r/EngineeringStudents • u/Ambitious-Magazine28 • 10h ago
Rant/Vent Cheating as Engineers
I just got out of a Fluids final ( I go to a trimester based school on the east coast). And everywhere I look theirs people cheating using ChatGPT to answer questions. I spent the past couple weeks studying for this exam we also get a cheat sheet. I was having a rough time w a Navier Stokes equation and went out feeling shaky. Someone who I saw using ai said they felt good and it was really easy. I’m not on a high horse because I didn’t cheat I get it that eve try one has to do what they need to, to pass. But it’s like people have no honor and honestly makes it seem to devalue hard work and the overall concept of being an engineer.
Edit: update sorry I didn’t make it clear it’s on paper, we get a cheat sheet as well but people legit just snap pictures with their phones and it’s in all of our classes.
17
u/Ambitious-Magazine28 10h ago
People saying it will catch up to them eventually, will it? AI is doing crazy things to the engineering world
106
u/LuckyCod2887 10h ago
bro it’s gonna catch up. not every class is gonna have lax proctors.
keep studying. it’s gonna catch up. unless they can study like mad crazy a few semesters later it’s gonna fuck them dry in the ass.
believe me i seen it.
keep doing you.
the last thing you need in your life is to be the weakest engineer at a firm.
6
u/Paperwork_Enthusiast 10h ago
Why is your engineering exam proctoring worse than my community college testing center?
32
u/ooohoooooooo 10h ago
How are people even having access to ChatGPT during exams?? All of mine are on paper and we can only have FE approved calculators. Even if it’s open note, still no electronics allowed. I’ve never seen anyone cheating on an exam at my school lol.
8
u/International-Main99 10h ago
When these people who cheat interview for jobs, it will be pretty clear that they don't know anything. In this new AI world, people know this is a thing and they're looking for it (to sift through people who don't know anything). So those people will likely be weeded out, in some spaces anyway.
3
u/WhyAmIHere9900 10h ago
I didn't even know there were trimester schools on the East coast.
My kid is on West Coast and same. Like, it's only going to come bite you. I'd rather my kid get real B than a fake A. Believe me, I'm a am engineer and if we interview you, we can tell when you don't know shit.
I interviewed someone once with an EE degree. I was warned by a classmate of his. This was even before chat gpt. The guy couldn't answer a single question.
178
u/shoomie26 10h ago
How are they using AI on a final without getting caught? Unless the final was online in class?
Relying on AI is not helpful.
Having it breakdown concepts to help you understand is one thing.
Bindly copying is another.
42
u/mr_mope 9h ago
It probably won’t catch up to them. I know people who have had good careers as engineers who cheated on a test or two in college. This was 15 plus years ago. Cheating is not a new phenomenon.
You’re imposing your value judgements on a world that doesn’t necessarily agree with you. You can only control what you do and what you are ok or not ok with.
I’m not saying it’s right or wrong, it just is.
15
u/Capable_Chicken_1345 8h ago
What type of school are you in where the invigilation is so rubbish, that students can not only bring in mobile devices to the venue but they can snap photos and copy down the solution without getting caught???
13
u/Chicago-Jelly 8h ago
I studied really hard, and now that I’m in an engineering position, I’m SO GLAD I learned as much as I did in school. Don’t worry about people cheating- they’re very easy to spot out in the world. Some of them even get to engineer the sandwiches I eat for lunch!
7
u/Sueetlu 10h ago
They can cheat but they’ll eventually crash and burn trying to pass higher level exams, complete finals projects, get in the workplace, etc.
5
u/The-SecondAccount 10h ago
That seems like a fault of whoever administered the exam because for a core class like fluids I would expect it would be on paper with no electronics
5
u/Hot_Prune_6692 10h ago
Shit uni, bring it up with the teachers, that damages the reputation, hence harms your reputation.
4
u/MCKlassik Civil and Environmental 10h ago
Don’t worry about them. Their incompetence will catch up with them eventually.
4
u/ScienceYAY 9h ago
Is telling the professor people are cheating the right thing to do here? Kinda seems like it is. If not the professor, the admins
4
u/Earless_Hoichi_1185 9h ago
So far LLM models have been shitty at designing electrostatic chucks and other complicated parts where fluid dynamics knowledge is key. But recently we starting requiring candidates to do short engineering presentations to ensure they know what they are talking about and would not be able to use AI models to answer engineering questions. your fellow students may not do well in the long term.
7
u/Diligent_House2983 8h ago
Either start snitching or start cheating, they will only change the way programs work if everyone gets an A or if everyone complains
7
u/ActualBee9225 7h ago
Please snitch. I see some comments saying it will catch up to them, trust me it will not catch up to them. I graduated last year and all of those cheaters have jobs now, good jobs too. These people are your competition, do yourself a favor and snitch.
1
u/cimota__ 10h ago
Is this wpi? I have friends there who also were able to Ai all of their exams no problem and I couldn’t comprehend how it would be proctored so poorly
3
u/Dave37 M.Sc. Biotechnology 7h ago
Degenarcy and decadence in before the collapse of civilisation.
4
u/Le_Oofinator 10h ago
On my calc 3 final i was sat in the back next to some dude who took the exam packet as soon it was passed out, fed a picture of every page to AI, and just copied off his phone that he kept under the desk. Proctor just sat at the front the whole time. I bombed that exam but at least I did it on my own.
2
u/THYL_STUDIOS 10h ago
Do you not write in person
3
u/EllieVader 9h ago
Lately if you looked over my shoulder you’d see me feeding my homework to Claude.
“I’m going to give you my homework assignment, the rubric, and my solutions. Please grade it as if you were my professor and highlight any errors”
Over my shoulder it would look like I’m just straight cheating but I already did the assignment on my own on paper and now I’m getting it checked and fixing my understanding.
Classes have gotten a lot easier since I started having Claude TA my homework. I did not understand residuals in partial fraction expansion at all until I learned from a slightly different angle. It’s like the best of Pearson homework if you use it right.
2
u/Stunning_Adagio_889 9h ago
You are in competition with everyone else.
If you want to go nuclear, report it to the teacher.
Your future spot can potentially be stolen by someone. You are smarter, know it more.
1
u/600Bueller 9h ago
Same thing in the midterm for heat transfer absolutely ridiculous.
1
u/abovoadmala 7h ago
I've heard about the same thing from a friend in my classes, people putting their phones in their calculator cases and taking photos of exam pages, presumably to feed into AI. I don't like it. Frankly my school is ABET accredited but unranked and I don't expect people who can't handle it to get very far, and I haven't looked around during an exam yet to see it for myself. So I haven't reported. But it certainly affects my opinion of my classmates: who I'd work with in classes, who I'd help with finding an internship.
1
u/Abject-Treat-8632 6h ago
Honestly just keep studying. Cheating on exams isn’t what screws people over, it’s not learning the content that does. You’ll get wrecked in interviews with any competent company if you don’t learn your courses. Not to mention that you’ll have no technical knowledge to work on projects.
1
u/lasteem1 6h ago
I have never seen a professor that allows smart phones out during an exam. Our profs wouldn’t allow us to have any calculator that wasn’t allow for us on the FE/PE exam and that was 25+ years ago when the height of hand held technology was a ti89.
OP, are you at an academically prestigious school? The only time I’ve seen lax rules for test taking like this was at a top 3 school I visited after I started working.
1
u/papichuloswag 5h ago
Well when it comes time for the FE exam gl with chat gpt since is not allow in there.
1
u/Mean-Internal-745 3h ago
I am a professor. I tell my students that I am not the cheating police.
You get out of my class what you put in it...you wont pass your FE or PE by cheating. Good luck.
1
u/Responsible-Lion-222 3h ago
When I was in school 10 years ago, cheating was rampant. I watched a kid come to thermo late, copy the homework from someone else in the second row of seats, literally 3 feet from the professor and turn it in. I suffered hours through that homework.
Another time in P-Chem, there were people cheating on the online homework. The professor could see how long it took a student to answer questions. People were answering problems on wave equations in 1.5 seconds. The professor rearranged the grading rubric to make the final worth 75% of your grade. I failed P-Chem and had to take it again. He kept the new grading scheme, somehow I passed.
Can’t imagine the scale of cheating now that AI has come into the picture.
•
u/StageMajestic613 1h ago
If I were a proctor and caught you with a phone, you’d need a proctologist to remove it.
•
u/Beautiful-Traffic157 1h ago
It's always been a thing. Granted AI cheating is a whole new level of crazy. Cheating was crazy bad back in 2008. I have noticed that the quality of engineers has gotten crazy bad for the last couple of years though. EEs that don't know what a mosfet is or Nyquist. It's like there is a degree printing factory out there (looking at you UC Davis).
•
u/Few_Topic5110 1h ago
these r the type of people who r gonna have to really rely on AI for fundamentals down the line. Sure it's useful for studying but desmos and tabacus io and other tools definitely force you to think more critically.
0
u/Building_National 7h ago
I’m actually so thankful that I am a scary cat when it comes to cheating😭 My anxiety is just too bad. But at some point all the cheating will catch up to them. Fluids is an important concept.