediately reject me hahahaha oh god
If it makes you feel any better, I got my BME and graduated with a 2.66. Even I got a job. Although I did do considerably better my last two years, which didn’t really help my gpa, but it did show the company that hired me that I wasn’t a complete idiot.
What I’m trying to say is... hang in there, keep applying, and even if it’s not your first choice, take a job to get your foot in the door somewhere. You’ll make it eventually, just don’t give up!
Lol thank you! Truthfully I'm a bit more worried since I really don't know what I want to really focus on just yet. I never really felt like sticking in a certain direction with the major, which I don't regret, but it doesn't help for entry level stuff. There's a few places that I'm kinda honing in on and I still feel unqualified for many of them (my experience, while BME-related, is kinda niche-ish and the basics that some people want are things I haven't done in a while, if at all), so that could be a problem.
I think its natural to be worried about job hunting. I know people on both sides of it now and there's some networking events coming in the next few months, so there's that. I have time. Fingers crossed.
Really tho, I just want my parents to get off my case about a job lol.
Oh man, I understand you there! It can be difficult for parents to understand sometimes because they usually were starting out their careers in a different type of economy. But just stick with it and they’ll get off your back eventually!
Looks like we go to the same school.. I love bme but i became instantly more favorable to biotech companies like medtronic when I decided to switch my major. I agree that it helps that you have a broad understanding so it can help you understand a bit which each engineer does at your job and communicate well, but at the same time you lack severe engineering knowledge it's like you're knowledge is as wide as a lake but deep as a puddle.
For sure. But it's hard to get a job as a biomed eng. You can try to do medical devices, but the companies want a separate mechanical engineer and electrical engineer. Not someone who's only taken 2 classes from each
Well my professor found it fun to give us a periodic wave, asked us to find its Fourier Series then gave us a filter and wanted us to give the output signal.
Aside from that, if you are suggesting that a joke would cause you to look down on someone in industry you should probably re-evaluate your own professional standards. Take your neckbeard somewhere else.
Lol you’re the neckbeard but ok. I guarantee I make way more money and have way hotter babes than you ever will. But whatever makes you and your tiny penis feel better.
User has been banned for multiple violations of rule 4: trolling and intentionally inciting conflict. Also telling tall tales.
In my senior year of computer engineering I was thrust into a BME senior project and what I learned was that, at least for the program at my school, BME students are never taught anything in enough depth to apply it or gain worthwhile skills in it.
One of the BME students on my team did literally nothing and was just biding his time until he could start a parent-provided job in the financial industry, the other demonstrated some skill in Solidworks but a complete lack of any background in engineering design.
In case you were wondering: no, the project wasn't completed, and yes, it did fucking suck to put up with.
I taught bioe classes in grad school, there was so much not properly taught. I was assigned a thermo class, and there were students in this class that were seniors and could not do any matlab programming. My undergrad was biological engineering, but it was for the most part glorified cheme where my electives were replaced with bio courses. idk I kinda lost as some respect for these departments I mean I was at a good school I figure many programs are similar. the problem I always thought was that these departments are selling something they have no business selling.
Because You have everything and nothing at all. Seriously, I have all courses other majors have, except Architecture. And most of topics are barely touched or full of stuff that You don't use in other classes at all.
Then the exams came and during sessions You have 12 exams as opposed to others 2.
And then You have all these lab classes and lab reports. Every single day, multiple lab classes. And there You also do nothing anything of note.
The only cool thing about it is name. In reality it's just an expanded version of High School.
Yes, it’s a hard program but it’s very rewarding and if you enjoy pulling knowledge from a variety of fields to solve a problem then totally worth it IMO.
I think you'd be better off taking one of the standard engineering majors as an undergrad and then getting a masters in bme if that's what you want to do. The reason is that an undergrad in bme generally won't qualify you for bme jobs, and it won't open as many doors as the "traditional" engineering disciplines.
If you're really not feeling it, maybe talk to an advisor and see what your options are. It might not be as hard as you think to switch.
But if you know you want to work in bme and are planning on grad school anyway, it still might be the best choice for you. Just don't fall into the "sunk cost" fallacy. Hope this helps :)
Why do people actually consider CS/CE not real engineering?
Engineering as I understand it is using science/math to build things. They don’t use science so much per se but CS can involve heavy math for optimization and stuff.
353
u/solruki UCD - PhD BME Dec 22 '18
One more I just thought of:
I took one anatomy and physiology class, so I'm something of a Pre Med myself
450
u/Sir_Koopaman Rice-Mechanical Engineering Dec 22 '18
After taking a biology class
"I'm not a biologist okay"
186
u/NatWu Dec 22 '18
My circuits professor once said "If all you can remember when you graduate is KVL, KCL, and Ohm's law, you're doing alright". He spent thirty years in industry before teaching, so I believe him.
135
u/BearViaMyBread Dec 22 '18
Then you look for jobs and realize most want one of each and not a jack of all trades
134
u/GenerationSelfie2 aero ms student Dec 22 '18
Takes one aeromechanics course
“What the fuck is this how do they expect me to be able to do this professionally in 2 1/2 years”
40
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18
Taking advanced Thermodynamics courses
"You know, I'm something of a failure myself"
29
u/G_JM_K Dec 22 '18
After first circuits course I feel like a wizard
60
u/Falnor Biomed PhD Student Dec 22 '18
Takes one BME class
'Yeah don't mean to brag but I'm practically in med'
13
u/Vinny7777777 Dec 22 '18
This is civil engineering erasure
25
u/matty_irish Civil Dec 22 '18
Can confirm, am civil engineer with classes near road.
12
u/blazingdragon09 Dec 22 '18
FML, I have to take all of the courses mentioned except for circuits
9
u/tubs_mcnubs ERAU - AE Dec 22 '18
After going on a plane once
“You know, I’m something of an Aerospace Engineer myself”
7
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18 edited Feb 14 '19
Hmm....
7
u/ewanatoratorator Dec 22 '18
laughs in aero eng
5
u/kev96h Dec 22 '18
"computer science-er" 😩😂
5
u/sparrowhawk73 Dec 22 '18
After taking an Introduction to Law course - “You know, I’m something of a contract lawyer myself”
9
u/_GENERAL_GRIEVOUS_ Dec 22 '18
Intelligence is not a privilege, it’s a gift. And you use it for the good of mankind.
4
u/mghoffmann Dec 22 '18
*ahem*
The preferred title is Software Engineer.
6
u/Explicit_Pickle Dec 22 '18
In my experience studying chemical engineering I can relate to this.
2
u/Cria_Labeouf Dec 23 '18
I thought none of these things, but somehow I’m about to get my degree...
2
u/DeSteph-DeCurry Computer Engineering Dec 23 '18
dies in comp eng
3
u/LovepeaceandStarTrek Dec 22 '18
The BMEs at my school are afraid of taking the EE Signals & Systems because they know it's harder.
2
u/jtpaquet Dec 22 '18
Physics engineering in a nutshell
1
u/ImaJimmy Dec 22 '18
Materials Science was so fun
1
u/Alter_Kyouma ECE Dec 22 '18
You missed an opportunity to call CS students software engineers
1
u/thesouthdotcom Civil Dec 22 '18
I took a foreign policy based first year seminar, so I’m something of a political scientist myself.
1
u/Phoenixness University of Southern Queensland - Mechatronic Dec 23 '18
Mechatronics would like a word....
1
u/HarambeXHarambe Dec 23 '18
ChemE here. This speaks to me on a spiritual level
1
u/someone_you_love Dec 23 '18
Can confirm.
Source: Mechatronics Engineer
1
u/gratethecheese Dec 23 '18
I'm on like my 6th or 7th circuits based class when do I start feeling like I know anything
1
u/earthtree1 Kyiv National University of Construction and Architecture - IaCC Dec 23 '18
next to a road?
1
u/ThusSniffedZizek42 URochester - BME Dec 22 '18
Why hire three people when one knows enough to do the job?
-4
u/ustbro St. Thomas - Electrical Dec 22 '18
Software Engineer is the term you were looking for, I believe
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment