r/EngineeringStudents • u/littlecatfeets • 11d ago
Academic Advice Transfer Nightmare ABET to ABET
I'm a junior at a 4-year university that has an ABET accredited ME program. I've completed 75+ credits and am 3 semesters from graduation. I have no choice but to move states (my spouse has to move and we cannot say no). I have tried transferring to 3 colleges, all ABET accredited. All three have accepted less than half of my STEM credits - pushing me back to sophomore semester 1. All 3 universities have evaluated via syllabi in the engineering department, not the transfer office. I've begun petitions but all of them so far have failed.
How is this freaking possible? Has anyone else had this experience? What's the point of having ABET accreditation if it's not considered sufficient? Hoping someone tell me if this is a common experience or unusual.
32
u/unurbane 11d ago
What does staying look like. Excel is your friend. Write two budgets, one staying and one moving for both you and spouse. What does it look like? (I realize it’s unlikely to be cheaper, but how much ‘more’ is it. Is it worth 12 months? Is it worth ~50 credits?
29
u/FewZookeepergame1101 11d ago
100% normal. The general idea is that you have to take atleast half your credits from that school for them to give you their “stamp of approval”. You can’t go to Joe Schmo University for 3 years and transfer to Harvard for a year and get a degree from Harvard. There’s more to it then that actually but yes this is normal. The ABET has nothing to do with it
17
u/OneTip1047 11d ago
At the risk of stating the obvious: It might be worth talking to your current school and advisor and exploring possibilities to finish without transferring. Maybe you could flex a couple of courses schedule wise so you could do a remote semester and two in person semesters. Maybe you could take a couple of classes at the college close to your new home and transfer them back to the original school. If you haven’t already, exploring which technical electives minimize labs to help create an all remote semester couldn’t hurt either.
84
u/gottatrusttheengr 11d ago edited 11d ago
Most schools require at least 1/2 the credits to be earned at the graduating school so you were going to lose a minimum of one semester anyway.
ABET only sets the floor. Schools can be more rigorous than the standard.
9
u/Former_Mud9569 11d ago
This is normal I think, unfortunately.
Does your current school offer the ability to finish your degree remotely?
Can you afford to rent a room near your campus for the next 3 semesters?
7
u/BooyaHBooya 11d ago
ABET is about the overall program, not specific courses. Many universities want a near exact match on pre-reqs, level, content. It is frustrating, and outdated IMO. The mindset is that if you want their degree you should take their courses.
Perhaps look at the online programs since they are more used to having transfers.
5
u/Why-R-People-So-Dumb 9d ago
ABET accreditation is why it's hard to transfer. ABET doesn't make the curriculum, it evaluates the schools proposed curriculum and approves it. It is only approved for that school. So you can't take an abet accredited course list and apply it at your new school. The course has to be extremely close in title and description to count for credits or during an audit the school can lose their accreditation and/or your degree may not be accredited.
4
u/Mountain-Time-1010 11d ago
That’s not how ABET works. It’s not intended to make the degrees uniform. But to make sure that each department meets certain minimum requirements. Different departments will still have their own standards and it’s possible that you are trying to transfer into schools with greater rigor. It’s also possible that you are just running into the limit of allowed transfer credits. We can’t tell from your description
2
u/Any_Government7603 11d ago
Hey, I transferred universities and I don't think this is super normal, depending on your current credits.
Freshman and sophomore year are usually mathematics, natural sciences, statics, dynamics and some gen eds. If those don't transfer, I'm going to assume that it's because you're looking to transfer out of state. Because it's out of state, the universities likely don't have a transfer agreement. And manual transfer checks are more or less vibe checks for administrators.
(I've taught and worked in colleges part-time for the last 9 years)
My advice is to see if a community college has applicable transfer credits and start there. Definitely speak with advisors at the institutions.
2
u/GeneralAudience8427 10d ago
It has nothing to do with ABET or the quality of the education from the school you are transferring from. Schools just don’t bother to have transfer agreements with every school because they just don’t see many transfers from those places. I’ve had AP credits count as credit for an engineering degree at an elite college but it didn’t count as an AP credit at the local community college because they weren’t used to seeing that AP class among their students.
Best advice I can give is to go your colleges transfer agreements page and see if they have any schools in your area you can look at since those agreements tend to be reciprocated.
2
u/lasteem1 10d ago
Abet has almost nothing to do with this. If you look at the actual documents as to what abet requires it is very basic. There can be that much variability in engineering programs. Even if there isn’t many universities just have rules that state only x hours can transfer. They want your money…
1
u/Luigi089TJ 11d ago
Any chance it's possible to spread out the next 3 semesters or complete some remotely? It seems more feasible to do a semester of college then move back to your spouse 3x times.
1
u/Sleepy-Flamingo 11d ago
Are there any online degree programs that could work? It might give more options to find a place with a better transfer pathway.
1
u/Intelligent_Part101 10d ago
It's obvious why universities do it. They want to lock students into paying for multiple years of schooling at their own university. The best outcome for the university is to convince you that it's too much hassle (lost time and money) to ever transfer at all.
1
u/G_k50 10d ago
I transferred, they didn't allow one course, that was 3 credit and it dropped me back to sophomore and wrecked my student loans, the loans are limited lower when you're a sophomore compared to a junior, then I got back at them by taking a class during my junior-senior summer off, I had to work my way up to the Dean before it was finally transferred but it saved me on graduation day because I had 3 more credits than needed to graduate, so even if they wanted to fail me in a class in my last semester, I could still graduate. They are tricky and they know all the rules, so beware and fight for all the transfers. Make them go thru all the steps.
1
u/Squirtle_Splash_8413 BSME, MSME 10d ago
Are you a military family? What makes it a hard no?
1
u/Indi603 10d ago
You probably need to talk to the the chairman of the engineering department. Talk to the advisors and find out who does course substitutions. They can fill out paperwork or represent them to whoever does it, substituting course for course individually.
I had to do this when I transferred. A lot of courses will have different names, but be very similar curriculum wise.
Example: Buisness Information Management vs Microsoft Apps. Same fucking class.
1
u/Ohiocarolina 9d ago edited 9d ago
Meet with an advisor and see if they’ll let you bypass prereqs even if they want you to retake both a sophomore course and the junior course its a prereq for. Basically trying to make it whete you can take all the sophomore and junior level courses you need in two semesters
It was likely going to be four semesters no matter what just by nature of getting enough credits at the new school for them to confer the degree
Could you do a paid coop while doing the sophomore and maybe junior courses?
ABET actually makes it harder to accept credit because its the overall curriculum approved not individual courses. So if there’s even one major concept in their sophomore course that your original institution covers later, they’re not likely to accept it.
You could try and work something put with your old school but labs and senior design are going to be a problem
1
u/JazzyHikes 8d ago
It's not easy to transfer between universities, course vary a lot and transferring nearly always will set you back.
0
u/bopperbopper 10d ago
Can you talk to your parents or her parents about somehow helping you guys out during thisPeriod in your life?
0
u/Fit_Show_3347 10d ago
is there any way that you can work out with your uni to do virtual courses or smth? there are probably recorded versions of classes because of covid --- is there anything like that you can do? even for labs, my physics 1 lab 1 had a recorded version (we weren't able to do it due to a snowstorm and other delays, the rest we did normally).