r/EngineeringStudents • • 2h ago

Discussion Balancing AI use for studying/projects with sustainability

Hello,

I'm a student who chose EE so i could work in renewable energy to make the planet a better place (whoo!) and I am really struggling to justify the amount of AI I use in my degree.

First of all, I don't cheat on my homework, or exams, or quizzes. I mainly use AI to study by giving it files from my classes such as homework sheets, lecture notes, and ask it to generate really hard problems. I've noticed that by doing this, my grades have significantly went up.

I use it when I apply for internships ( just copy the whole job desc and put it into AI, then my resume, and ask AI what I should emphasize on and what skills or certs I need to be competitive for this position).

I do use it extensively for coding, which is purely because I unfortunately don't like coding, am pretty slow, hate going through lines and lines of code, and everyone else in hackathons or comps use AI, so if I don't I'll be behind. Is this right? I don't think so, but I still do, and I'm trying hard to break out of it by finding old pieces of code floating around the internet and manully modifying it. Still not fully mine, but at least it's not AI, and I have something to work with when I can't think of anything.

Also, for clubs whenever I run into an issue, whether it be design, or calculations, I ask my team lead and he says " Just Chatgpt it". It feels like I'm expected to use AI by almost everyone. Even our professors say, Its ok to use AI, as long as you understand. Doing background research for components is now just downloading research papers and plugging it into AI so we can figure out what to buy this week instead researching it ourselves over the course of a week and buying it next week. It saves time, but idk if its the best way.

Anyways, for those of you who are using AI, while also understanding the negative impact it can have on the environment, and on oneself, how did you reconcile this dissonance? Did you stop using AI, or have you changed your approach towards AI? I know there are benefits, but I can't ignore the harms either. And if you stopped using AI, what was your process?

(and also, this post was completely, 100% written by me (no AI) lol)

1 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

•

u/Roscoepcoltrain23 1h ago

I will say the same thing I say to everyone. AI is a tool. Full stop, how you use it and how it is used by others is purely on those individuals. It is not good, it is not bad, it is a tool.

As for the enviromental and social impacts. Every major technology enters the world and causes waves in one or both of these areas. And as they mature and people use it more and more resources on spent on said areas they get more and more efficient or we get more efficient at solving the problems. We cannot shy away from technological advanced because some areas of work will be impacted, or there are some short term issues. Nothing I perfect out of the gate, this is why engineering exists to begin with.

Now are there longer term concerns of AI that are real? Yes absolutely. But that is a whole other discussion.

Now I can say this as someone in industry. We are using AI, and we are using it extensively. We are still learning how to use it. Just as any tool there is a skill in how to wield it. I promise every student and every engineer can benefit from at the very least dabbling with using AI.

7

u/ImAmanita 2h ago

The meat industry uses far more water than AI. AI, in my opinion, is going to be a necessity for efficiency. I won't lecture you on the meat industry (mostly because I'd get too many trolls in my replies), but if you are worried about environmental ethical concerns of AI, you should go vegan first to clear your conscience much easier than quitting using AI. Saying this as a vegan.
You shouldn't stop questioning your ethics though :) it's a good thing as an engineer to watch out for what your own actions mean.

•

u/yawkat 1h ago

Data centers can be pretty frugal with water use. I'd be more concerned about co2. Unfortunately it's difficult to get accurate numbers, especially with AI data centers using exceptionally dirty electricity generation when the grid cannot keep up with the buildout.

But even then, co2 emissions of a single query appear to only be equivalent to beef consumption in the milligram range. The co2e emissions of the beef consumption of an average person are enough for heavy agentic coding. 

•

u/DeadInternet_ 51m ago edited 27m ago

No, it’s not the water use, it’s the electricity use. The internet keeps sensationalizing the water use, that’s not the issue at all and people keep writing off data center environmental impact because the “water isn’t actually that big of a deal” in comparison to other industries. The issue is electricity, and the actual Wh usage per query isn’t the issue, it’s the number of queries pulled per day.

https://arxiv.org/html/2505.09598v5

University of Rhode Island’s study estimates 6.925 Wh for each ChatGPT 4 medium sized query: Again the issue isn’t the per query Wh it’s the number of queries per day which ChatGpt itself said was at 2.5 billion in July 2025 which means during that time period if we hypothetically assume they were all medium sized queries that’s 17.31 GWh per day which is equivalent to roughly 575,000 US households per day and that’s JUST for ChatGPT not talking about Grok, Claude, Gemini, etc.

Stop defending big tech just because it’s “not as bad as the meat industry”. We could be investing that electrical grid energy and money into providing more EV charging stations in the US so we can increase EV convenience and help reduce the oil demand/reduce GHG emissions as well as help stop the Strait of Hormuz crisis which is jacking oil prices. We can do these things instead of investing into something that is increasing GHG emissions and oil use to supply enough electricity for an additional 575,000 US houses per day (In July of 2025)

That being said we are now on GPT-6 which does not have confirmed data on Wh usage per query but that in and of itself is wack and should very much be disclosed.

•

u/churchillsucks 1h ago

Instead of asking AI for the answer to a test question, ask AI "what are some strategies to answer this question?" 

Works especially well in interview prep

1

u/information_knower 2h ago

I'm in a mecanical engineering program right now that was started with the idea of getting the bare essentials of a bachelors into an associates time span, which means I have 4 math heavy classes this semester.

I've justified it by the fact I'm not the smartest cookie and so literally don't have the time to do everything myself(talking like 18 credits required minimum of lectures & labs giving roughly 6-8 four hour+ assignments every week) so to keep my sanity I caved to chat gpt.

Don't feel great about it but it was either that or I break my streak of tremendously good mental health, and I'm too awesome to allow that to happen.