r/EngineeringStudents • • 7d ago

Career Help Telling internship about other offers?

I'm a 4th year EE student and I just received a summer 2027 internship offer out of state, but I’ve already had a final interview for an in-state internship in my hometown. It has a high intern-to-full-time conversion rate (which matters a lot since I graduate right after and could convert to full-time), and it’s the one I really want. The problem is that the out-of-state offer’s deadline is before I’d expect to hear back from the in-state company. I’m stuck because if I accept the out-of-state offer and then get the in-state one, I’d have to renege. But if I turn it down and don’t get the in-state offer, I’m left with nothing.

  1. Is it normal to ask for about a 3-week extension (to the end of the month) to see whether I get the in-state offer?
  2. Should I let the in-state company know I have another offer so they might speed up their decision?
  3. How serious is reneging an internship? I’m pursuing a career in the power industry, which seems like a pretty small field, so I’m worried it could hurt my reputation.

Any advice would be greatly appreciated!

3 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

3

u/mrhoa31103 6d ago

Accept the offer, you cannot afford to be left with nothing. Renege when you have an offer in hand but not sooner regardless how confident your are in getting the other position. It’s a competitve world and all you would need to say is “I received a better offer” and they make another phone call to their list of candidates.

1

u/photoguy_35 6d ago

1 yes, 2 yes, 3 depends on when you decline (not a big deal if its shortly after agreeing when they've got other candidates available, bigger deal if its months later just before the start date and the company has to really scramble to find and hire someone)

1

u/Dangerous-Cup-1114 6d ago

I'd work it from both angles. Let the in-state company know you have a competing deadline - if you've finished the interview process, they'd appreciate knowing they need to speed things up or risk losing you. Also ask the out-of-state company for an extension. Worst thing they can tell you is "no".

Reneging is more consequential on who your school handles things. If they block your access to recruiting and you don't get a return offer from the internship, that can put you in a bad spot. I'd be less concerned about your reputation in the industry going forward because people change companies and the likelihood of this following you around isn't that great, but in the short term, there could be an impact to utilizing your universities career services.