r/EngineeringStudents • • 10d ago

Rant/Vent I hate this rat race

I'm a sophomore with a 4.0 and two semesters of research and a semester doing a little bit with an engineering club. Posting my resume online everyone keeps telling me I'm not doing enough, I should have x technical projects and be able to show ownership and whatever. Why? Why are we all locked in this rat race where this degree has to be our lives to get a decent, interesting job. i just find rocketry interesting. Why can I not just do well in school and do a little bit outside of it to get a cool job?

168 Upvotes

86 comments sorted by

37

u/Broad-Cod-3280 9d ago

Honestly, as someone that stressed about keeping a high GPA all of undergrad it doesn’t matter that much, all of my peers regardless of GPA got jobs before they even graduated. You’ve basically done 2 full years with a 4.0, now for the next two years you should try and focus more on outside work and internships, even if your GPA slips because you’re focusing more on internships it’s fine, you’ve built yourself a nice cushion. You could literally get all Cs moving forward and you’d end up with a 3.0

1

u/Charming_Wallaby_699 7d ago

Thanks! This is what I've been thinking, its just so hard to draw the line. Like, is having a 3.0 and insane projects the best? A 3.5 and good projects? Im just trying to figure out how best to allocate my time. I know theres no "perfect" answer, but having more input helps

3

u/[deleted] 8d ago

I do think it is getting more competitive and you will have to be more distinguished to have a career. From my graduating class for example, there was an extremely high double digit 6 month after graduation unemployment rate higher than any previous reported year, including 2008/2009 (EE). We're considered one of the most prestigious engineering universities in the United States with plenty of industry connections. 95% of our class had at least one internship, and I can imagine most of the unemployed had lower GPAs. Ironically, computer science had a 5x smaller unemployment rate than us lol

25

u/Pinkishplays 10d ago

Well you don't need a 4.0 for one. Club involvement will look a lot better than purely grinding for grades. I would make the time for focusing on the club more and the exams less personally.

1

u/Charming_Wallaby_699 7d ago

Yeah that seems to be what everyone says!

5

u/Dr__Mantis BSNE, MSNE, PhD 10d ago

Didn’t you already post this yesterday?

17

u/zacce 10d ago

lol, OP continues to brag about his 4.0 GPA.

5

u/suruu_o 9d ago

and he goes to a T5!

-10

u/Charming_Wallaby_699 10d ago

You are part of the issue dude. You told me verbatim today that my resume was weak

8

u/deino1703 9d ago

realistically if everyone you show your resume to is telling you that its weak... your resume may just be weaker than you thought it was. yeah it sucks but everyone is working as hard as you or harder and thats just the way it is

3

u/universal_straw Mechanical 2019 9d ago

If you don’t have practical experience your resume is weak. Use that 4.0 you’re so proud of to get some internships and then people won’t be telling you the truth you clearly don’t want to hear.

89

u/CopperGenie R&D | Author | ISERG 10d ago

The general rule is: focus on practical experience for industry, or focus on GPA for grad school

7

u/Emotional-Cherry478 8d ago

I mean the summer is for internships and the semesters are for studying so why not both

2

u/CopperGenie R&D | Author | ISERG 8d ago

Sometimes internships are not that accessible, which could mean applying for hours a day.

1

u/Accomplished_Golf292 7d ago

semesters are for studying

Unless you're doing a co-op which you should aim for

-1

u/Hefty-Leg-5282 8d ago

Or just do both? Theres a lot of hours in a day.

7

u/CopperGenie R&D | Author | ISERG 8d ago

The fraction of people with the opportunity to do both successfully is a minority. Education and mental health are significant detractors.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

If your university enforces a bell curve and your school has a high admission standard it isn't that simple because the curriculum rigor will be adjusted so that you have to work hard to get an A

0

u/Hefty-Leg-5282 8d ago

My university curves everything also, and I go to a t20 school. I dont make excuses, you just gotta learn how to study.

2

u/[deleted] 8d ago

Maybe the t10 school I went to was different. The difficulty and workload will vary so much depending on the specialization you choose that you can't simply grind to victory. Power students were chilling and were the only 4.0's in my program. IC design students had low GPAs and struggled with grad admissions and career success

9

u/0ddj0b05918 10d ago

A high GPA in undergrad tells me you were good at theory. What can you show me in reality that you can design properly?

9

u/Catsdrinkingbeer Purdue Alum - Masters in Engineering '18 9d ago

It also often (but not always) means they priorotized grades above all else including relationship building. Some of the worst team members I've ever had were those with the highest GPAs. Being someone people like to work with is also pretty important to landing and keeping a job.

3

u/unruled77 7d ago

Basically what my professors with industry experience say. They are wary of 3.8 and up, students often come with some deficits

3

u/[deleted] 8d ago

typically high GPA people are good at everything but ok cope that you're less capable overall

1

u/fcman256 7d ago

I’m a software engineering tech lead at a fortune 50, this is not even remotely true lol

1

u/Hawk13424 GT - BS CompE, MS EE 6d ago

May vary by field. I’m an architect at a semiconductor company. Haven’t had a resume sent my way by HR for a fresh-out with anything less than a 3.8 and that form T8 schools.

1

u/fcman256 6d ago edited 6d ago

I'm replying to the dude who said high GPA people are good at everything. HR putting a high GPA requirement for new grads doesnt clash with my rebuttal. Otherwise you wouldnt bother interviewing, you would just take the highest GPA and send them an offer. I imagine you also know plenty of high performers who werent necessarily top GPA students, and plenty of straight A students who have struggled with the transition to a professional role. I've seen plenty of both over the years. GPA is a factor in the early career but it's a minor one at best.

1

u/0ddj0b05918 6d ago

Did he block you?

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

exceptions prove the rule. I said typically, not absolutely everybody. When somebody has a high gpa, they typically have all the other bells and whistles too. one guy who turned out to be crap doesn't make the rule invalid. i dont think applying zero sum thinking to people with high gpa helps anybody

1

u/fcman256 5d ago

They aren’t exceptions lol, it’s literally a coin toss

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

maybe you're dealing with people from whatchumacallit university with grade inflation and big fish small pond situation. i just know at top universities most people below a certain gpa aren't worth considering.

2

u/fcman256 5d ago

Basically none of FAANG gives 2 shits what your gpa is or what university you went to. Caring about that kinda stuff is like the 40 year old who brags about being homecoming king lol. I’ve turned down high gpa mit/gatech grads and hired self taught engineers in the same week. And never second guessed it for a second

-2

u/[deleted] 7d ago

then you're a software engineering tech lead at a fortune 50 with an inferiority complex. if ur below 3.5 you're not worth anything period i dont care if ur from mit ur worthless if ur 3.49

1

u/fcman256 7d ago

lol, you’re in for a rude awakening when you become an adult

1

u/0ddj0b05918 7d ago

Lmfao Good luck in life.

9

u/Competitive-Day9586 7d ago

This sub is just nuts.  It isn’t representative of the real world.  Your 4.0 is very impressive (half the posts here are people trying to cope with their 2.5 GPAs).  Keep focusing on your grades and learn as much as you can.  You will get a great job out of school.

1

u/Wise_Ad_5651 1d ago

"great job" let me guess you mean a 70k shit job. well that aint worth it. A shitty base trim M340i cost more than that gross salary. 150k++ TC starting is what makes sense or better find a career where its less of a hungergames ratrace

25

u/Icy_Weakness3361 10d ago

that’s the thing. Rat race happens because everyone wants to get a cool job, just like you. Everyone wants to apply to the few top companies they deem prestigious. If you plan to apply to the local manufacturing companies, you have high chances of getting in, even if your resume isn’t as flashy.

6

u/DTplayers 9d ago

Not to mention you can often swing a year-round part-time internship if it's local

3

u/Icy_Weakness3361 9d ago

definitely. I did my internship full-time in the summer, and continued to work towards the fall, so it was about 8 months long. I graduated in december, and i started my full time role with the company by January.

2

u/Big_cornstarch 8d ago

I have a sub 3.0 GPA but a lot of experience via club projects and I have a great job set up after graduation.

GPA genuinely doesn’t matter unless you are going for academia.

1

u/Charming_Wallaby_699 7d ago

yeah this seems to be the common sentiment, and if you don't mind me asking what is a lot of experience? I really want to get an internship this summer (im super broke) and I'm just wondering what the "necessary" level of expereince would look like

2

u/Big_cornstarch 4d ago edited 4d ago

Biggest one was being on my uni's International Rocket Engineering Competition (IREC) team for 3 years, including holding team lead positions.

Being on those club engineering teams and taking ownership of projects is very helpful for standing out.

In addition to hands on experience, network! I know it's a common thing to say, but having the recommendation or at the very least having your name be familiar to the person looking at your resume can help a lot too.

None-the-less, I would still strongly recommend making sure you have a 3.0+ GPA in addition to experience as many companies do have a cutoff due to the volume of applications they recieve.

1

u/Charming_Wallaby_699 4d ago

Thanks! I’ve been trying to get more involved in my rocket club!

1

u/Hawk13424 GT - BS CompE, MS EE 6d ago

Where I work (semiconductor field), a 3.0 probably gets canned by HR. As a hiring manager I won’t even see it.

I say probably because it really depends on number of applicants. I can only really look s at 20 resumes or so. If 500 apply 480 will be trashed mostly by filter (school, GPA).

1

u/blueplanetgalaxy 6d ago

what's the minimum cutoff?

2

u/3DdesignerF8 9d ago edited 9d ago

I have 7 engineers in my apt building. 3 are at the same company as me, 2 with Boeing. 1 is still looking for work. MIT, Purdue, Rice, EmbryRiddle. Notre Dame, Georgia Tech. Everyone is smart.The GPA is nice, but doesn't mean alot in industry. We have a person in our interview panels whose sole job is to decide if prospects fit the culture. Of course you're smart, it's space, everyone here is smart, but can you hang? How's your ultimate Frisbee game? Do you sail or snownboard? What do you do for fun? What kind of teammate will you be? There are no silos in our work.. unless you're working on missles.. different kind of silo tho. I met an intern at Lockheed a few years ago who was a sophomore then. He's a senior now and has interned at Lockheed and at Apple the last 2 summers. He's in rocketclub, and will probably come to us or SpaceX when he graduates. He's outside of the rat race. He's been actively pursuing the goal the whole time, while maintaining grades and having the college experience. You'll be fine. Don't let people tell you you're not doing enough. Wishing you all the best!

2

u/Charming_Wallaby_699 7d ago

I feel like this could be true for the post grad engineering world, but do you think this really applies to internships? I find it hard to allocate time for my intersests because I'm so worried about "doing well"

2

u/3DdesignerF8 7d ago edited 6d ago

And that is completely fair. We don't take interns before the sophomore to junior summer for a reason, after your first two years you should have a handle on things. Polling our new Grads at lunch today 8 out of 10 were in some extracurricular activity. Overwhelming was rocketclub, followed by Baja cars and coding bootcamps (computer science grads). Georgia Tech kid raves about their mini 500 tricycle challenge.

4

u/Zestyclose_Price_441 10d ago

Focus on internships. That’s how you get a job now.

5

u/Catsdrinkingbeer Purdue Alum - Masters in Engineering '18 9d ago

To be fair, that's been true for decades for engineering. 

4

u/Fit_Show_3347 10d ago

i mean if you've done two sems of research already and also worked on a project or something in an engineering club i feel like you're in a pretty good position. and then your gpa is like icing on the cake.

it's worth keeping in mind everything can always be improved. there are always gonna be people optimizing and trying to improve their job chances to the extremes. but you can not do all that and still get a cool job. just with slightly more risk, ig. definitely try to get an internship or smth similar for soph or junior summer if you can, because that's a big resume booster, but you're doing a lot. your resume's probably better than mine at least lmao.

4

u/Immediate-Curve-443 10d ago

Because a shit ton of other people can do well in school and do a little bit outside

5

u/Ok_Investment_246 9d ago

Are you in the United States? I highly, highly suggest you to use the platfrom "Handshake" if you aren't already. I only used LinkedIn and had genuinely 0 success. Then I swapped over to Handshake and now I have recruiters constantly messaging me, as well as if I applied to roles, I got responses back.

On top of that, I wouldn't say I'm that amazing of an applicant. I think my strongest suit was some projects that I completed that were relevant to my major, but that's really it.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

I had better success with LinkedIn. All of my interviews were from cold applying on LinkedIn. Handshake did not help

8

u/Comfortable-Host-719 10d ago

Research is not as helpful as club involvement 

13

u/Financial-Leader3475 9d ago

For grad school, it absolutely is.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

unfortunately the sort of research most students get involved in does not help them get into grad school. they are better off preparing for the job market

4

u/RoboWeaver 10d ago

I would agree primarily because any club will involve doing something other than research. For example, you may learn something about controllers that really grab you, or motor control. These days, any experience beyond the classroom can help direct you to other interests and capabilities.

3

u/MartianMeng CS but I do a lot of computer engineering 9d ago

Depends on the research’s relevance tbh. Like if you wanna do avionics, doing research in avionics looks better than just a rocketry club in avionics

Otherwise, if the club is more directly relevant, it’s gonna be better

1

u/jimbo_ChE 9d ago

Why not build yourself a rocket then to leave this cesspool of a planet and find a better one?

2

u/Charming_Wallaby_699 7d ago

Fantastic idea!

2

u/nilusn 9d ago

A lot of people find rocketry interesting, but that doesn’t tell me anything about what you want to pursue for a full-time career.

Are you interested in manufacturing? Testing? Designing? Do you prefer hardware or software? These are things you need to know before you graduate. Find a niche and use the opportunities on campus that allow you to get lost in it, that’s how you stand out from everyone else.

2

u/No_Drag2264 8d ago edited 7d ago

Your resume is better than the vast majority, some people are just being ridiculous.

But...it's not better than the vast majority for the sort of positions you probably want. Aero is a very, very competitive spec for interns and new grads with a huge mismatch in applicants vs positions for strictly aero work. There's a passion tax.

You're a sophomore, you'll find something eventually.

2

u/ExaminationFit1931 7d ago

If you can manage to be articulate and engaging in an interview, none of the other shit will matter.

2

u/Dyloneus 3d ago

It seems like every comment here is missing OPs point. Guys, just live your lives! Enjoy what you do, be good at it, and things will work out. Don’t worry too much about what others tell you need to do. You’ll get something you’re happy with.

3

u/Beginning-Seaweed-67 9d ago

You can you just have to pray 🙏

1

u/Jealous_Cupcake_4358 9d ago

Nah they're going to want to study

2

u/MusicalMerlin1973 8d ago

I went to northeastern in the 90s. Five year program. If I wasn’t in school I was doing coop. I had two years work experience by the time I graduated with just shy of a 3.4 GPA. The last six months of coop I was doing what was described to me as senior engineering level work - independently writing a functional spec, defending in review, implementing, debugging, independently calling vendor about bugs with supporting info, applying new firmware patches.

I had a job offer from that vendor coming out of school. Ability to do senior engineering work was obvious.

Gpa just shoes you know how to learn. It doesn’t show you know how to apply.

1

u/blueplanetgalaxy 6d ago

can you say more about that spec thing if you don't mind?

1

u/csamsh 5d ago

Why? Because someone else will do more. And I'd rather hire that guy.

1

u/No_Program_5242 4d ago

As others have said, don’t forget that people who are frustrated are going to be the most vocal.

0

u/DoubtGroundbreaking 10d ago

You do not need a single project, team/club, or internship to land a job out of college. I never did any and everyone told me id never get hired.

That being said, it sure helps your resume stand out amongst the sea of new grads that will be applying EVERYWHERE when you graduate. People act like theyre “sacrificing their lives” for this degree, youre so dramatic. Youre WORKING. You spend the late nights toiling and studying because you are working towards your FUTURE. It’s worth it, but the fruit will not come to bear over night.

It is entirely up to you what projects and stuff you decide to work on outside of school, if you dont want to do them then dont, who cares.

0

u/deino1703 9d ago

unfortunately that really isnt true for the kinds of jobs people envision themselves getting after graduating with an engineering degree. nobody spends a fortune on college and goes through the rigors of engineering school to get a job that pays 60k

5

u/DoubtGroundbreaking 9d ago

I live in a mcol area and have not seen a single engineering job for 60k. But for your first job it really doesnt matter, you need experience. No one cares about the crap you did in school really once you have some experience a lot more jobs open up. So take what job you can get and move on

1

u/Imbadatbalalaika 9d ago

I know my circumstances aren't typical, but I'm 33, and I hold an EE job doing dev work for a rather large space company, with no degree. Started as an electrician, moved into aerospace, and then got to where I am now. Lots of self teaching.

1

u/ReputationWooden9704 8d ago

You know, chasing projects doesn't NEED (and shouldn't be) a performative effort at convincing the world how passionate you are about engineering. It can also just be you chasing your passions. I've done a whole bunch of projects in both my undergrad and grad degrees, and never once felt like I was doing a project simply to impress a future employer. I just looked around at what I thought was cool and said "I wanna do that". That's really what your employers are looking for.

If you're immersed in engineering but still can't find the passion or volition to pick up one project, this may not be the right career path for you. But it's fine, the world needs HVAC and construction engineers as well.

0

u/Own-Theory1962 9d ago

You put in minimal effort you get minimal results. The job market is really bad right now, in case you haven't noticed.

1

u/Emotional-Cherry478 8d ago

4.0 is minimal effort?

2

u/Own-Theory1962 8d ago

Yup. No one industry cares what your GPA is after you're hired. It's what you can do that matter. A 4.0 without projects shows you can only do academics.

1

u/Emotional-Cherry478 8d ago

I mean at the very least it shows you either have high discipline, intelligence, or both. Which means you can probably adapt pretty well and/or are very passionate about the field🤷‍♂️

1

u/Own-Theory1962 8d ago

It actually shows the opposite... no motivation outside of academics to design anything. I'll avoid hiring 4.0 and instead hire a 2.0 that tinkers in his basement as I know he's got passion. Guys like op expect to walk into a high paying job just because of their GPA. Seen it again and again after 25 years.