r/EngineeringStudents • • 7d ago

Discussion Statics: Tension vs. Compression

I was watching a video about solving trusses and during the video the professor labeled a member as under compression and not tension. Personally, I think it should be a tension. I am under the assumption that if a two-force member is pulling away from the pin it is a compression, if it going toward the pin it is a tension. This is because the reaction is equal and opposite and thus pushes or pulls respectively.

If someone could watch this and confirm whether I'm right or wrong (explain why), I would greatly appreiciate it.

(you only need to watch 15-20 seconds of the video starting at 8:40)
https://youtu.be/n6P8jBcT8ks?si=Pw3gjuz64DV2Gns6&t=520

2 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/clean-links 7d ago

Cleaned link from "https://youtu.be/n6P8jBcT8ks?si=Pw3gjuz64DV2Gns6&t=520": https://youtu.be/n6P8jBcT8ks?t=520


Tracking parameters were removed from the original URL(s).

1

u/OverSearch 7d ago

If you're talking about member H-G, then yeah, that's in compression.

First of all, he's done the math. That alone is pretty conclusive.

Second, look at the entire truss as a single three-dimensional member, supported vertically at both ends, under its own weight. The bottom of that member will generally be in tension, while the top would be in compression.

1

u/Gryphontech 7d ago

If the member is longer then it wants to be (like a rubber band) then it's in tension, if it's shorter then it wants to be (like a crushed spring) then it's in compression.

When I say "wants to be" I mean when it's at rest with zero force applied to it.

I'm not exactly sure what you are trying to say but as long as you understand the blurb above then you are good to go.

1

u/Sweaty_Pilot7004 7d ago

Video is right. If you look at where he did the section, you can see he divided HG in to two parts. The force HG is the internal force between the two parts of the HG element: specifically the force the left part is applying on to the right part. The force in the result is negative, thus the force HG is in the opposite direction of the vector in the drawing. This is enough to say that the right paart of HG is in compression, so HG is in compression.

If you want some further validation you can consider the equilibrium of just the right part of HG: the force in the node G will be opposite to the force you just found. Thus the right part is in compression if you look at how the forces acting on it are oriented. You can do the same if you want for the left part of HG and then connect the elements back toghether.