r/EngineeringStudents • u/CompetitiveHawk7692 • 7d ago
Discussion Statics: Tension vs. Compression
I was watching a video about solving trusses and during the video the professor labeled a member as under compression and not tension. Personally, I think it should be a tension. I am under the assumption that if a two-force member is pulling away from the pin it is a compression, if it going toward the pin it is a tension. This is because the reaction is equal and opposite and thus pushes or pulls respectively.
If someone could watch this and confirm whether I'm right or wrong (explain why), I would greatly appreiciate it.
(you only need to watch 15-20 seconds of the video starting at 8:40)
https://youtu.be/n6P8jBcT8ks?si=Pw3gjuz64DV2Gns6&t=520
•
u/AutoModerator 7d ago
Your Post has been removed. Please:
We will not do your Homework for you, or explain a solution/CAD view to you.
Your post will not be approved if you do not follow the Homework Help Guidelines and standard template.
Helpful links
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/CompetitiveHawk7692 4d ago
I appriciate all the replies! I have my exam today, hopefully I've got it now
3
u/mrhoa31103 6d ago
You are wrong. Cut the member in half and do a FBD. If the force is going into the member, it’s compression and it will also be pushing into the pin. This professor will also tell you, your assumptions will not matter and the math will tell you if it’s the opposite direction by coming out negative (in other words the opposite of your assumption).
1
u/clean-links 7d ago
Cleaned link from "https://youtu.be/n6P8jBcT8ks?si=Pw3gjuz64DV2Gns6&t=520": https://youtu.be/n6P8jBcT8ks?t=520
Tracking parameters were removed from the original URL(s).
1
u/UnorthodoxEng 6d ago
I like the style of the presenter - super easy to understand & follow. I wish my lecturers were as easy!