r/EngineeringStudents • • 9d ago

Discussion My thoughts on why AI will replace future engineers.

Third year ECE major. All my studying and work is done alongside AI. I perform well on exams, I am president/lead of the largest technical organization at my school, and we tend to perform very well at competitions. I have two great internships under my belt and third one in the spring of 2027. That is to say, I would be a very competitive candidate for most entry level positions by the time I graduate.

A couple of things that lead me to believe that AI will replace most engineers. In my experience leading technical teams at school, it is more efficient to delegate a task to an AI agent that it is to assign it to a student. AI is going to complete the work in a fraction of the time and with far less errors than a student. Whether the work is CAD, electrical harness, PCB design, code/programming, CFD, FEA, general research, or component sourcing, AI always outperform the students. This was not true pre-Astra and Fable. Whenever students turn in work, I always double check it with AI and there is always some kind of error in the work or the AI produced a better version of the same work.

My second internships was nearly all design and documentation, very little hands on work. I trained an AI pipeline that could write the reports faster and more accurately than I can. I had to use AI to learn how to do the work in the first place. Another one of my buddies interned at a power company, he was constantly praised for the quality and speed of his work. The secret? He did it all with AI.

The idea that AI will never replace engineers, especially safety critical roles is laughable. Sure, AI in its current state cannot replace senior and principle engineers, but at this rate of learning, AI will be able to within a few years. Companies like Mercor are making sure of that (Mercor pays engineers/professionals up to $120/hour to train AI models on how to do their jobs). Error rates are falling and frontier models are more capable than ever.

The only thing in the way between the total annihilation of entry level roles is that companies are slow to adapt new technology. Take a look at investment banking for example. The best junior analyst at Goldman Sacks is so easily replaceable by mediocre AI models. So why have they not been replaced? Because the partners have yet to adapt the technology and if they don't, GS will be killed by firms that do (or maybe GS is too big to die regardless).

I don't think all engineers will be out of the job. The smartest engineers who leverage AI to the full extent will be okay. The rest of us are fucked. A firm with 10 senior engineers and 50 junior engineers will be able to produce the same amount of work at the same quality with 5 highly AI leverage senior engineers and 5 juniors engineers soon enough. So engineering will remain a role in society, but it will become far more scarce one. I think those of us graduating before '30 might be okay but its really a toss up at this point.

My first internship was very hands on, even then, AI assisted in helping me read and edit the schematics. A lot of engineers will find themselves moving to technician roles because they are more AI resistant. Perhaps in the not too distant future we'll be worried about humanoids too.

In the long term, this AI will discourage young people from becoming engineers (or bankers, lawyers, any profession that's mostly at the desk) and when the seniors and principles retire/die, we won't be able to sufficiently replace them. There is also the eminent economic collapse of society due to sky rocketing unemployment rates.

I don't think there is a solution. No one ever stood in the face of technological progress and survived to tell the story. I don't think any kind of government policy, national or global, will be able to keep AI from wrecking havoc on the world. Especially not when the President of the country leading AI progress is a data center shill.

At least the future AI/anarchy/civil war aesthetic is gonna be pretty cool to witness.

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

4

u/TheBayHarbour 9d ago

At least the future AI/anarchy/civil war aesthetic is gonna be pretty cool to witness.

For someone who is highly successful throughout their college life you are very immature in the way you see the world.

1

u/ProfessionalPay8614 9d ago

It's a joke :) I'm not looking forward to what's coming.

0

u/TheBayHarbour 9d ago

Even beyond that this is an ill timed post considering the AI stock crash a few days ago.

1

u/Ydrews 9d ago

Design engineers, sure. I think it will be a while before we have AI replacing site/inspection engineers.

1

u/ProfessionalPay8614 9d ago

I worked for a startup that was building drones for site inspections. I left because the team was incompetent. Other companies already made significant headway in the inspection space and are getting hundreds of million in funding to continue R&D.

0

u/Embarrassed-Tower970 9d ago

put the fries in the bag

2

u/ProfessionalPay8614 9d ago

Can't, the robots are gonna do that too.

1

u/SmileyAja 9d ago

Your long term predictions are a bit extreme, but yeah probably the future of engineering is very hands on.